Attack of the Hollywood Clichés! review – Rob Lowe raises idiocy to a high art

Produced by Charlie Brooker, this jam-packed sendup of hackneyed film tropes – from The Baguette Rule to The Smurfette Principle – is a perfect hour of fluff and nonsense

The last time I saw Rob Lowe – and I did actually have to check this wasn’t the result of some kind of pandemic-induced hallucination – was in ITV’s Wild Bill, in which he played a Miami ex-cop who had relocated to east Lincolnshire to become the chief constable. It was an astonishing expression of the undying trouper spirit that must endure in every actor if they are to survive. We watched Billy Hicks from St Elmo’s Fire drive a Volvo through a field of cabbages, for chrissakes! About Last Night’s Danny Martin faced off with a baddie atop a wind turbine in the Boston countryside!

Lowe is game, is what I’m saying. And he is game again as presenter of Attack of the Hollywood Clichés! (Netflix), a piece of fluff and nonsense – these are terms of praise – by Charlie Brooker and other assorted writers. Looking at the movie industry’s most frequently used tropes, it was made up of a plethora of clips, comments and a small but crucial extra measure of wit and deftness than the genre customarily manages.

Which is not to say that the gang forgot the pleasure of silliness raised to high idiocy. “Since all aspects of your protagonist have to be remarkable,” explained Lowe in his introduction to the Maverick Cop cliche, “it’s not enough for them just to have a job. Whatever that job is, they’ve gotta job the shit out of it! Especially if their job is THE job! The cop’s job!” There was something extra – if ineffably – pleasing about hearing a quintessentially US star lean into such quintessentially English daftness. The writers knew it, he knew it and we knew it. Lovely. He also assured us, when holding the grocery bag with a baguette sticking out of it to kick off the section about Hollywood’s favourite domestic interiors prop, that the bag was acting as a protective cover to stop him absorbing any carbs through his skin. “All movie stars insist on it.”

Attack of the Hollywood Clichés! managed to cover just about every cinematic chestnut there is, from the Meet Cute and Manic Pixie Dream Girl to Dead Man Walking (never be the character two days from retirement, and certainly don’t reflect on your love and aspirations for your young family) via the likes of the Jump Scare, the Spit-take and Montage Mode. Apposite clips and informed observations from a variety of actors, critics and cultural commentators abounded. It was crammed with bits of film trivia, like the reason a false scare is known as a “Lewton bus” (after horror producer Val Lewton) and the history of the Wilhelm scream – that bloodcurdling cry you hear at moments of high celluloid drama, first recorded for Gary Cooper’s 1951 outing Distant Drums and used with increasing irony-slash-knowing-fondness as a stock sound effect ever since. It covered an impressive amount of material – managing in the Maverick Cops segment, for example, to nod not just to the Dirty Harrys of history, but the latest additions too, like Kate Winslet’s mighty Mare of Easttown. You felt like you were getting a lot of entertainment for your money/60 minutes of life, which was a nice change from the usual feeling induced by this sort of programme, ie that it was 15 minutes of material spread unforgivably thin.

It also managed to confront the cliches that are less instantly comic. The Smurfette Principle noted that most female roles exist in the service of male protagonists and viewers, while the Meet Cute acknowledged that most potential suitors’ behaviour in romcoms would count as quite serious harassment in the real world. Bury Your Gays pointed out Hollywood’s unwillingness to let non-heterosexual characters survive (and included the statistic that 40% of such characters nominated for Oscars are dead before the end credits). Consecutive segments on the White Saviour and The Magical Negro tropes briefly but firmly traced their histories and included the scene from The Nun’s Story in which Audrey Hepburn and her porcelain-skinned sisters in Congo are teaching the local women how to wash their babies, and an excerpt from The Legend of Bagger Vance, the story of Will Smith teaching a white man how to play better golf. “I don’t think Will Smith’s at home rewatching The Legend of Bagger Vance,” commented TV writer and cultural critic Ira Madison III drily. “Some white person in Ohio is.”

All this and Rob Lowe gainfully employed too. An hour well spent, I’d say.

Contributor

Lucy Mangan

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Attack of the Hollywood Cliches! Charlie Brooker and Rob Lowe churn out a shoddy tropefest
It’s got a fine lineup of film stars and critics, but this tedious tour of movie tricks feels like an opportunity missed. What were they all thinking?

Joel Golby

27, Sep, 2021 @5:00 AM

Article image
Wild Bill review – why is Rob Lowe fighting crime in Lincolnshire? Search me
It’s hard to get over the fact that the actor has come an awfully long way from St Elmo’s Fire and The West Wing to star in ITV’s new cop drama

Lucy Mangan

12, Jun, 2019 @9:00 PM

Article image
Cat Burglar review – Charlie Brooker’s note-perfect nostalgia trip for cartoon fetishists
Harking back to the glory days of cartoons, this ingenious interactive game makes you answer quiz questions to help the criminal Rowdy Cat get rich quick. Consider me hooked

Stuart Jeffries

22, Feb, 2022 @7:00 AM

Article image
Black Mirror season six review – prepare to convulse in horror on the sofa
Netflix’s perversely prescient dystopian drama will once again ruthlessly mine your existential angst. Expect incredible turns from Paapa Essiedu, Salma Hayek and Aaron Paul – even if this isn’t its best season

Lucy Mangan

15, Jun, 2023 @5:00 AM

Article image
Unstable review – this Rob Lowe nepo-sitcom is staggeringly joke-free
The actor stars alongside his son (playing his son) in a nauseatingly schmaltzy, second-tier comedy. It’s utterly unfunny, but at least its lead is as charming as ever

Lucy Mangan

30, Mar, 2023 @8:50 AM

Article image
Time series two review – Jodie Whittaker shines a light on the idiocy of our legal system
The ex-Doctor puts in a brilliant performance alongside Bella Ramsey, as a jailed mum who isn’t allowed enough phone calls to get her kids looked after. It’s a powerful message

Lucy Mangan

29, Oct, 2023 @10:00 PM

Article image
Hollywood Bulldogs review – thrilling tales from heroically stupid stuntmen
Meet the excellent British oddballs who doubled for the likes of Harrison Ford and Roger Moore – and whose near-death stories of derring-do are enough to make you hyperventilate

Stuart Jeffries

28, Jun, 2021 @5:20 PM

Article image
Killer Women With Piers Morgan review: all a bit murder porn
Although Morgan is a good interviewer (and doesn’t he know it) Erin Caffey doesn’t give a lot away. Plus: Philomena Cunk’s hilarious thoughts on Shakespeare

Sam Wollaston

12, May, 2016 @5:20 AM

Article image
The Full Monty TV review – boring and badly written
Wacky plots, endlessly irritating characters and a distinct lack of stripping – this Disney+ series isn’t a patch on the film

Lucy Mangan

14, Jun, 2023 @5:00 AM

Article image
The Equalizer review – farcical fun with Queen Latifah’s avenging angel
The one-man A-Team is back on TV … except this time she’s a woman vigilante, defying a clunky script to tackle shady villains and deliver justice for those in need

Lucy Mangan

03, Aug, 2021 @9:00 PM