Titian painting given to Charles I's plumber goes up for sale

Oliver Cromwell’s government gave artwork as part payment of money owed for palace repairs

A Titian painting once owned by Charles I and given to his plumber as part payment for money owed is coming to auction.

The two-metre tall painting is a show-stopper in its own right, depicting the terrified virgin martyr St Margaret escaping from the mouth of Satan in the shape of a dragon. But its extraordinary provenance adds another layer to its story.

Its sale comes as the Royal Academy of Arts prepares to open what is expected to be one of the blockbuster art shows of the year, with works from Charles I’s collection reunited for the first time in 400 years.

The RA show will include about 150 works by artists including Holbein, Van Dyck, Rubens and Mantegna, many of them sold by Oliver Cromwell’s government after Charles I’s execution in 1649 and which are now stars of collections around the world.

Cromwell’s government wanted to both raise money for the state and pay off Charles’s debts as quickly as possible, selling an estimated 1,500 paintings and 500 sculptures.

One person owed money – £903 for various palace repairs – was John Embry, the royal plumber. A deal was offered whereby the state would give him £403 in cash and the rest could be made up with pictures. He chose 24, including the Titian, then called Margrett Afraid of a Monster, and valued at £100.

Alexander Bell, co-chair of old master paintings at Sotheby’s, said that valuation was less than some of the other Titians Charles prized so much, “but more than the vast majority of works in the enormous and storied collection, including the now-world-famous Salvator Mundi by Leonardo Da Vinci at £30.”

Charles I’s collection was one of the most stupendous on the planet and he particularly valued his Titians, hanging them at his palace at Whitehall. Saint Margaret hung in the same room as remarkable paintings such as the Allocution of the Marquis del Vasto to his Troops, now in the Prado collection; the Entombment of Christ, now in the Louvre; and Woman in a Fur, now in the Kunsthistorisches Museum in Vienna.

The painting tells the story of Margaret of Antioch, a virgin martyr who refused to marry the prefect of Antioch and was tortured and imprisoned as a result. The legend goes that Satan appeared to her in the form of a dragon and devoured her. FShe managed to escape by using a cross to irritate the monster’s insides.

Scholars believe it was painted in the mid-1560s, one of two versions on the same subject signed by Titian. The prime version is in the Prado in Madrid and scholars believe this second version would have been painted alongside it with greater assistance from his studio.

Nothing is known of what Embry did with the painting, although the assumption is that he chose it in the hope of selling it on. He later became Cromwell’s surveyor general and had awkward questions to answer when the monarchy was restored. He gave the new king, Charles II, some of the paintings, but not the Titian.

After Embry, the painting has been recorded in the collection of an early 18th-century Hampshire MP, Richard Norton – an eccentric known as “Mad Dick”; and the aristocratic Harcourt family of Oxfordshire. It was sold at auction in 1948, for 500 guineas, and subsequently sold by a Swiss dealer in 1959 to the forebear of the present owner.

While the painting will not be in the RA show, it will be part of an online reconstruction of the collection of Charles I at Whitehall Palace. It will also be on view at Sotheby’s New York from 26 January ahead of its sale there on 1 February. It carries an estimate of $2m-3m (£1.5m-£2m).

The RA show opens to the public on Saturday and will include Titians that hung alongside Saint Margaret during Charles I’s lifetime, including Supper at Emmaus, a painting often overlooked by visitors to the Louvre because it hangs in the same room as the Mona Lisa.

(November 15, 2017) 

Leonardo da Vinci’s Salvator Mundi sold for $400 million at Christie’s ($450.3m, including auction house premium)

(May 2, 2012) 

One of four versions of The Scream created by Munch and the only one that is privately owned. The painting sold for $119,922,500

(April 30, 2010) 

Picasso’s Nude, Green Leaves and Bust (1932) sold at Christie's in New York for $106,482,500

(January 12, 2010) 

L’homme qui Marche I (1961) by Alberto Giacometti sold for £65,001,250 ($105,182,398) at Sotheby’s in London

(May 5, 2004) 

Picasso’s Boy With a Pipe (1905) sold at Sotheby's in New York for $104,168,000

(November 8, 2006) 

Gustav Klimt’s Portrait of Adele Bloch-Bauer II (1912)went under the hammer at Christie’s New York and sold for $87,936,000

(April 14, 2008) 

Francis Bacon’s Triptych (1976) sold for $85.9m to oligarch Roman Abramovich

(November 12, 2010) 

A Chinese 18th century Qianlong dynasty porcelain vase sold for £53,100,000 ($85,921,461) at Bainbridges auction house in London

(March 22, 2006) 

Dora Maar au Chat (1941) by Pablo Picasso sold for £51,560,080 ($83,429,503) at Sotheby's in London

(May 15, 1990) 

Portrait of Dr Paul Gachet (1890) by Vincent van Gogh sold for $82,500,000 (£50,985,692) at Christie’s in New York


Mark Brown Arts correspondent

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Charles I: King and Collector review – majestic collection fit for an unfit king
This blockbuster show is chock-full of masterpieces. So why is our critic calling for revolution?

Jonathan Jones

22, Jan, 2018 @6:01 PM

Article image
Framed in mystery: painting tells story of doomed Norfolk family
Years of research uncover lost 17th-century treasures and the song of a pale little girl

Maev Kennedy

21, Jun, 2018 @1:51 PM

Article image
Tate acquires British impressionist painting Le Passeur for £1.5m
Tate Britain puts William Stott of Oldham’s 1881 work Le Passeur (The Ferryman) on public display after buying it for the nation

Mark Brown Arts correspondent

05, May, 2017 @1:18 PM

Article image
Joseph Highmore infanticide painting to be shown in UK for first time
The Angel of Mercy is part of exhibition of artist’s work at Foundling Museum, built to save abandoned children of 1700s London

Maev Kennedy

27, Sep, 2017 @11:10 AM

Article image
Tracey Emin/Edvard Munch: The Loneliness of the Soul review – moments of horror
Royal Academy, London
Munch’s paintings of troubled women are echoed dramatically in Emin’s clamouring images of herself as she struggles to exorcise her demons

Adrian Searle

03, Dec, 2020 @12:11 PM

Article image
Royal Academy Summer Exhibition review – as if the pandemic never happened
Amid a sea of irrelevant doodling, only the BLM room and apocalyptic works by Tracey Emin and Anselm Kiefer are in tune with our troubled times

Jonathan Jones

28, Sep, 2020 @12:58 PM

Article image
American Gothic arrives in London for Royal Academy show
Grant Wood’s 1930 masterpiece had never left North America until it went to Paris three months ago

Mark Brown Arts correspondent

13, Feb, 2017 @4:46 PM

Article image
Royal Academy show to look back at 250 years of Summer Exhibitions
The Great Spectacle, to be held in London in 2018, will illustrate controversies and disputes of art world since 1768

Mark Brown Arts correspondent

05, Jul, 2017 @5:25 PM

Article image
Lost portrait of Charles Dickens turns up at auction in South Africa
Margaret Gillies’ 1843 work, found among trinkets, depicts author as young literary star

Mark Brown Arts correspondent

21, Nov, 2018 @6:00 PM

Article image
Painting the Modern Garden: Monet to Matisse review – thrillingly cosmic
Royal Academy, London
This exhibition of psychedelic modernist pastoral art is a ravishing joy and takes Monet out of the chocolate box, revealing one of art’s great humanists

Jonathan Jones

25, Jan, 2016 @7:30 PM