Orwellian dystopia? Nashville roots? How not to make a pop comeback

From Lady Gaga to the Pet Shop Boys, music is full of ill-advised genre shifts and attempts at demolishing an old identity. Here are some of the worst

The ‘did Orwell at GCSE’ manoeuvre

The best albums are those that tell you what you know already, and that’s what happens when artists suddenly remember studying 1984 in Year 10. And, by the way, did you see the subsequently debunked meme about CCTV that your mum posted on Facebook? Makes u think, right? Did you know social media’s quite addictive? And that President Trump, he doesn’t sound ideal! The “everything’s like Black Mirror!” idea was recently pulled off by Bastille – who did a good job of turning their album concept into a cross-platform marketing extravaganza.

Who’s next Both Chvrches and Years & Years are using opaque dystopian imagery in their album teaser campaigns. Naturally, Muse are 100% back on their bullshit with Thought Contagion.

Pivot to rodeo

Nothing says “I went to Nashville for a fortnight now I think I’m Dolly Parton” quite like a “country”-inspired comeback album. Kylie, Miley Cyrus and Lady Gaga have all used Nashville recently. Soundbites about Nashville’s history provide great source material for promo interviews, despite the fact that recording studios in Nashville are pretty much like recording studios anywhere else in the world: if you give them money, they let you in. Fearne Cotton could miraculously discover her authentic country roots if she chucked enough cash around.

Who’s next If you see Dua Lipa on Skyscanner, grab her laptop and chuck it out of the window.

The bait and switch

None of us want our favourite pop personnel to just keep making the same album for ever (newsflash: actually we kind of do), but some shifts in sonic direction are pop’s equivalent of a handbrake turn. This can be an act who’ve achieved popularity through electronic pop music “going real” (as on Pet Shop Boys’ Release, Goldfrapp’s Seventh Tree, the Harry Styles album or Gaga’s Joanne) but, less testingly, this move can sometimes involve a semi-famous, semi-peripheral artist waking up one morning and thinking, as Nelly Furtado did with Maneater, that it’s time to have a massive No 1 single.

Who’s next On the Maneater front, Janelle Monáe’s just teamed up with the writers behind Justin Bieber’s Sorry and is clearly not messing about.

The greatest latest hits

Streaming means the conventional greatest hits album is dead for artists who don’t shift most of their music via supermarkets, but the streaming world’s constant thirst for one-off single releases can result in a massive backlog of hits that don’t seem to belong to an album. By the time an album does eventually appear, it’s at least 50% smash.

Who’s next It’s almost four years since Clean Bandit released an album. There have been five hits – including two No 1s – since then, but the band’s second album hasn’t yet been announced.

The definitely-not-an-album album

Charli XCX’s last album came out in 2014. Or did it? In the last year she’s actually released two albums, except they’re not albums because they’re mixtapes. The songs aren’t mixed together. The album-length collections are for sale, like albums. XCX recently said that one liberating thing about making a mixtape is that it’s easier to get guest vocalists – labels don’t get their contractual knickers in a twist if they’re not dealing with a “proper” project. It’s a decent marketing angle, too: mixtapes are taken less seriously than albums by most over-35s but they’re greeted more enthusiastically, and are seen as more authentic blasts of creativity by their target audience.

Who’s next Stefflon Don’s about to follow up her 2016 mixtape Real Ting. The new one’s called Real Ting II.

Guys! This is the real me!

Anyone who’s enjoyed a hit album before their 18th birthday will at some point be keen to point out that they’re actually very musical and interesting. The modern queen of “Guys! This is the real me!” has to be Miley Cyrus, who in a six-album career has presented her definitive self no fewer than six times: with 2007’s Hannah Montana 2: Meet Miley Cyrus (which braced a generation for the news that Miley was an actual human), 2008’s Breakout (she was breaking out from Hannah!), 2010’s Can’t Be Tamed (which presented that old favourite – the More Mature Direction), 2013’s Bangerz (no hang on, this was the more mature direction), 2015’s Miley Cyrus & Her Dead Petz (Christ knows what that was), and last year’s “pivot to rodeo” masterpiece Younger Now.

Who’s next Miley Cyrus.

Contributor

Peter Robinson

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Selfies! Smoking! Snogging! Why pop stars love a house party
From Beastie Boys to Beyoncé, we explore music videos’ enduring obsession with red cups and riotous shower scenes

Michael Cragg

30, Jan, 2018 @9:00 AM

Article image
Stetsons, beards and good, honest sweat: why pop stars are going back to basics
Country and Americana have become shorthand for mainstream musicians who want to mature. Justin Timberlake is the latest to join the ranch

Dorian Lynskey

20, Jan, 2018 @10:00 AM

Article image
Born to make you flappy: why pop is obsessed with wings
The new Charlie’s Angels video marks the return of a pop staple. Here we chart its feathered history

Hannah Verdier

08, Oct, 2019 @8:00 AM

Article image
Reclining album sales? Why pop stars are making sofas not songs
From Louise Redknapp’s footstools to Kylie’s Atmosphere Duvet, an increasing number of musicians are turning to home furnishings

Michael Cragg

02, Nov, 2018 @1:00 PM

Article image
Shaggy and Sting, Janet and Cliff: the eight weirdest collaborations in pop
From Janet Jackson and Cliff Richard’s Two to the Power of Love, to Shaggy and Sting’s new record, here’s a rundown of the oddest musical melanges

Michael Cragg

05, May, 2018 @9:00 AM

Article image
Kylie on her 2019: ‘Maybe I should go back to Glastonbury and get real sloshy’
Ahead of her Christmas special, Kylie’s Secret Night, the pop icon joins Alan Carr to talk about perms, extreme fans and, most crucially of all, the strength of sticky tape

Michael Cragg

23, Dec, 2019 @7:00 AM

Article image
The 50 best albums of 2020: the full list
Our countdown is complete, topped by a mercurial work of sprawling invention by a woman who has dug deep to survive. Taken as a whole, these choices contain drama, solace, poetry and fire, a fitting selection for a turbulent year

Ben Beaumont-Thomas and Laura Snapes

18, Dec, 2020 @8:07 AM

Article image
Brit awards 2024 – full list of winners
The winners of every category at the 2024 Brits, updated as the ceremony progresses

Guardian music

02, Mar, 2024 @8:19 PM

Article image
Montages, headphones, nudity: a beginner’s guide to pop-star docs
As Lady Gaga’s Five Foot Two shows, there’s only one way to make a pop documentary. Let’s tick off the cliches

Michael Cragg

03, Oct, 2017 @7:59 AM

Article image
Pet Shop Boys: 'Gorillaz should be worried about going on at Glastonbury after Dizzee Rascal'

Ahead of their Other Stage headline set at Glastonbury, we meet Neil and Chris as they give the rest of this year's festival lineup a once-over

Peter Robinson

25, Jun, 2010 @11:02 PM