Fruits Basket: Prelude review – heartrending anime series gets the ending no one deserves

A laboured recap and unsettling romance frustrates a potentially engrossing plot in a coda that might be offputting to newcomers and the fanbase alike

A coda to a hugely popular manga and anime series, Fruits Basket: Prelude steps away from the supernatural elements of its preceding iterations while aiming to retain their emotional lyricism. The first half-hour of this “prelude” functions as a recap of the series; this lengthy prologue revisits how Tohru Honda, a sensitive orphaned girl, falls in love with Kyo, a teenage boy who is cursed to transform into a cat when touched by a member of the opposite sex. These events, absorbing enough when told over the course of the series, are a bit of a slog when conjured up in this clipped format. Simply checking off the high points of their relationship is going to be confusing for newcomers and all too familiar for ardent fans.

But when Fruits Basket: Prelude finally kicks off its narrative thread, which follows the life of Tohru’s mother Kyoko, who dies in a car accident, becomes serviceably engrossing. The romantic elements might raise some eyebrows – Kyoko and Tohru’s father meet as student and teacher in a junior high school – but Kyoko’s transformation from a lost delinquent to a doting mother is rather movingly done.

Still, considering that Kyoko’s story only takes up about two-thirds of the running time, the whole enterprise feels like careless fan service. The decision to split Tohru and Kyoko’s struggles into parallel lines is an odd one, and a missed opportunity. Considering the way Kyoko faces abuse and neglect from her own parents, Fruits Basket: Prelude could have probed further into how intergenerational trauma informs Tohru’s own identity now that she is building a family with Kyo. All in all, this is a film that will not only fail to convert new believers but also frustrate the existing fanbase.

• Fruits Basket: Prelude is released on 20 July in cinemas.

Contributor

Phuong Le

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Jujutsu Kaisen 0 review – sorcerer anime series gets a spectacular prequel
This masterful coming-of-age tale sees the process of coming to terms with past traumas through a horror-fantasy lens

Phuong Le

15, Mar, 2022 @11:00 AM

Article image
The Quintessential Quintuplets review – sisters compete for love in charming anime
The premise of a high-school tutor forced to choose which of his students to marry could have been disastrous but this romantic fantasy film avoids ickiness

Phil Hoad

05, Dec, 2022 @7:00 AM

Article image
Pompo: The Cinephile review – anime love letter to movie-making
Takayuki Hirao’s animated feature is set in the fictional Nyallywood, where a B-movie producer in pigtails and a sailor dress takes on a serious-minded film about ageing, art and loss

Phuong Le

27, Jun, 2022 @2:00 PM

Article image
Fortune Favours Lady Nikuko review – anime teen embarrassed by ‘Meaty Lady’ mum
Director Ayumu Watanabe navigates the growing pains of a young girl, coping with life on a houseboat with her mother and the tragicomic dramas of school life

Phuong Le

11, Aug, 2022 @10:03 AM

Article image
Belle review – anime that makes for an intriguing big-screen spectacle
This weird postmodern drama sees a lonely teenager join a virtual world where she becomes a hugely successful singer

Peter Bradshaw

01, Feb, 2022 @2:00 PM

Article image
Maquia: When the Promised Flower Blooms review – heart-melting anime
This female-centred story set among dragons and ancient clans is a sentimental tale of motherhood and ageing

Cath Clarke

26, Jun, 2018 @2:41 PM

Article image
Inu-oh review – medieval anime rock opera rips Noh theatre a new one
Masaaki Yuasa’s showstopping animation reframes the classical performance style as a world of rock gods and cavorting dancers

Phil Hoad

27, Sep, 2022 @2:00 PM

Article image
Dragon Ball Super: Super Hero review – eye-candy anime is gloriously mesmeric
The immensely popular franchise is back with a bewildering cast of brightly coloured characters in a world of bad guys with outrageous quiffs

Leslie Felperin

17, Aug, 2022 @8:00 AM

Article image
Psycho-Pass: Providence review – anime thriller investigates dark side of technology
Japanese studio Production IG’s conspiracy noir is a fabulous-looking tale influenced by Blade Runner

Phil Hoad

31, Jul, 2023 @10:00 AM

Article image
Eternal 831 review – anime thriller stops all the clocks with a superpower
In Kenji Kamiyama’s drama, a boy discovers that he can halt time when emotionally stirred and that terrorists are exploiting the same power

Peter Bradshaw

12, Dec, 2022 @11:00 AM