South Africa raise ball tampering concerns about England

• Any official complaint must be made by start of play tomorrow
• Stuart Broad insists he was merely stopping the ball with foot

England's cricketers are at the centre of a ball-tampering row after South Africa "raised concerns" with the match referee, Roshan Mahanama.

On the hottest day of the tour so far, England's bowlers had already felt the heat as South Africa took charge of the third Test, scoring 312 for two to take a lead of 330 at the end of the third day. But things got even warmer at the end of play when Cricket South Africa revealed that it had spoken with Mahanama regarding the condition of the ball, though no official complaint was lodged.

Television cameras showed Stuart Broad stopping a straight drive with the sole of his boot during the opening session of play. His fellow England fast bowler Jimmy Anderson was also seen picking at scuffs on the ball. The footage was replayed several times on local TV. When the players took the field after lunch both umpires, Daryl Harper and Tony Hill, were seen speaking with the England captain, Andrew Strauss.

A CSA spokesman said: "There have been several queries from the media about video footage shown today, and certain allegations being made about the ball. We have raised our concerns with the match referee about it and we've left it to him to decide if any further action or investigation is necessary."

Mahanama said: "There are certain protocols to be observed and I have received no official complaint. It has been a long hot day." He added that if South Africa were to take the matter any further the official documentation would have to be in place before the start of playtomorrow.

Unless that documentation is put in place first thing there will be strong suspicions that South Africa are employing gamesmanship. An England spokesman said: "We totally refute any suggestions of ball tampering or malpractice."

Broad was said to be "bemused" and that it was laziness that made him stop the ball with his boot. Neither the umpires nor the match referee spoke about the incident with the England management, who are understood to be furious about the suggestions.

At the close, England's coach, Andy Flower, said: "The umpires or match referee haven't said anything to us about that. That's the first I've heard of it. I think over the years we have seen a lot of tall fast bowlers stop balls with their feet, so I don't see anything sinister in it all."

If England did do anything sinister they did not do it very well. They failed to take a wicket for 54 overs while South Africa's captain, Graeme Smith, (162no) and Hashim Amla (95) put on 230, a second-wicket Test record for the ground.

Contributor

Paul Weaver in Cape Town

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Michael Vaughan calls England 'silly' as ball-tampering case is thrown out
Michael Vaughan has criticised Stuart Broad and Jimmy Anderson despite the ICC ruling out taking any action

Paul Weaver at Newlands

06, Jan, 2010 @8:59 PM

Article image
Graeme Swann swoops to help England destroy shambolic South Africa
It was fitting that Graeme Swann took two of the four wickets which sealed a crushing England win on the final morning in Durban

Mike Selvey at Kingsmead

30, Dec, 2009 @11:52 AM

Article image
Andrew Strauss sweats on England bowlers' fitness in South Africa
The decision to use a four-man attack in the first Test has backfired after Graham Onions strained his calf

Paul Weaver at Centurion

16, Dec, 2009 @7:00 PM

Article image
Jacques Kallis takes South Africa to strong position against England
Jacques Kallis scored his 33rd Test century to ensure that South Africa emerged from the first day of the third Test at Newlands in good shape

Mike Selvey at Newlands

03, Jan, 2010 @7:02 PM

Article image
Inspired England push panicked South Africa to the brink
A madcap hour either side of the tea interval put Andrew Strauss's men on the verge of victory in the second Test

Mike Selvey at Kingsmead

29, Dec, 2009 @5:26 PM

Article image
England unable to mask bowlers' failings as South Africa level series

England's bowlers struggled against a rampant AB De Villiers as South Africa won the third one-day international by 112 runs

Paul Weaver in Cape Town

27, Nov, 2009 @10:26 PM

Article image
Andrew Strauss hails bowlers as England take charge in South Africa
The England captain praised James Anderson but urged caution after victory in the fourth ODI put England in a commanding position in the series

Paul Weaver in Port Elizabeth

29, Nov, 2009 @5:48 PM

Article image
England accused of persistent cheating during Test series by South Africa
AB de Villiers said that England's cricketers were guilty of working on the ball at the second Test in Durban as well as in Cape Town

Paul Weaver at Newlands

06, Jan, 2010 @9:46 PM

Article image
England beat South Africa by one run on Duckworth/Lewis method
Eoin Morgan scored a brilliant unbeaten 85 as England beat South Africa on the Duckworth/Lewis method

Paul Weaver in Johannesburg

13, Nov, 2009 @9:31 PM

Article image
England win tug of love for Craig Kieswetter
Craig Kieswetter, Somerset's South African-born wicketkeeper batsman, has pledged his future to England

Paul Weaver in Johannesburg

13, Nov, 2009 @5:47 PM