Biden, Trump – and two very different classified document scandals

At first glance, both presidents appear to have similarly bungled the handling of documents – but here’s how the two cases differ

The discovery of classified documents in offices used by Joe Biden’s thinktank and in a locked storage unit in a garage near where the president keeps his Corvette may not be a criminal matter, but it does appear to have taken a political toll.

With a new Reuters/Ipsos poll on Thursday finding that Biden’s approval rating, which had risen at the end of 2022, was back down to just 40% – near the lowest level of his presidency – many Democrats are smacking their foreheads, fearing Biden has done exactly what his expected 2024 opponent, Donald Trump, was under investigation for doing.

So much for painting Trump as dangerous, volatile and a threat to national security. Right?

But that’s not to say the two cases are the same. The scale of the scandals is hugely lopsided: thousands of documents in Trump’s possession, including many marked top secret, versus an estimated dozen in Biden’s.

Crucially for justice department investigators, led by the special counsels appointed by the attorney general, Merrick Garland, the actions of the two presidents are also vastly different.

Trump declared his intent to take documents, refused to hand them back, had to be raided by the FBI to secure the records, then fought authorities in court for months.

Biden’s team handed the documents back voluntarily.

Here is a breakdown of how the two cases are similar – and how, in major ways, they are different.

Interactive

Biden, 80, is expected to launch another run for the White House, perhaps as soon as next month, after he delivers the State of the Union address on 7 February.

Republicans in Congress have slammed the president regarding when the documents were discovered – before the midterms – claiming Biden was not forthcoming about such potentially politically sensitive discoveries.

But the Reuters/Ipsos poll results suggest it isn’t just Biden whose ratings are down as a result of various scandals in Washington.

Only 20% of respondents said they approved of the House speaker, Kevin McCarthy, the top elected Republican, while just 35% said they had a favorable view of the House as a whole and 38% approved of the Senate.

In that light, Biden’s head appears to be just above water. He must be hoping no more classified documents emerge to push him back below.

Contributors

Chris Michael, Andrew Witherspoon and Richard Luscombe

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Classified documents: how do the Trump and Biden cases differ?
The president and his predecessor have each retained secret papers but what do we know and what happens next?

Richard Luscombe

12, Jan, 2023 @4:52 PM

Article image
Why prosecutors might get Trump – and not Biden – for classified documents
Trump’s situation is more perilous because of his reluctance to cooperate and his suspected obstruction of justice

Hugo Lowell in Washington

03, Feb, 2023 @7:00 AM

Article image
In the case of the classified documents, it’s more serious for Trump than Biden
The former president’s retention of papers at Mar-a-Lago appears to satisfy more criteria for prosecution than the find at Biden’s institute

Hugo Lowell in Washington

11, Jan, 2023 @10:00 AM

Article image
Biden, Trump and the classified documents – podcast
The discovery of batches of classified documents on Joe Biden’s property presents a headache for the president – but his case is quite different from that of Donald Trump, reports David Smith in Washington

Presented by Michael Safi with David Smith; produced by Tom Glasser and Solomon King; executive producer Phil Maynard

20, Jan, 2023 @3:00 AM

Article image
Campaign funds used to pay Biden legal bills in classified documents inquiry
President’s campaign has attacked Trump for using donations to pay his numerous legal bills – but Biden used funds similarly

Martin Pengelly in Washington

12, Apr, 2024 @2:55 PM

Article image
Friday briefing: What to know about the Trump and Biden document stories – and why they’re very different
In today’s newsletter: Both the current and previous president of the United States are under investigation over classified documents – but their cases are very different

Archie Bland

03, Feb, 2023 @6:58 AM

Article image
Special counsel delivers Trump a Biden attack line on a silver platter
The president won’t face criminal charges in classified documents case, but the line he is an ‘elderly man with a poor memory’ will linger

David Smith in Washington

09, Feb, 2024 @12:13 AM

Article image
Biden blames Trump’s ‘web of lies’ for US Capitol attack in first anniversary speech – as it happened
In scathing speech, Biden says Trump ‘tried to prevent a peaceful transfer of power as a violent mob breached the Capitol’

Maanvi Singh (now) and Vivian Ho (earlier)

07, Jan, 2022 @12:33 AM

Article image
Biden campaign calls Trump ‘weak and desperate’ after New York court hearing
Spokesperson for president notes Trump’s Jesus comparisons and lack of campaign events and says US ‘deserves better’

Martin Pengelly in Washington

26, Mar, 2024 @1:27 PM

Article image
With Trump in trouble, Republicans step up assault on DoJ and FBI
Critics say party that touted its law-and-order credentials now intent on wrecking institutions that get in Donald Trump’s way

David Smith Washington bureau chief

08, Jul, 2023 @11:00 AM