Q&A recap: Tanya Plibersek calls for donation laws shake-up after China spy scandal

Labor frontbencher says political fundraising needs to be more transparent to avoid manipulation by foreign powers

Labor’s Tanya Plibersek has called for a shake-up of political donation laws, including the introduction of real-time disclosures, to curb the potential for foreign influence after revelations that the Chinese government attempted to fund an agent’s run for federal parliament.

The former shadow foreign minister said politicians needed to be more transparent, and to go above and beyond existing disclosure laws to protect Australia’s democracy from manipulation.

On Sunday it was revealed by a Nine/60 Minutes investigation that the Chinese government had approached a Liberal party member, Nick Zhao, and offered him $1m in campaign funds to run for parliament. After Zhao approached Asio to reveal the contact, he was found dead in a Melbourne hotel room.

On Monday night’s Q&A program Plibersek said these kinds of foreign intelligence operations were “something that anybody who participates in public life has to be aware of and be careful of”.

But she did not go so far as saying Chinese influence was “an infection”, as Q&A’s host, Tony Jones, put it.

“Not only should we ban foreign donations, we should have much lower disclosure thresholds for donations, we should have real-time disclosure and spending caps in our elections,” Plibersek said.

“Politicians have to do our part. We have to do better than following the law. We have to be strong and show an example of independence and integrity.

“Our media have a really strong role to play in scrutinising our democratic institutions and any effort of foreign interference.”

The Australian’s foreign editor, Greg Sheridan, said both Labor and Liberal had not been outspoken enough about China’s human rights violations.

On Monday the Guardian and other outlets published hundreds of leaked Chinese government documents obtained by the International Consortium of Investigative Journalists that revealed the full scale of the country’s Uighur internment camps.

“Human rights ought to be a perennial strand in that relationship [between Australia and China],” Sheridan said.

In regards to Hong Kong, Sheridan defended the decision of his own paper, the Australian, to refer to protesters as “terrorists” in a piece written by its national chief correspondent, Hedley Thomas.

“I think Hedley Thomas has done an outstanding job in Hong Kong and he represents great courage in the view he’s taken,” he said.

Sheridan said he was previously “heart and soul with the demonstrators” during the first five months of the pro-democracy protests. But they were now “going down a wrong path” by attacking people and property.

“In that [early] period the demonstrators were extremely careful not to ever attack a human being and really not to attack property, not to do any property damage. They’d even clean the streets after themselves.

“In the last month, some demonstrators have done things which are unconscionable. They’ve set alight individual civilians that they disagreed with and tried to burn them to death. They’ve tried to steal a policeman’s revolver, resulting in a shooting incident.”

The panel also heard from Tamar Zandberg, an Israeli politician from the Democratic Union, who said continued Israeli settlements on the West Bank were “one of the biggest obstacles for peace”.

Zandberg, a member of the Knesset, was asked about Donald Trump’s declaration that the settlements were not illegal, which contradicted international law, and the US legal position since 1978.

“The settlements are one of the main reasons why we still don’t have a viable agreement between Israel and the Palestinians that would ensure a two-state solution,” she said.

“Their existence and the fact that they are not evacuated from there is actually against the interests of Israel and Israelis … We should solve this in bilateral talks between Israelis and Palestinians, between two brave leaders deciding to change the course of history towards peace.”

Contributor

Naaman Zhou

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
China's conduct in Hong Kong comes under cautious scrutiny on Q&A
Panellists debate whether Australia is ‘turning a blind eye’ to China’s rising power

Helen Davidson

12, Aug, 2019 @10:26 PM

Article image
PM refuses to stand down Angus Taylor despite NSW police investigation – as it happened
Scott Morrison says no action is required after speaking to the NSW police commissioner. This blog is now closed

Amy Remeikis

26, Nov, 2019 @7:01 AM

Article image
Tanya Plibersek flags 'problem' with religious discrimination bill overriding states
Labor frontbencher says party would find legislation ‘difficult to support’ and negotiation required before ALP backs changes

Sarah Martin

01, Sep, 2019 @1:14 AM

Article image
Malcolm Turnbull denies he is anti-China in combative Q&A appearance
Prime minister says it’s ‘absurd’ to say he is anti-Beijing as poll shows parties are neck and neck in Bennelong byelection

Katharine Murphy Political editor

11, Dec, 2017 @12:57 PM

Article image
Stuart Robert on robodebt: 'This government does not apologise' – as it happened
Morrison responds to Chinese spy plot allegations; and Jacqui Lambie ‘not supporting a repeal’ of medevac, Rex Patrick says. All the day’s events, live

Amy Remeikis

25, Nov, 2019 @6:54 AM

Article image
Q&A: News Corp a malignant influence on our democracy, Richard Di Natale says
In the final episode before the election, politicians battle it out over Newstart rate, climate change and housing policy

Anne Davies

13, May, 2019 @8:47 PM

Article image
Q&A: Tim Wilson defends joining Hong Kong protests
Coalition MP accused of hypocrisy for disparaging Australian Extinction Rebellion protesters

Calla Wahlquist

14, Oct, 2019 @7:26 PM

Article image
Q&A recap: Arthur Sinodinos refuses to rule out Tony Abbott's return
Cabinet secretary appears to give unenthusiastic support for both Malcolm Turnbull’s future leadership and the actions of George Brandis

Michael Slezak

24, Oct, 2016 @8:46 PM

Article image
Peter Dutton has plumbed new and dangerous depths by suggesting China is backing Labor | Daniel Hurst
Did the defence minister not hear the Asio boss warn that stoking community division has ‘the same corrosive impact on our democracy as foreign interference itself’?

Daniel Hurst

10, Feb, 2022 @7:54 AM

Article image
Australia's relationship with China in a 'terrible' state after Morrison's US visit, Labor says
Richard Marles accuses PM of taking ‘pot shots against our largest trading partner’ amid US-China tensions

Sarah Martin Chief political correspondent

29, Sep, 2019 @2:58 AM