Helmand civilians caught between the Taliban and a hard place

Local Afghan population weighs up the price of security in the face of injuries and deaths caused by Nato forces

UK pays £1.3m in compensation to Afghan civilians

Loi Lala's children were playing inside their home in Nowa district when stray bullets from British heavy weapons smashed into the building.

According to Lala, a 60-year-old businessman , British forces nearby had managed to confuse a crowd watching fishermen using an electricity generator to stun river fish with a gathering of insurgents.

A five-year-old girl was killed and two other children were left disabled.

Apart from the suffering caused to civilians, mistakes like this risk turning the Afghan population against the coalition forces. "The foreigners came to me and said they were very sorry because you are responsible for the security of our convoys," Lala said. Nato provided helicopters to race the children to hospital and the equivalent of £1,370 in the local currency.

"They asked for forgiveness and the elders also asked me to forgive," he said. "They were children, they were not Taliban, but I know they were shot by mistake. I have no education, but I know you need weapons to bring security."

Perhaps because of the importance of the British and American presence in Helmand to his livelihood – Lala profits from contracts to provide armed security to convoys that ferry vital supplies to military bases all over Helmand – he was prepared to forgive. On top of the compensation payment for the children, foreign forces also gave him a contract to build a bridge worth more than $8,000.

But for others, receiving compensation can be a drawn-out process. Several people in different Helmand districts complained that payments are frequently seized by tribal elders and power brokers before they can get to the right people.

According to Haji Mirza Khan, an attack on his family's house in Babaji killed two of his brothers, and wounded him and women and children. "It was an airstrike from a plane," he said. "We don't know what they were thinking or what intelligence they had."

It took a couple of trips to the provincial capital of Lashkar Gah and lobbying government officials before, he said: "The English people came and said we are very sorry, please forgive us." But he added: "We still haven't got the money."

Babaji has seen regular conflict ever since British forces launched Operation Panther's Claw in 2009, with many families having to abandon their homes to find safer places to live. But for the family of Abdul Nasir Janan, a 38-year-old labourer, the fighting simply followed them to their new home on the outskirts of Lashkar Gah about a year and a half ago.

His two brothers, Ghafar and Rabani, were killed by an airstrike by a "computer plane", as he calls the unmanned drones that are constantly busy above the skies of Helmand. A third man, a cousin, who had fled the fighting in his home district of Musa Qala, was also killed. The missile left behind carnage: the bodies of the victims were blown apart, with some of the bodies unrecognisable.

"The governor and the police chief came to us and asked us to forgive. The British came and said that they were very sorry but on their computer they thought they killed Taliban," Janan said.

His family received $4,000 for each man killed and $1,000 for each person injured.

Contributor

Jon Boone

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Afghan civilians reported killed in Helmand air strike
Claims of 12 children among dead after attack ordered when US marines reportedly came under fire while on patrol

Jason Burke in Kabul

29, May, 2011 @5:28 PM

Article image
British troops plan larger role in Helmand to cover US withdrawal
UK armed forces to patrol larger area in southern Afghan province but a return to Sangin ruled out

Nick Hopkins

07, Nov, 2011 @5:59 PM

Article image
The Taliban spring offensive - civilians count the cost
No major offensive has accompanied the resumption of widescale fighting but it has not stopped civilian casualties rising markedly

John Wendle in Kabul

01, May, 2013 @1:58 PM

Article image
Pakistan president says US-led war against Taliban is being lost
Asif Ali Zardari says Nato coalition should replace its current approach with a long-term strategy to win over the Afghan people

Simon Tisdall and Haroon Siddique

03, Aug, 2010 @7:39 PM

From Newry to Helmand, the lessons are the same | Simon Jenkins
Simon Jenkins: Had Monday's car bomb exploded in London it would have been inflated into a terrorist atrocity, fuel for the Afghan war

Simon Jenkins

23, Feb, 2010 @8:00 PM

Article image
British and US troops to launch new Afghanistan offensive
Announcement of operation to wrest Helmand areas from Taliban control comes on eve of peace talks in London

Julian Borger and Richard Norton-Taylor

25, Jan, 2010 @9:01 PM

Article image
Nato deaths raise tension over Afghanistan strategy | Nick Hopkins
Nick Hopkins: After a recent series of incidents, opinion in Afghanistan and the west is hardening towards an accelerated withdrawal

Nick Hopkins

26, Mar, 2012 @1:02 PM

Airstrikes kill more than 60 Taliban fighters in Helmand

No civilian casualties reported after Afghan army bomb convoy armed with mortar weapons

Sam Jones and agencies

12, Oct, 2008 @11:01 PM

British forces greet US help in Helmand
UK commander of Nato forces in south Afghanistan says move can allow British to concentrate on helping the most populated towns

Richard Norton-Taylor

08, Jan, 2010 @2:41 AM

Article image
Nato will send 5,000 more troops to Afghanistan, says Brown
PM paves way for US troop surge in Afghanistan, saying he has assurances from Nato countries

Patrick Wintour, political editor

25, Nov, 2009 @8:02 PM