Price for drug that reverses opioid overdoses soars amid record deaths

Pfizer manufacturing problems leave nonprofits paying exorbitant prices for dwindling supplies of life-saving naloxone

As the United States faces an unprecedented surge in opioid overdoses, harm reduction groups are seeing shortages in naloxone, a usually affordable and easy-to-use medication that reverses overdoses and has been credited with saving many lives.

But it’s not because of a lack of supply; there’s actually plenty of naloxone out there. Instead, the dangerous shortage of naloxone is all about soaring prices.

Community groups working to prevent overdose deaths are now paying up to 30 times more for the life-saving medication – at a time when more Americans than ever are dying from overdoses.

The US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention said on Wednesday that nearly 100,000 people died of overdoses during the first year of the pandemic – a record high and a 30% increase from the year before. A majority of those deaths were caused by opioids, especially drugs tainted with fentanyl, an extremely dangerous substance that is 100 times more potent than morphine.

The simultaneous rise in overdoses and the lack of affordable naloxone is a “perfect storm”, Amanda Latimore, director of the Center for Addiction Research and Effective Solutions, told the Guardian.

“Not having this life-saving medication to reduce overdose deaths, during a time when we’re seeing the greatest increase we’ve ever seen, is a public health crisis. There hasn’t been a more important time than right now to have an overdose reversal drug available. And now that we’re seeing this shortage, we can expect even more fatal overdoses,” she said.

Opioid overdoses can often be reversed with naloxone, which is sold under brand names including Narcan and Nevzio, is safe and effective when administered quickly. The medication can be injected or inhaled.

Drug giant Pfizer reached a deal with the Opioid Safety and Naloxone Network (OSNN) Buyers Club in 2012 to provide its injectable medication at low cost for harm reduction groups, which work closely with people with substance abuse disorders to prevent overdose deaths. But Pfizer ran into problems in manufacturing doses of naloxone earlier this year, and the company temporarily stopped supplying the affordable medication to the community groups battling overdoses. The issues are now fixed, and Pfizer expects to be fully stocked again by the end of the year.

But meanwhile, thousands of people are dying from overdoses without enough medication to reverse them, as other drug firms have not responded to the supply problems by lowering their prices. The drug is now far more expensive for the very providers that need it the most.

“We are being asked to attend a lot more funerals than we ever have before,” said Nabarun Dasgupta, an epidemiologist at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill and an adviser for the OSNN Buyers Club.

“I estimated 12,000 to 18,000 excess deaths if we didn’t get the shortage handled, and I think a good chunk of those deaths have already happened,” he told the Guardian.

There is no reason other companies couldn’t cut their prices to help fill the gaps left by Pfizer’s manufacturing issues, Dasgupta said, except for one:

“Profit. There’s no other way to put it.”

But even if pharmaceutical companies dropped the price for harm reduction groups, he said, they were still “making their profit off institutional buyers”. Hospitals and other care systems can still buy the treatments at previously negotiated prices.

Harm reduction groups used to buy naloxone from Pfizer to create kits that cost about $2.50 each. Now they have to pay $37 for a different generic medication or $75 for Narcan – a 15- to 30-fold increase. They simply haven’t been able to afford enough kits to save everyone’s lives.

“To put it in stark terms, you could be saving one life or you could be saving 10 lives for the same price,” Leo Beletsky, a professor of law and health sciences at Northeastern University, told the Guardian.

Emergent BioSolutions, the company that produces Narcan, has not raised the price since the medication was launched in 2016, a spokesperson told the Guardian in an email, and “provides a discounted price to national, state, and local governmental health and safety entities closest to at-risk populations, including public health clinics, fire departments, and police departments”. But discounts are not offered to harm-reduction organizations.

One harm-reduction group in Colorado is almost out of supplies. “We’re experiencing a shortage in injectable Naloxone in CO and nasal Narcan is expensive at the moment,” the group tweeted this week, with a photo of the nearly empty drawer of medication. “We’re in the worst overdose crisis we’ve ever seen.”

The coronavirus pandemic has “really sparked a surge” and exacerbated existing disparities of who lives and who dies after an overdose, Beletsky said. “It is an absolute crisis.”

And the true extent of pandemic pressures and naloxone shortages is yet unclear. “It takes six months to a year for it to show up in some of the federal datasets,” Latimore said.

The experts wonder why other naloxone producers don’t drop their prices, even temporarily, to cover the gaps.

“For something that is so effective and so safe, there’s no reason why it shouldn’t be more affordable,” Latimore said.

Naloxone is an inexpensive medication that’s been around since the 1970s. Other life-saving medications such as insulin and EpiPens are also sold at prohibitively high costs.

“This is a symptom of broader dysfunction in the US pharmaceutical industry, where public health concerns are secondary to financial concerns,” Beletsky said.

But “it’s not enough to criticize the pharmaceutical industry,” he added. “We should be using the regulatory tools that we have to compel them to act in a different way.”

The federal government could step in to make the prices more affordable and consistent, “but that just hasn’t happened yet”, Latimore said.

Because there are no gaps in supply – only in price – the US Food and Drug Administration hasn’t declared a naloxone shortage.

One solution could be creating public benefit corporations – organizations that produce essential medications for low prices. Such a corporation was proposed in the Purdue Pharma settlement, Beletsky pointed out. The Biden administration could also invoke the Defense Production Act to compel private entities to prioritize manufacturing naloxone under the rationale that the opioid epidemic is a national crisis.

The pandemic may, in fact, pave the way for action. The Cares Act passed last year granted new powers to the FDA for making prescription drugs like naloxone available over the counter, which would significantly reduce ordering issues, Dasgupta said.

“Let me tell you what they’ve used it for: wart removers, anti-flatulence medications and ingrown toenails,” he said.

It’s not that leaders don’t care, Dasgupta said. “What’s been really fascinating in our conversations with federal officials has been not a lack of compassion, but a total blindness to how the system operates in practice,” he said. “​​There’s a huge disconnect between policy and what happens on the ground.”

Requiring pharmaceutical companies to lower prices for naloxone, or creating federally or philanthropically funded programs to buy the drugs, would be relatively inexpensive, he argued. Last year, the buyers club provided 1.3m doses.

“We’re talking about a couple million dollars,” Dasgupta said. “It’s just so small in terms of the [financial] impact around this. It’s really heartbreaking.”

Contributor

Melody Schreiber

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
North Carolina reverses thousands of drug overdoses amid opioid crisis
A state initiative focused on getting drugs into the hands of current users is receiving national attention for stopping more than 3,000 deaths

Timothy Pratt

10, Jun, 2016 @3:13 PM

Article image
US drug overdoses soar to record number in 2020, fueled by pandemic
CDC data shows over 93,000 died from overdoses, a 30% rise from 2019, mostly triggered by pandemic-related stressors

Maya Yang

15, Jul, 2021 @9:41 PM

Article image
US child opioid overdoses increased over past two decades, research finds
America’s opioid crisis has taken top slot as a public health concern a little more than a year after the FDA approved Oxycontin for use among children

Jessica Glenza in New York

31, Oct, 2016 @3:00 PM

Article image
'It's all fentanyl': opioid crisis takes shape in Philadelphia as overdoses surge
Nationally, over the past three years, fentanyl-related deaths have increased by 540%, and the epidemic is felt acutely in Philadelphia’s Kensington area

Edward Helmore in Kensington, Philadelphia

27, Dec, 2017 @6:00 PM

Article image
Rudy Giuliani won deal for OxyContin maker to continue sales of drug behind opioid deaths
The US government secured a criminal conviction against Purdue Pharma in the mid-2000s but failed to curb sales of the drug after Giuliani reached a deal to avoid a bar on Purdue doing business

Chris McGreal in Washington

22, May, 2018 @10:56 AM

Article image
Opioid crisis: overdoses increased by a third across US in 14 months, says CDC
Results show opioid overdoses increasing across all regions and in most states, for most men and women and most age groups

Jessica Glenza in New York

06, Mar, 2018 @6:29 PM

Article image
'Opioid overdoses are skyrocketing': as Covid-19 sweeps across US an old epidemic returns
The pandemic is creating the social conditions – no jobs, isolation, despair – that helped enable the opioid crisis to emerge in the first place. Now it’s back

Chris McGreal

09, Jul, 2020 @10:00 AM

Article image
Opioid crisis: lawmakers accuse drug executives of fueling epidemic
CEOs of the three biggest companies deny contributing to disaster at hearing in Congress, while another executive says he’s ‘deeply sorry’

Chris McGreal in Washington

08, May, 2018 @6:30 PM

Article image
US drug overdose deaths rose to record 72,000 last year, data reveals
CDC figures show drug epidemic – fueled by rise in fentanyl – has become more deadly than gun violence and car accidents

Erin Durkin in New York and agencies

16, Aug, 2018 @1:22 PM

Article image
Why are more Americans than ever dying from drug overdoses?
Deaths from drug overdoses in the US reached staggering new heights in 2017, according to newly published figures. Trump called the crisis a “national shame and human tragedy” – but what is fuelling it?

Niko Kommenda, Erin Durkin and Lydia Smears

29, Nov, 2018 @12:36 PM