The Sex Lives of College Girls review – this comedy’s spectacular chemistry makes it the modern-day Friends

The gang of pitch-perfect actors give this show the perfect, elusive blend of truthful, joyful and funny

I have been remiss. I realise now, as its second series begins, that I have neglected to proclaim to you at every possible opportunity over these last few vexing years that help was at hand to smooth your passage through the dark days. I apologise unreservedly and say now: let The Sex Lives of College Girls (ITVX) comfort you and, also, I must state that it is not porn because I know that’s what you’re thinking. It is the creation of writer, actor, director and production powerhouse Mindy Kaling (The Office, Never Have I Ever, The Mindy Project) and Justin Noble (a writer on Brooklyn Nine-Nine and Never Have I Ever) and is the perfect, elusive blend of truthful, joyful and funny.

It focuses on the adventures and misadventures (often genital based) of a quartet of roommate freshers at the fancy fictional Essex College in Vermont. Whitney (Alyah Chanelle Scott) is a star soccer player whose mother is a US senator, which in the first series made it all the more important that she didn’t find out Whitney was having an affair with her assistant soccer coach. The parents of Indian-American Bela (Amrit Kaur) were equally shielded from the knowledge that their daughter was less interested in her neuroscience studies than she was in becoming a comedy writer and topographer of shredded frat boys. Leighton (Reneé Rapp) is the rich legacy student from the Upper East Side – an all-American blonde from a picture-perfect family that will shatter if they discover she is gay. And sweet Kimberly (Pauline Chalamet – yes, sister of Timothée), as naive and enthusiastic as a labrador puppy, is a small-town scholarship girl who has to navigate all the barriers life among the moneyed elite brings. Individually, the actors are pitch-perfect. Together, they are something special. At their best they remind you of the Friends’ chemistry which – whatever you thought of the show then or think of it now – was spectacular.

The second series picks up more or less where we left off. The girls are back after Thanksgiving break. Whitney – and her mother – have weathered the breaking of the coach storm and Whitney is with lovely Canaan (Christopher Meyer), who is almost worthy of her. But it is the soccer off-season and unlike her teammates, all busy with activities to pad out their graduate CVs, Whitney struggles to find a second string to her bow. Leighton hasn’t come out to her family but by the end of the first episode is out to all her roommates and over the next few episodes embarks on the odyssey of exploration, with all its delights and mistakes, that we watched her straight peers navigate last season. Bela – who spent her first term learning that the majority of comedy writers are a) pricks and b) start young – is now set on forming an all-female enclave, hampered only by the fact that all the volunteers for it are “unfunny turds”. And Kimberly, stripped of her scholarship by her midterm exam scandal (which has also seen off several Thetas) has to find a way of coming up with $23,000 tuition a term without her parents finding out.

There is a new guy down the hall, Jackson (of great topographical interest to them all). He (played by Mitchell Slaggert) is a climate refugee from Kansas – his school blew away in a tornado – who has distractingly loud sex with many different girls but by the end of the third episode is beginning to form a bond with Kimberly.

All is, in short, as it was. The girls throw themselves headlong into life, the jokes come thick and fast, the main players strike sparks off each other and the supporting cast are just as good. There is less Willow (Renika Williams), so far, than last time, which is a great sadness. But the rest are all present, correct and adding to the general sense of a show bursting with good things: talent, energy and wit to burn. It takes on the big and small stuff that makes up college life, allows some hugging and some learning without becoming smothered by schmaltz and lets us relive, for 20-odd minutes at least, those halcyon days when the world was tiny and we were the biggest things in it. Sometimes, I wish the programme could slow down a little and let some of its moments breathe, but that’s probably just because I am older – possibly older than Essex itself – and need my tablets. Still, it will leave you better than it found you, and who can really ask for more than that?

  • The Sex Lives of College Girls is streaming on ITVX in the UK, and in Australia on Binge and Foxtel Now

Contributor

Lucy Mangan

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Somebody Somewhere season two review – even this uplifting comedy’s quietest moments are dazzling
Every subtle scene is stuffed with emotion, poignancy and a great sense of humour. It’s a lovely antidote to TV’s more stressful shows

Rebecca Nicholson

06, Jun, 2023 @8:35 PM

Article image
Such Brave Girls review – properly brutal and properly funny
There is a particular joy in seeing a woman-led, female-written sitcom that revels in plumbing the depths. It is scabrous, unflinching – and hilarious

Lucy Mangan

22, Nov, 2023 @10:25 PM

Article image
Smothered review – this fresh twist on a romcom is utterly lovely
Don’t expect histrionics from this comedy about the practicalities of love. It’s a sweet, deeply nice take on romance that is extremely watchable

Rebecca Nicholson

07, Dec, 2023 @10:30 PM

Article image
Ted review – this foul-mouthed teddy bear sitcom doesn’t feature a single funny joke
Seth MacFarlane’s animated comedy prequel is like a deliberate attempt to ignore everything its creator has ever learned. Bloated episodes drag on without raising a smile – it’s a total disappointment

Lucy Mangan

09, Feb, 2024 @10:00 PM

Article image
Ghosts US review – remove the original sitcom’s best bits and you have … this
This American remake of the BBC comedy is less thoughtful, less nuanced, less … good. But the brilliance of its premise means it’s still fun

Jack Seale

20, Nov, 2022 @8:55 PM

Article image
Dad’s Army: The Animations review – excellent lost episodes complete the comedy’s canon
Early audio recordings of the classic sitcom are brought back to life, but while it doesn’t quite capture the show’s deepest joys, this is a comforting dose of nostalgia

Jack Seale

06, Nov, 2023 @8:30 PM

Article image
Everyone Else Burns review – a comedy to become religiously devoted to
Simon Bird stars in a sitcom about a family caught up in an evangelical sect. And with perfect jokes that come this thick and fast, you’ll be an instant convert

Lucy Mangan

23, Jan, 2023 @10:35 PM

Article image
​​Ghosts Christmas Special review – a beautiful farewell to a sublime sitcom
If you ever needed a sign that this comedy had reached classic status, this clever, spiky finale is it. It’s a perfectly-timed end to a show that will be sorely missed

Jack Seale

25, Dec, 2023 @8:15 PM

Article image
Big Mood review – Nicola Coughlan is a force of nature
The Derry Girls actor is funny to her bones in this sitcom about mental health and long-term friendship. It’s full of lovely touches, if not enough nuance

Lucy Mangan

28, Mar, 2024 @10:35 PM

Article image
How to With John Wilson review – as disturbing, hilarious and genius as ever
In its final series, Wilson’s meditations on the loneliness and silliness of modern life remain a glorious treat. One of the funniest shows on television is certainly bowing out on a high

Jack Seale

08, Mar, 2024 @11:35 PM