The week in radio: Homecoming; The Kids Who Decide What All The Other Kids Talk About

A podcast mystery proves that radio drama can speak to real life, while on Radio 4, young entrepreneurs take control of the conversation

Homecoming (Gimlet Media) | Gimlet
The Kids Who Decide What All The Other Kids Talk About (Radio 4) | iPlayer

Radio drama. I know I’m always horrible about it, but every time I check it’s still bad. Though there are honourable exceptions, all of which slip my mind, 99% of radio drama is sterile, stagey and stupid. At least, the BBC offerings are: those terrible series that cut Woman’s Hour down to 45 minutes; the one-offs that you switch on by mistake on a quiet afternoon; the pompous, star-studded adaptations of worthy books. All awful. (The Archers has improved, but I still only listen when something is going badly wrong.) Let’s have a look at the week’s Radio 4 offerings, shall we? Which do you fancy: a drama about Brexit? A comedy about dementia? A cop show? All is issue-based commissioning peppered with bad accents, silly situations and not a single unobvious idea. Plus, actors who keep acting. Argh.

I don’t know what kind of drama BBC producers and directors enjoy, but surely some of them have watched Stranger Things or Happy Valley? Breaking Bad? Modern Family? Toy Story 1, 2 or 3? If not, here’s a new show for them to try. Homecoming, from Gimlet Media, the US podcast powerhouse, is a drama that actually has me hooked. In fact, I hesitate to recommend it to you, because I think it might be best to listen to it all in one go, after the series has finished. It seems designed for the full-on, hour-after-hour binge listen.

No plot-spoilers here. Just some elements. A decent person caught up in something bigger than she realises, an unscrupulous boss, the threat of government involvement, an unsettling, unfolding mystery… Also, Homecoming expects you to concentrate. The story jumps from past to future. The script works like a proper thriller. The actors, who include Catherine Keener, David Schwimmer and Oscar Isaac, play characters who are contemporary and real. And no one crowbars in an explanation or calls someone by name in a situation where nobody would in real life.

As with any Gimlet offering, a lot of thought has gone into the programme, and after each episode there’s a section that shows that off. It unpicks what you’ve just heard, through a discussion point or interview: a little like the “how we did it” bit after each Planet Earth.

I’m not madly keen on such extras – once I believe in the wizard of Oz, I don’t want to see the little old man – but I listened to the first one, where Gimlet founder Alex Blumberg asked Homecoming writer Eli Horowitz about the use of long-distance phone conversations in his episode. Horowitz talked about bad connections, awkward pauses, the way each person is also doing something else at the same time and how that affects the status of the people on the phone. All stuff that never usually makes its way into drama and yet is part of everyday life.

I like contemporary life. I enjoy social media. So I was interested to hear about Social Chain, a company set up and staffed by young people (average age: 22). Social Chain owns more than 400 of the most popular social media accounts and uses them to advertise brands. It says it can get a topic trending on Twitter within half an hour. In The Kids Who Decide What All The Other Kids Talk About, Paul Mason, a frothing-mouth columnist but an excellent reporter, talked to Social Chain’s founders, all of whom proved jolly and sane. Mason and other commentators worried that young people didn’t always know when they were being sold to. Mason worried that the business might collapse. The Social Chainers didn’t, though, and I rather liked them for that.

Contributor

Miranda Sawyer

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The week in radio: Asquith’s Fight for Equality, The Enemy Within and more
Moving past the corridors of power to hear how the race relations struggle has affected real men and women proves moving and illuminating

Miranda Sawyer

30, Oct, 2016 @7:00 AM

Article image
The week in radio and podcasts: all change at Woman's Hour, LBC and TalkSport
Moves galore are in the offing for presenters at the BBC, LBC and TalkSport

Miranda Sawyer

12, Sep, 2020 @4:00 PM

Article image
The week in radio: Short Cuts; In the Studio; No Place of Greater Safety, FRDH
The BBC is doing its best to create an air of intimacy as it embraces its inner podcast

Miranda Sawyer

24, Sep, 2017 @6:00 AM

Article image
The week in radio: Today, Woman’s Hour, 5 Live Daily With Emma Barnett and more
Radio hosts played their Trump cards on US election day, featuring Margaret Beckett on fighting form – and Nigel Farage

Miranda Sawyer

13, Nov, 2016 @7:00 AM

Article image
The week in radio: S-Town; The Shock; Yeah, But It’s Not As Simple As That
S-Town is even better second time round. Plus, Jude Rogers’s fascinating investigation of trauma

Miranda Sawyer

23, Apr, 2017 @6:00 AM

Article image
The week in radio: Phil Williams; PM; Late Night with Iain Lee; Alex Edelman’s Peer Group; I was Billie Holliday’s Replacement
The BBC was at its best covering the terrible events in Manchester, while Iain Lee provided some welcome respite

Miranda Sawyer

28, May, 2017 @6:00 AM

Article image
The week in radio: Johnnie Walker Meets Peter Kay; Desert Island Discs; Blink Once for Yes
Johnnie Walker struggles to get a word in with Peter Kay, while the late Victoria Wood proves that modest reflection is a far better way of winning listeners’ hearts

Miranda Sawyer

01, Jan, 2017 @8:00 AM

Article image
The week in radio and podcasts: Scala Radio; Don’t Log Off; Moving Pictures – review
If you find Classic FM too cheesy and Radio 3 too highbrow, Simon Mayo’s bright and breezy Scala Radio could be just the thing

Miranda Sawyer

10, Mar, 2019 @7:00 AM

Article image
The week in radio and podcasts: Today; 1619
John Humphrys finally bows out from the Radio 4 flagship, while a New York Times podcast illuminates US history

Miranda Sawyer

22, Sep, 2019 @4:30 AM

Article image
The week in radio and podcasts: Radio 4; Making Gay History
Inertia dominates at a Radio 4 still without a new controller, while a brilliant US podcast marks 50 years since the Stonewall riots

Miranda Sawyer

07, Jul, 2019 @6:00 AM