One pilot dead as Virgin Galactic's SpaceShipTwo rocket plane crashes

Virgin Galactic says plane designed for commercial space travel was undertaking test flight in California when ‘in-flight anomaly’ occurred

A Virgin Galactic spacecraft crashed after an explosion during a test flight over the Mojave desert on Friday, killing one of the pilots, seriously injuring another and leaving debris scattered over a wide area.

The plane, SpaceShipTwo, was undertaking a test flight as part of Sir Richard Branson’s plans for commercial space travel when a “serious anomaly” occurred, the company said. Branson was on his way to the Mojave base on Saturday in the wake of the crash.

Witnesses reported the spacecraft broke apart soon after it was detached from the launch plane that carries it to 45,000ft. Rescuers found one of the pilots dead on the ground. The other, who appeared to have deployed an emergency parachute, was airlifted to a hospital with serious injuries.

Virgin Galactic said that SpaceShipTwo was powered by a fuel mix that had not previously been used in flight, although it had been tested extensively on the ground. The company was unable to say whether the change to the fuel mix offered an explanation for the accident, which happened just before 11am local time.

The crash served as another stark reminder the dangers of space exploration, three days after an unmanned rocket on supply mission to the international space station exploded seconds after takeoff from a Nasa launch facility in Virginia.

“Space is hard, and today was a tough day,” said George Whitesides, CEO and president of Virgin Galactic, at a news conference. “We are going to be supporting the investigation as we figure out what happened today and we are going to get through it,” Whitesides said.

Branson said he would persevere with the space tourism venture despite the “devastating loss” and Virgin Galactic would do everything possible to support the pilots’ families. Branson said the journey to the Mojave Desert spaceport was “one of the most difficult trips I have ever had to make” and but he wanted to be with the “dedicated and hard-working” team there. He promised full co-operation with authorities.

Writing on his website Branson said: “We’ve always known that the road to space is extremely difficult – and that every new transportation system has to deal with bad days early in their history.”

Echoing the words of Galactic CEO Whitesides, Branson declared: “Space is hard – but worth it. We will persevere and move forward together.”

Two pilots are usually on board for Virgin Galactic’s test flights, launched from a base in the Mojave desert. The identities of those involved in Friday’s accident were not immediately disclosed.

The California Highway Patrol confirmed that one person was dead and another had suffered “major injuries” in the accident, which happened at 10.51am local time.


A spokesman for Kern County sheriff said the co-pilot of the plane had been killed, while the pilot ejected.

SpaceShipTwo is the second-stage launch vehicle for Virgin Galactic’s space flight program. It is designed to disconnect from the WhiteKnightTwo (WK2) craft and ascend to space under rocket power, then returns to earth.

Ken Brown, a photographer who witnessed the accident, said that the craft exploded after it was launched from the carrier vehicle. “They separated, the rocket seemed to start fine as it’s done in the past three tests, then there was a big puff. We could see that major pieces were coming down.”

Brown said that he and blogger Doug Messier, who was with him, found a piece of debris across the road with the remains of one of the pilots. “I’m still shaking.”

Messier, a blogger who runs the website Parabolic Arc, which reports on space news, wrote on Twitter that he witnessed the crash from Jawbone Station, which is on a ridge overlooking the desert where the craft crashed. “We saw the twin contrails of WhiteKnightTwo overhead. They do that prior to a drop,” he tweeted. “SpaceShipTwo dropped. From what I could tell, motor fired and then stopped then fired again. I think that’s what happened.”

During the test, the vehicle suffered a serious anomaly resulting in the loss of SpaceShipTwo. WK2 landed safely. (2 of 4)

— Virgin Galactic (@virgingalactic) October 31, 2014

Messier reported that clouds made it hard to see clearly, but it appeared that SpaceShipTwo “broke apart and started coming down in pieces over the desert.” He added: “We started seeing clouds of dirt where pieces of the ship came down. One after another. At least three.” Messier reported then driving to one of the debris sites. “Debris from the ship was scattered all over the road,” he said.

The Federal Aviation Administration said it was investigating the accident. It said: “Just after 10am PT today, ground controllers at the Mojave Spaceport lost contact with SpaceShipTwo, an experimental space flight vehicle. The incident occurred over the Mojave desert shortly after the space flight vehicle separated from WhiteKnightTwo, the vehicle that carried it aloft.

“Two crew members were on board SpaceShipTwo at the time of the incident. WhiteKnightTwo remained airborne after the incident.”

NBC News reported that the aircraft was forced to wait on the runway at the test site for three hours before it took off, while the ground team assessed the weather conditions.

Virgin Galactic, owned by Branson’s Virgin group and an Abu Dhabi investment company, has suffered setbacks before. In 2011, SpaceShip Two experienced a malfunction during re-entry during a test flight, though the pilots were able to correct the problem and land the craft successfully. Analysts have been sceptical about whether Branson’s plans for commercial space travel can be achieved: the launch date has been repeatedly delayed.

John Lodsdon, a professor emeritus in political science at George Washington University, specialising in space and space policy, said test flights such the one undertaken on Friday were inherently risky. “You conduct tests because you’re not sure that things are going to work,” said Lodsdon, who served as a member of the board that investigated the Columbia space shuttle disaster in 2003. “Failure is a not unexpected outcome of a test, and this, unfortunately, was a very catastrophic failure.”

Lodsdon told the Guardian that he thought the accident might “slow down the emergence of a private suborbital business,” and said that it “remains to be seen whether it will be so negative an impact that it will be impossible to revive the business.” Such an outcome would be “unfortunate, I would say sad,” he said.

Chris Hadfield, a Canadian astronaut and former test pilot, who warned last year in that a crash by a Virgin Galactic craft was possible, said on Friday that he hoped the cause of the accident would be determined swiftly.

“Trying to do something complicated doesn’t happen easily, and it doesn’t happen without cost,” he told the Guardian by telephone from Toronto. “The resolve that the professionals in the business have is what makes it happen. This is the true nature of being a test pilot or an astronaut: to see both the cost and the benefit, and to recognise that if we want to explore - if we want to go faster or go higher - then that doesn’t come for free.”

The accident is the second this week to hit a private US space company. On Tuesday, an Orbital Sciences Antares rocket exploded 15 seconds after liftoff from Wallops Island, Virginia, destroying a cargo ship bound for the International Space Station.

About 800 people, including Tom Hanks and Angelina Jolie, had paid to book a two-hour journey into space on SpaceShipTwo, which would include a planned five minutes of weightlessness.

Last year Hadfield, whose tweeted photos, videos and rendition of David Bowie’s Space Oddity brought him global fame during a stint on the International Space Station, questioned what kind of experience future space tourists will have with Virgin Galactic, saying they are “just going to go up and fall back down again”.

He said: “They’ll get a few minutes of weightlessness, and they’ll see the black of the universe. And they’ll see the curve of the Earth and the horizon, because they’ll be above the air. But whether that’ll be enough for the quarter-million-dollar price tag, I don’t know.”

• This article was amended on 3 November 2014. An earlier version incorrectly described the WhiteKnightTwo carrier aircraft as propeller-driven. It has jet engines.

• Comments were opened for a short time in error on this article

Contributors

Nicky Woolf and Amanda Holpuch

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Virgin Galactic's SpaceShipTwo makes first rocket-powered flight - video

Virgin Galactic's SpaceShipTwo completes its first rocket-powered flight on Monday morning above the Mojave Desert in California

30, Apr, 2013 @5:35 AM

Article image
Virgin Orbit stops operations and furloughs most staff
Satellite launch company hunts for funding lifeline following failed attempt from UK soil

Alex Lawson

16, Mar, 2023 @9:16 AM

Article image
Branson hails Virgin's SpaceShipTwo 'the sexiest spaceship ever'

Craft unveiled in freezing Mojave desert in front of celebrity guests including Arnold Schwarzenegger

Andrew Gumbel in Mojave, California

08, Dec, 2009 @8:08 AM

Article image
Some Virgin Galactic seatholders ask for refund on tickets after crash
Company reveals 3% of customers have cancelled as investigators release analysis of pilots’ actions prior to crash

Ian Sample and Juliette Garside

05, Nov, 2014 @3:41 AM

Article image
Virgin Orbit California rocket launch paves way for UK lift-off
Rocket strapped to wing of 747 takes off from California space port to launch site above Pacific

Stuart Clark

21, Jan, 2022 @6:00 AM

Article image
SpaceShip Two's end drags dream of cheap space flight to Earth in Mojave
The wreckage of SpaceShipTwo suggests that engineers are still a long way from making rocketry safe for paying passengers

Robin McKie, science editor

02, Nov, 2014 @10:25 AM

Article image
Alien finding institute Seti runs out of cash to operate telescope

Organisation's brand new $50m array put in hibernation, reducing chances of finding elusive extraterrestrial signal

Alok Jha, science correspondent

26, Apr, 2011 @7:28 PM

Article image
Virgin Galactic crash investigators are a long way from finding the cause
Descent system was unlocked two seconds before SpaceShipTwo disintegrated, but what happened next is unclear

Ian Sample

03, Nov, 2014 @6:52 PM

Article image
Virgin Galactic to accept Bitcoin for space flights
Richard Branson says: 'All of our astronauts are pioneers … and this is one more way to be forward-thinking'

Amanda Holpuch

22, Nov, 2013 @4:43 PM

Article image
Virgin threatens to pull out of projected spaceport
Richard Branson's plan in the balance as Virgin Galactic argues with New Mexico over $200m spaceport

Edward Helmore in New York

13, Jan, 2013 @12:04 AM