Our Bodies Are Your Battlefields review – sensitive study of trans women’s struggles

Filmed with power and insight in Argentina, the documentary conveys a feeling of intimacy and closeness

What makes this documentary about a community of transgender women in Argentina so powerful is the feeling of intimacy and closeness. Director Isabelle Solas films her subjects with sensitivity and insight – and in return they open up their lives for the camera. That said, the film doesn’t exactly make it easy for audiences outside Argentina, giving virtually no explanation or context. It opens with scenes from the 2018 trial of a man convicted of stabbing to death a trans woman, Diana Sacayán. But it takes a bit of Googling to learn her story: Sacayán was a high-profile transgender activist murdered in 2015. The conviction of her killer was historic – the first in Argentina under laws against gender-motivated hate crimes.

The film focuses on two trans women. One is veteran activist Claudia, a funny, witty force of nature who is doing her damnedest to lobby feminist groups for more trans inclusion. We see her passionately and persuasively making the case for common ground at a rally. “History has made us invisible too, it has persecuted us, it has murdered us, humiliated us.” Claudia is close to her family: her elderly mother beams with pride sitting next to her daughter.

That’s not the experience of other trans women in the film, who talk of being disowned by their families, pushing some into sex work. Many share their stories with Violeta, a cool and soulful anthropology researcher and trans activist, who is the film’s other focus. Being trans is dangerous in Argentina; one activist points out that life expectancy is just 35 years in Latin America as a whole. In her early 50s, she is beating the odds. Still, the film ends on an optimistic note: Violeta at an exhibition celebrating trans culture and history – wall after wall of black and white images from the archive of gorgeous trans women done up to the nines.

• Our Bodies Are Your Battlefields is available from 22 June on Mubi.

Contributor

Cath Clarke

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Pornomelancholia review – sorrows of the sweaty, permanently aroused sex influencer
Argentinian director Manuel Abramovich juxtaposes the spicier elements of porn star Lalo’s life with his loneliness

Catherine Bray

23, Jan, 2024 @11:00 AM

Article image
Donna review – a tender love letter to a San Fran trans activist
Jay Bedwani’s warm, moving documentary shines brightest when it lets its hero be the star of the show

Phuong Le

12, Jul, 2022 @8:00 AM

Article image
Instructions for Survival review – a trans man’s close-up portrait of intolerance
The reality of trans life in Georgia is laid bare in Yana Ugrekhelidze’s heartbreaking documentary, which follows Alexander and his partner Marie as they look to escape

Phuong Le

17, Apr, 2023 @6:00 AM

Article image
Our Body review – a brave, unblinking, hospital’s-eye view of women’s health
Documentarist Claire Simon films women, including herself, receiving care in a women’s health, obstetrics and gynaecology ward at a Parisian hospital

Leslie Felperin

05, Mar, 2024 @9:00 AM

Article image
Keyboard Fantasies review – glorious doc about pioneering trans composer
This follows the rediscovery of Beverly Glenn-Copeland in his 70s – an electronic musician who radiates life and happiness

Cath Clarke

09, Nov, 2021 @2:00 PM

Article image
Emilia Perez review – Jacques Audiard’s gangster trans musical barrels along in style
A thoroughly implausible yarn about a Mexican cartel leader who hires a lawyer to arrange his transition is carried along by its cheesy Broadway energy

Peter Bradshaw

18, May, 2024 @6:40 PM

Article image
Corporate Accountability review – collaboration with Argentinian state terror exposed
Jonathan Perel’s low-key doc focuses on the companies, still in business, which collaborated with the killings and torture that followed 1976 coup

Cath Clarke

16, Oct, 2021 @9:46 AM

Article image
'What is it about my freedom that bothers you?': how trans films are evolving
The recent BFI Flare festival of LGBTIQ+ films showcased a raft of transgender titles from a powerful family drama to a devastating documentary about a jazz musician. They bear witness to a complicated but optimistic new future

Freddy McConnell

30, Mar, 2021 @11:15 AM

Article image
The End of Wonderland review – trans porn star deals with eviction and a hoarding crisis
Laurence Turcotte-Fraser’s wistful documentary follows resourceful porn star Tara Emory’s ‘entropic’ problem with clutter

Phil Hoad

07, May, 2024 @6:00 AM

Article image
Camouflage review – the dark past of Argentina’s dirty war detention centres
Author Félix Bruzzone fronts this haunting film about Campo de Mayo, where his mother was among tens of thousands of people who ‘disappeared’ under the dictatorship

Phuong Le

22, Apr, 2024 @6:00 AM