A growing headache for the Chinese economy

Its people won't stop saving and spend their money, while local authorites and state businesses won't stop borrowing

Since 2008, an explosion in debt-fuelled expenditure – on infrastructure and property, not shopping – has kept the economy racing ahead. If China is to overtake the US as the world's economic powerhouse, this boom must not derail Beijing.

In the first phase of the borrowing boom, the finance ministry sanctioned a huge government-funded post-crash stimulus. In a second phase, it allowed local authorities and state-run enterprises to go on a borrowing spree.

The borrowing – which tops $3tn (£1.8tn) in the local government sector alone – has disguised massive over-production and a squeeze on private sector profits from greater competition and rising wages. Local authorities have financed their losses with land sales. Recent figures show that about 37% of provincial, city and county government debts are backed by land sales revenues.

Last year was supposed to mark the end of this post-crash period and see China wean itself off debt as a means of maintaining consumer demand. Workers were supposed to start spending their earnings and allow businesses to cut back borrowing. But the savings habit has persisted. And the extent of bad loans has soared to 17% of GDP. The total is so large it could topple one of China's big four banks.

Amid the bullish forecasts, one respected economic consultancy said recently that China's GDP growth could fall to 2% over the next few years with bad debts rising beyond 20% of GDP unless the situation is alleviated.

While this may seem exaggerated, assurances from senior ministers that growth is heading for 7.5% this year are looking thin.

In March, finance minister Lou Jiwei said it would be acceptable for China to miss its target so long as enough jobs were created, which is one way of puncturing expectations.

The pessimism is not shared inside the politburo or in academic circles in China. While there is concern that local authority borrowing is difficult to control and some state-run enterprises are already drunk on debt and ready to fall over, the consensus is that foreign exchange reserves built up over decades can be spent on bank rescues, should the wheels start to come off.

At its worst, the bad debt bill could reach $3tn. There is $3.8tn sitting in the People's Bank of China's foreign reserves fund, so it could save the system if necessary. But Beijing's cupboard would be left horribly bare.

Contributor

Phillip Inman

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
America is pulling one way, China the other: will the global economy sink or swim?
Economists are proposing two radically opposed forecasts for global growth. Considering the evidence, it’s hard to side with the optimists

06, Dec, 2015 @7:00 AM

Article image
New Covid infections pose challenge to China's growth and Xi's leadership
The leader has declared victory over the virus, but a fresh outbreak is complicating the narrative

Phillip Inman

23, Jan, 2021 @4:00 PM

Article image
The world economic order is collapsing and this time there seems no way out | Will Hutton
The refugee crisis is paralleled by the savage fallout from a global financial system running out of control

Will Hutton

10, Oct, 2015 @11:05 PM

Article image
Chinese shares are falling, but the real fear is that the economy itself is slowing
Disastrous losses on the Shanghai exchange are leading to concern that the era of runaway Chinese growth is faltering at a critical time in the world economy

Heather Stewart

01, Aug, 2015 @2:59 PM

Article image
Trump vaunts his China trade pact – but some say it’s too little, too late
While a cessation in hostilities is welcome, businesses have a lot of ground to make up, and few expect any further progress

Phillip Inman

11, Jan, 2020 @4:14 PM

Article image
Everyone wants to decouple from China – except Osborne
The chancellor’s charm offensive has impressed Beijing. But the powerhouse of the east is now exporting economic problems all over the world

Heather Stewart

27, Sep, 2015 @7:59 AM

Article image
The UK’s deals worth billions with China: what do they really mean?
President Xi Jinping’s visit generated a huge – and controversial – series of agreements on trade, technology and culture. What do they mean?

Phillip Inman, Terry Macalister, Gwyn Topham and Mark Sweney

24, Oct, 2015 @3:00 PM

Article image
Global economy: hopes and fears for 2014

Will the coming year be one of tax cuts, pay rises and good cheer, or will the legacy of the financial crisis still haunt us? And what of China, Japan, the eurozone … Observer writers try to predict the economic shape of the next 12 months

Heather Stewart and Larry Elliott

29, Dec, 2013 @12:05 AM

Article image
We need growth, but austerity keeps the economy in chains
William Keegan: George Osborne's cutbacks are not the cause of this depression, but they are a major factor in keeping it alive. When the private sector collapses like this, governments must step in

William Keegan

20, Oct, 2012 @11:16 PM

Article image
It's springtime, but the economy is hardly blooming
William Keegan: The UK, having been a leader in the operation to prevent another Great Depression, is now a laggard in the recovery stakes

William Keegan

30, Apr, 2011 @11:05 PM