Cultural appropriation of Māori traditions is an exercise in entitlement and privilege | Tina Ngata

Māori face dispossession and hyper-incarceration – cultural assaults are part of the same pattern

Earlier this week, Princess Cruises (a brand of the Carnival Corporation) was brought into the public spotlight when their crew were photographed in cheap, appropriative costumes pantomiming a Māori ceremony for their passengers, and collectively, Māoridom took a heavy sigh.

As much as anyone else, we wish we did not have to respond to such issues, and yet we always will rise to defend our cultural integrity and inevitably someone (who is usually not one of us) will tell us that there are more important issues to tend to.

Like many indigenous groups, Māori face multiple challenges, from hyper-incarceration, land dispossession and homelessness, to our children being continually removed from our homes by the state. What seems to be missing for so many are the ways in which these issues are connected to cultural appropriation. How can something as apparently innocuous as a crude outfit constitute a racist, harmful act?

An early obstacle in making this connection is that of clear definition. Indeed even the experts note that cultural appropriation is not easily summed up in one sentence. Usually it involves one group taking from a culture that they do not belong to and using it as they see fit.

While it is often defended as innocent homage or humour, it is in fact an exercise in entitlement and privilege. It is experienced by minority groups as an extension of generations of cultural erasure and replacement.

What we see in Tauranga is a classic demonstration of how cultural appropriation blends cultures for a particular exotic look. There is no correlation between the fine lines of tā moko (Māori facial tattoos) and the scribble across the faces of the crew. The “grass skirts” bear no resemblance to our customary attire. Undoubtedly there was equal disregard for proper protocols within their fake ceremony. Cultural integrity does not matter for appropriators, all that matters is that you reach peak “otherness”, a level of exoticism that provides an escape of sorts from the norm of the dominant culture.

There are multiple problems with this. Of course many tourists presumably travel in order to experience “other” places, including the culture of that place and have a rightful expectation that this experience will be an authentic one. As pointed out by Tauranga leaders, there are local groups available to provide this service, and it denies both the economic and cultural benefits of engaging with tourists.

Such benefits are a part of the reason we accept the added burden upon our infrastructures and environment presented by cruise ships – but there is also a larger issue. Whether it be cruise liner companies carrying out crude faux welcome ceremonies, or Halloween costumes of hypersexualised “dusky native maidens”, or Europeans selling our haka as a form of team-building, the cost of cultural appropriation for Māori, and indeed for indigenous peoples in general, extends well past lost revenue for our authentic art forms.

More often than not, appropriation is driven by fetish or profit. The explicit miscommunications of cultural parodies so often minimise and erase the sophistication of cultural protocols and art forms, and replace them with fetishised primitive references that reinforce harmful stereotypes.

In turn, these stereotypes lead to assumptions about our behaviour as partners and parents. Consequently, we are much more likely to be convicted and imprisoned for the same crime that would see someone else released or serve a noncustodial sentence. For women, these stereotypes are often also wrapped up in ideas of exotic promiscuity, which make us targets for sexual assault while also being less likely to see justice for sexual crimes committed against us.

Quite separate from the harms of explicit misrepresentation, there is an implicit power relationship communicated here. When one group claims the right to take from and redefine another, it tells us in a multitude of ways who doesn’t matter. It paves the way for the the Otago Daily Times to run cartoons that depict dead Samoan babies as a punchline for colonial humour.

Thanks to the efforts of communities of colour around the world, instances of cultural appropriation appear to be on the decline, and that holds significant promise for our race relations. However this will only continue to improve when we, as a community, forge ahead with calling such cultural assaults out for what they are – an abuse of privilege that has no place in a just society.

• This article was amended on 4 December 2019 because an earlier version mistakenly referred to Carnival Cruise Line, another brand owned by the Carnival Corporation.


Tina Ngata

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Sydney is no place to build a Māori meeting house – it is disrespectful to Aboriginal people | Morgan Godfery
Marae embody deep connections to the land and are a statement of indigeneity – but Māori aren’t indigenous in Australia

Morgan Godfery

05, Mar, 2022 @7:00 PM

Article image
New Zealand Māori party calls for a ‘divorce’ from Britain’s royal family
Party co-leader Rawiri Waititi said the move was ‘an opportunity to reimagine a more meaningful and fulfilling partnership’

Tess McClure in Auckland

07, Feb, 2022 @1:15 AM

Article image
Jacinda Ardern faces Waitangi Day reckoning with Māori as progress stalls
Three years after the prime minister asked Māori to hold her to account, many are disillusioned with her government

Eleanor de Jong in Queenstown

01, Feb, 2021 @12:34 AM

Article image
Māori moko facial tattoos revived by a new generation with designs on the future
After brutal colonial-era efforts to suppress Māori culture, symbols of Indigenous identity are flourishing once more

Tess McClure in Auckland

10, Jun, 2022 @7:00 PM

Article image
Tiny New Zealand airport that tells Māori love story in running for global design award
Regional hub in New Plymouth – built on land seized from Māori in 1960 – is up against the likes of New York’s LaGuardia for Unesco’s Prix Versailles

Eva Corlett in Wellington

20, Aug, 2021 @12:56 AM

Article image
‘Pivotal’ Māori leader Tipene O’Regan made member of Order of New Zealand
Champion of Māori rights honoured by Queen for life of work dedicated to improving ‘economic, cultural and social standing of Māori communities’

Eva Corlett in Wellington

06, Jun, 2022 @1:52 AM

Article image
New Zealand’s warming seas threaten Māori food sources relied on for generations
Māori tribes record changes to lands and oceans, with some food-gathering practices that have sustained communities for hundreds of years lost

Tess McClurein Ōpōtiki

09, Jun, 2023 @8:00 PM

Article image
New Zealand creates public holiday to celebrate Māori new year
Jacinda Ardern had pledged to make Matariki a holiday in the 2020 election; it will be celebrated for the first time on 24 June 2022

Elle Hunt in Wellington

04, Feb, 2021 @3:44 AM

Article image
‘The gates of hell opened’: after decades, Māori survivors of state abuse are finally heard
Māori children faced not just the physical abuse, but the trauma of being cut off from their culture, New Zealand royal commission hears

Eva Corlett in Wellington

18, Mar, 2022 @6:00 PM

Article image
The Māori Party defied the odds because Labour has left Indigenous voters wanting | Leigh-Marama McLachlan
Māori are calling for much-needed systemic change – but the question is whether Labour is willing to deliver it

Leigh-Marama McLachlan

19, Oct, 2020 @3:38 AM