Third Democratic debate: 11 things we learned

Bernie Sanders apologized, Martin O’Malley was aggressive and Hillary Clinton was strong on foreign policy and tax. And yes, she closed with a Star Wars line

The third Democratic debate is in the bag. Here’s what we learned.

  • The debate was a spirited but polite exchange, with a mix of camaraderie and some sharper jabs when the candidates wanted to draw a contrast. They fielded questions on foreign policy, taxes, Wall Street, healthcare, gun control and war.
  • Former secretary of state Hillary Clinton and Vermont senator Bernie Sanders turned in strong performances, sticking to the issues and drawing some clear distinctions between them.
  • Martin O’Malley struggled to make a mark, alternately attacking his rivals, especially Clinton, and sprinkling self-praise with anecdotes from his time as Baltimore mayor and Maryland governor.
  • Sanders apologized for a campaign staffer who breached data of Clinton’s campaign, and the strange political spat that briefly caused Democrats to suspend Sanders from a vital database was quickly resolved.
  • Clinton and Sanders argued at length about military intervention abroad. Sanders said the US cannot be “the world’s policeman” and should make Saudi Arabia and other Muslim countries lead the fight against jihadi militants. Clinton said the US needs to walk the “rough road” of both promoting democracy while working with the autocrats of the Middle East. All agreed the US should not send ground troops en masse back to the region.
  • O’Malley and Clinton badgered Sanders over his guns voting record, noting that he had voted for measures supported by the gun lobby in the past. Sanders acknowledged that he had moved away from those positions in light of recent shootings, and scolded O’Malley: “Do not tell me that I have not shown courage to the gun people.”
  • Sanders and O’Malley promised to break up the banks, and Clinton said she thinks “everybody”, including the middle class, corporations and Wall Street, should love her. “They ain’t gonna like me,” Sanders said of the latter two, even though he granted some decent companies do exist. Everybody wanted to increase wages and ensure fair pay for women.
  • All three candidates got into heated disputes over taxes and how the US would pay for lower education and healthcare costs, with Clinton ruling out any tax hikes on the middle class. Sanders refused to do so, arguing that a marginal increase would be offset by savings. He also proposed a tax on speculative finance.
  • Clinton said US tech companies should cooperate with law enforcers who want greater access to their data. O’Malley said the US shouldn’t sacrifice civil liberties but maybe those tech companies should volunteer the data anyway.
  • Republican frontrunner Donald Trump came up repeatedly, as did his proposed ban on Muslims entering the US. Clinton said Isis militants are showing videos of Donald Trump to recruit fighters, Sanders said Trump played on hate and fear to distract Americans from the divisions in the US, and O’Malley talked about “the fascist pleas of billionaires with big mouths”.
  • The candidates managed to get a few laughs. Sanders shouted “my name was invoked”, alluding to the debate rules, and teased his rivals’ self-promotion tactics: “I’ll advertise my website as well.” Clinton went topical, closing her remarks with: “May the Force be with you.”

Contributor

Alan Yuhas

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Democratic debate: candidates face off on foreign policy in light of Paris attacks
Lively debate drew heated contention between candidates on national security as Sanders and O’Malley questioned Clinton’s ‘weak tea’ financial reform plan

Dan Roberts and Sabrina Siddiqui in Des Moines, Iowa

15, Nov, 2015 @5:19 AM

Article image
Democratic debate in Des Moines: 12 things we learned
The candidates honored the victims of the Paris attacks then clashed on what to do about Isis … and Martin O’Malley took a memorable swipe at the Donald

Tom McCarthy in New York

15, Nov, 2015 @2:24 PM

Article image
Brooklyn Democratic debate: eight things we learned
Hillary Clinton and Bernie Sanders came out firing over banking and continued to trade jabs over guns, Israel and Palestine, and a $15 minimum wage

Tom McCarthy in New York

15, Apr, 2016 @11:33 AM

Article image
What we learned from the fourth Democratic presidential debate
Hillary Clinton and Bernie Sanders’s uneasy truce has split, and the candidates are all divided on the issue of healthcare

Alan Yuhas

18, Jan, 2016 @5:06 AM

Article image
Democratic debate: after Sanders' apology, candidates spar on Isis, taxes and guns – as it happened
Follow along as Clinton, Sanders and O’Malley square off on foreign affairs a day after DNC backs down over lawsuit

Alan Yuhas; Dan Roberts and Lauren Gambino in Manchester, New Hampshire; Ben Jacobs in Washington DC and Megan Carpentier in New York

20, Dec, 2015 @4:25 AM

Article image
Clinton and Sanders duel on Wall Street and healthcare in Democratic debate
Record on gun control, especially ‘Charleston loophole’, hurts Sanders but contest of pragmatism v idealism sees Clinton put on defensive

Dan Roberts and Ed Pilkington in Charleston

18, Jan, 2016 @7:55 AM

Article image
Democratic debate: candidates spar on terrorism, Wall Street reform, healthcare — as it happened
Clinton, Sanders and O’Malley face off in Des Moines, Iowa as CBS adds terrorism and national security to questions on familiar social issues

Tom McCarthy and Megan Carpentier in New York with Dan Roberts and Sabrina Siddiqui in Des Moines, Iowa and Ben Jacobs in Washington

15, Nov, 2015 @5:04 AM

Article image
Heated debate sees Clinton and Sanders spar on Middle East policy and taxes
Clinton eschews progressive wing in defense against claims she is ‘fan of regime change’ over US role in Syria and as she fends off Sanders’ call for higher taxes

Dan Roberts and Lauren Gambino in Manchester, New Hampshire

20, Dec, 2015 @5:34 AM

Article image
We asked all 22 presidential candidates to define a US refugee policy. Few had clear answers
The Guardian pressed every contender for the White House on how they would confront shocking realities from abroad. Just two called for taking on more refugees

Sabrina Siddiqui in Plymouth, New Hampshire

07, Sep, 2015 @11:05 PM

Article image
'Hillary gets an A-': national high school debaters review Democratic debate
No one understands the technique and skill involved in debating better than the students selected for the USA Debate Team. We asked them to give their verdict on Tuesday’s first Democratic debate

Ruth Spencer

14, Oct, 2015 @3:29 PM