Vigil finale review – an anxiety-inducing horror spectacular

A clock-ticking, claustrophobic finale had DCI Silva in a cat-and-mouse game with a shifty Russian asset. If only they’d given her a map

Read the Vigil finale recap and join the discussion here

Vigil (BBC One) concluded in nightmarishly claustrophobic style. Not content with sticking half of the cast on a large metal tube under water, it trapped noted hater-of-small-spaces DCI Amy Silva in a tiny metal tube under water, filled the tube with water, drained it of water, only for the larger metal tube to start filling with water, and honestly, after half an hour of tension like that, I needed a lie down, in a very big, wide, airy open space.

Vigil has given us six solid weeks of credulity-testing twists and turns, but it has never relented, and buckling up for the hour has been a large part of the fun. It is television from the Bodyguard school, expertly ramping up the stress until it becomes relentless, then adding another shocker into the mix, just because it can. Yes, it is far-fetched (at least, you must hope it is): HMS Vigil is the kind of submarine where a crew member could accidentally sit on the “launch nukes” button and you wouldn’t bat an eyelid. But it has been thrilling.

The finale did everything it needed to do. Of course the Russian asset was Doward; the sonar operator who was brand new, apparently failed to notice a massive tanker passing over the submarine, and looked very shifty indeed. He also appeared to become, in the tradition of all monstrous screen villains, briefly unkillable, like a T-1000 made of sinister glances, headphones and pure gall. Luckily for Silva, Prentice had, by chance, already flushed the tube before he came to rescue her (thank heavens for the “cancel tube flood cycle” button), eventually saving her life by tracking her increasingly tepid morse code and hauling her out of there.

Here, the show pivoted to all-out horror spectacular, and I loved the Alien/slasher sequence, as surprisingly nasty and horrible as it turned out to be. Suranne Jones makes an excellent Sigourney Weaver-type action hero and I hope there is more of this kind of thing for her in future. She had to thwart a bloodied Doward staggering around in a gas mask waving a knife, after having only recently lost consciousness and almost dying. She ran around trying not to breathe in bleach, probably wishing she’d been given a safety-on-board laminate when she arrived, or at the very least, a map.

While this cat-and-mouse game played out, Doward’s earlier sabotage began to sink the boat quicker than you can say, did someone pull out the plug? Naturally, this gave the rest of the crew a squeaky-bum time limit of 10 minutes to fix it, or else the entire crew would be done for. In the end, teamwork won the day, though Silva’s ability to deliver the news of a beloved crew member’s death by loudly charging the suspect with his murder suggests she may need some tactfulness training.

Throughout, Vigil has been a rich and sometimes sickly meal. Just one of its anxiety-inducing scenarios would be enough for most dramas, but this had international conflict, political intrigue, claustrophobic horror, psychological trauma, murder,cops, romance and nerve agents thrown in and set to various clock-ticking countdowns. When the story inevitably moved back to land, it became more sober, wrapping up loose ends, rather sentimentally and unexpectedly saving a life, and resolving the love story between Silva and DS Longacre. (I note that the “chatty bath for two” cliche that haunts on-screen same-sex romances still held strong here.) By the time everyone was safe and sound, Russia had been accused without technically being accused, and nuclear disarmament was dismissed as impossibly tricky, it was hard to deny that they’d earned a bit of soppiness.

But soppiness was never Vigil’s forte. This was big, brash television, designed to thrill, excite and terrify. To paraphrase the ad hoc eulogy given by Cmdr Newsome: it did its job. It did it well.

Contributor

Rebecca Nicholson

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Vigil finale recap – a thrilling white-knuckle voyage
As the submarine saga concluded, we returned to the navy’s most accident-prone boat for the final time. Would the spy be outed? And would Silva and her cat make it out alive?

Michael Hogan

26, Sep, 2021 @9:00 PM

Article image
I Am Victoria review – a masterclass in what pushes a woman to the edge
In the new series of Dominic Savage’s searingly truthful dramas, Suranne Jones plays a mother trying to do it all … and hurtling towards a meltdown

Lucy Mangan

05, Aug, 2021 @9:00 PM

Article image
Vigil review – Suranne Jones feels the pressure in sharp submarine thriller
Martin Compston is in trouble and Jones’s detective must calm the troubled seas, in a murky marine drama that delivers solid, old-fashioned entertainment

Lucy Mangan

29, Aug, 2021 @9:00 PM

Article image
Vigil series two review – Suranne Jones’s thriller doesn’t need a submarine to be brilliant
Political truth bombs are dropped Spooks-style as our intrepid detective is embroiled in murky goings-on in a fictional middle-eastern dictatorship – what could be more scary?

Jack Seale

10, Dec, 2023 @10:00 PM

Article image
Christmas Carole review – Suranne Jones is pitch perfect in this instant festive classic
From a ghostly Morecambe and Wise to high-kicking dance numbers, this modern retelling of the Dickens classic is absolutely glorious

Lucy Mangan

24, Dec, 2022 @9:30 PM

Article image
We Own This City review – like The Wire, but about real corrupt cops. What a horror show
David Simon’s swaggering new series might remind you of The Wire, but We Own This City is based on a true case of mass police corruption in Baltimore – which makes it all the more disturbing

Rebecca Nicholson

07, Jun, 2022 @9:05 PM

Article image
Derry Girls finale review – absolutely cracker
This perfectly proportioned ending tugs at the heartstrings, and delivers the funniest TV scene of the year bar none. Rarely does a comedy bow out on such a high

Rebecca Nicholson

18, May, 2022 @9:04 PM

Article image
Vigil episode one recap – what a maritime humdinger. Consider us hooked!
The BBC’s new sub-aqua blockbuster from the Line of Duty producers is like HMS AC-12 – and it got off to a storming start

Michael Hogan

29, Aug, 2021 @9:00 PM

Article image
Vigil episode four recap – Silva and the crew are in deep water
As Suranne Jones’s detective continues her submarine snooping, more details of blackmail, Port Havers and poor Jade’s death rise to the surface

Michael Hogan

12, Sep, 2021 @9:00 PM

Article image
Deceit review – Rachel Nickell drama probes the ethics of entrapment
Niamh Algar puts in a phenomenal performance in this four-parter about the controversial undercover police operation which followed Nickell’s death, and events that beggar belief

Lucy Mangan

13, Aug, 2021 @9:00 PM