The Gone review – it’s the rich, warm characters that make this thriller so compelling

An Irish couple go missing in New Zealand, and a Dublin detective flies in to investigate – but why? As we meet the local Māori community, this crime drama becomes almost a mood piece

If you can forgive the ponderous opening episode and its slightly by-numbers feel, there is much to enjoy in the new six-part police drama The Gone.

When a young Irish couple go missing during a stay in New Zealand, hardbitten-slash-maverick Dublin detective Theo Richter (Richard Flood) flies over to help the local cops investigate, despite the fact that he has just handed in his resignation after 20 years for no reason he is willing to give to his superiors. Unresolved trauma from an old case? Burdened by a secret sorrow? Something is prompting him to pick fights and find distraction in getting beaten to a pulp by thugs, and no doubt we’ll find out soon enough.

Why does New Zealand need Dublin? Because half the missing couple is Sinead Martin (Rachel Morgan), the daughter of Hannah Martin (Michelle Fairley), the judge who recently put away the head of an Irish drug operation run by the Fallon family, who are not the type to let that kind of thing go unpunished. Hannah survived a recent revenge attack – so maybe they have moved on to her family. On the other hand, it is soon discovered that the other half of the missing couple, Ronan Garvey (Simon Mead), was dealing drugs at his gym and had a temper on him that he may have liked to take out on his girlfriend.

Kiwi-side, the couple’s disappearance reminds residents of a pair of murders committed 17 years ago in the same remote rural town, the perpetrator of which was never caught. DS Diana Huai (Acushla-Tara Kupe) has returned to the town, her childhood home, after a long absence. It is clear from the strained relations she has with the inhabitants, including and especially those to whom she is related, that she too is carrying a sorrow that will need to be brought into the light over the next five or six hours.

There is also, as you might possibly already suspect, given the setting and the genre, a new business in town – a giant recycling-cum-fertiliser plant, led by a non-native CEO, who wants to acquire surrounding sacred land amid growing protests from the Māori community. These are led by older, stalwart members – Wiki (Vanessa Rare) and Buster Huia (Wayne Hapi), Diana’s uncle and aunt. They raised her as a child but are now virtually estranged.

Finally, there is Aileen Ryan (Carolyn Bracken), an Irish journalist who has been following the Fallon story for years and has duly pursued Richter to New Zealand to sniff out the latest developments. She proceeds, like most journalists, to cause nothing but trouble.

Once the opening episode has put all the pieces in play, the plot thickens (sometimes with so much indistinct dialogue that you feel but one more gobbet of half-audible information away from losing the thread entirely) and becomes intriguing, if not propulsive.

What really separates The Gone from the common herd, however, is the presence of Wiki and Buster. Flood and Kupe do their best as the detectives, but their parts are essentially colourless, merely functional. Wiki and Buster are rich, warm character studies, bringing emotional depth and – as we move into their story – sometimes joy, and sometimes an aching sadness. Their scenes – individually or together – breathe life into the whole. They help shift The Gone into something approaching a mood piece – a meditation on the importance of connection to each other (they have been together 30 years, mostly running a safe house for troubled teenagers). It becomes a homage to a town (the difference it makes to know generations of the people around you is often evoked, particularly in the long friendship between Wiki and a local police sergeant), and also to the land (there is a lovely exchange about the “fucking English” and their propensity to take that which does not belong to them).

Evidence of foul play mounts, clues are uncovered, leads are followed, libellous articles are published. A Fallon is found to have made his way to New Zealand too, people are endangered, CEOs become increasingly anxious as investors become increasingly spooked, bits of plot join up, then other bits come along and complicate things all over again. Violence builds and erupts – and yes, secret sorrows are aired and childhood traumas resolved. Though the script sometimes stumbles, there are also enough moments of wry humour and resonant truth to keep the whole thing more than merely watchable. If you need something else to tip you over the edge, there’s the scenery too. How New Zealanders get anything done with the vistas spread before them I do not know.

  • The Gone is on BBC Four and is available on BBC iPlayer, and on Apple TV and Amazon Prime Video in Australia.

Contributor

Lucy Mangan

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Passenger review – this supernatural thriller is scarily fresh
Confident, atmospheric and packed with creepy realism, this drama – starring Wunmi Mosaku as a copper trapped in a small town – is a convincingly detail-oriented paranormal horror

Lucy Mangan

24, Mar, 2024 @10:00 PM

Article image
Hijack review – Idris Elba makes this beautifully daft plane thriller soar
The Luther star is majestically charismatic in this real-time hijack drama. He is the rock on which seven hours of brilliant, bingeable nonsense are based

Lucy Mangan

28, Jun, 2023 @5:00 AM

Article image
Without Sin review – Vicky McClure is fantastic in this heavyweight thriller
The Line of Duty star is predictably great as she wrestles with the grief of her daughter’s murder in a top-notch conspiracy drama

Rebecca Nicholson

28, Dec, 2022 @9:00 AM

Article image
Platform 7 review – this tedious thriller is a waste of good actors
The paper-thin script on this mystery drama about a suspicious death makes for a very long watch. It’s a shame, seeing as it features stars like Top Boy’s Jasmine Jobson and Phil Davis

Lucy Mangan

07, Dec, 2023 @5:00 AM

Article image
Wolf review – this totally wild thriller has to be seen to be believed
This adaptation of Mo Hayder’s novel is absolutely out there. Conspiracy! Murder! Camp comedy! It’s like two shows smashed together – and the bizarre results are addictive

Lucy Mangan

31, Jul, 2023 @9:00 PM

Article image
The Patient review – Steve Carell is absolutely faultless in this intense kidnap thriller
The Office star plays a kidnapped therapist in this claustrophobic two-hander with Domhnall Gleeson. It might be slow going, but the performances are utterly stellar

Lucy Mangan

30, Nov, 2022 @12:50 PM

Article image
Obsession review – the actors in this erotic thriller all seem to need the toilet
Presumably the odd facial expressions in this woeful drama are meant to say ‘barely controllable lust’. They actually say: ‘really regretting that bad oyster’

Lucy Mangan

13, Apr, 2023 @5:00 AM

Article image
TikTok: Murder Gone Viral review – this documentary’s social media obsession is utterly bizarre
Two of these killers had a perverse mother-daughter dynamic that would make Freud faint. So why is this show so determined to unconvincingly pin the blame on TikTok?

Leila Latif

30, Jan, 2024 @10:00 PM

Article image
Beef review – Ali Wong’s dark, existential thriller is deliciously subversive
Entertaining chaos and extremely funny dialogue result from this Netflix show about two rage-fuelled drivers having a life-affirming feud. It’s a rare delicacy

Ellen E Jones

06, Apr, 2023 @5:00 AM

Article image
Dark Matter review – Joel Edgerton abducts himself in fun multiverse thriller
It’s a fascinating premise – a physics genius creates a way to go to a parallel universe and switch places with his less successful self. If only this series weren’t about five universes too long

Lucy Mangan

08, May, 2024 @5:00 AM