Thatcher’s enduring legacy and most heinous sin | Letters

David Redshaw is staggered by Keir Starmer’s admiration for her, Brian Hughes says her government created the illusion of an economic miracle, while Charles EL Gilman disputes her total hostility to the EU

Andy Beckett’s takedown of the Thatcherite myth is timely (Margaret Thatcher set Britain’s decline in motion – so why can’t politics exorcise her ghost?, 12 April). Most remarkable is Keir Starmer’s admiration for the “entrepreneurialism” she let loose. Starmer is clearly stuck in his New Romantic era and hasn’t done his history.

The biggest burst of entrepreneurship came in the pre-Thatcher 1960s. The young Turks who burst into the music industry through the side door. The fashion revolution in Carnaby Street and Kings Road. The new magazines, including the very first glossy women’s rights publication. And, sneering rightwingers might note, I don’t think there was the proverbial politics of envy. I think we rather admired Terence Conran, whose airy Habitat emporiums offered well-designed homeware at affordable prices. It all made Britain suddenly world famous.

The only entrepreneurial activity Thatcher let loose was in the late 1980s when, having devastated the northern industries, she and Nigel Lawson devised a way of kickstarting the economy by deregulating the financial sector and offering people criminally stupid amounts of credit – a gambit that predictably went pop in 1990 and contributed to her demise. Let’s have less Daily Mail mythology and more accurate history please, Keir.
David Redshaw
Saltdean, East Sussex

• In his excellent piece about Margaret Thatcher’s ongoing influence, Andy Beckett has perhaps overlooked her most heinous sin. Her government, to the horror of Harold Macmillan, used the proceeds of privatisation not to invest in infrastructure or other capital projects but to fritter away on tax cuts and giving an illusion of an economic miracle.

It did the same with North Sea oil revenues. Norway was the only other European country to have the great good fortune to become self-sufficient in the black gold. It used the rewards to improve its infrastructure and to build up a fund to protect against future economic problems. The Thatcher government frittered ours away just as it had when selling our national assets.

Now instead the Tories are building up massive public debts, in effect stealing from future taxpayers. It’s no surprise that we boomers are often despised for our lucky lives. In the 1980s, thanks to Thatcher and her acolytes, we stole from previous generations; the public companies we sold had been built up using money from millions of customers and taxpayers. Now we are in effect doing it to generations younger than ours.
Brian Hughes
Cheltenham, Gloucestershire

• It is strange that those who have held frontbench office at Westminster since Boris Johnson’s disastrous purge claim to be Thatcherites, for they are actually something startling different. Margaret Thatcher was always a remainer, like the purge’s victims. While ambivalent to certain European institutions and policies, she was never, as Andy Beckett suggests she was, hostile to the entire project. She campaigned for reform from within – and sometimes achieved it, such as the common agricultural policy rebate. As an incumbent prime minister she fought – and defeated, preventing a 1980s Brexit – a Labour party far more hostile to the European project. So far from being Thatcherites, this decade’s Conservative leadership are Footites, at least on Europe.
Charles EL Gilman
Mitcham, Surrey

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
UK industrial decline not all Margaret Thatcher’s fault | Letters
Letters: Industrial employment in Britain began to decline in the 1950s, and in the two decades before Thatcher came to power hundreds of thousands of such jobs were lost

Letters

29, Jun, 2016 @7:01 PM

Article image
The questionable legacy of Theresa May | Letters
Letters: Allegra Madgwick challenges the idea that the prime minister is a feminist champion, Hester Doherty questions how she stood up for domestic abuse victims, and Judy Stober thinks we are too kind. Plus letters from Les Bright, Mark Lewinski, Kip Bennett and Tony Cole

Letters

19, Jul, 2019 @4:26 PM

Article image
Brussels’ failings on eurozone and Brexit | Letters
Letters: Peter Muchlinski says Brussels needs to wake up and offer a cooperative solution to Brexit. Michael Cunningham says Peter Mandelson’s endorsement of neoliberalism helped to lead us to Brexit

Letters

24, Feb, 2019 @6:05 PM

Article image
English language usage and politicians’ prowess | Letters
Letters: Terence McSweeney explains why English is often used internationally, Steve Callaghan says politicians need to invest in modern language teaching across all sectors, Philip Stewart recalls a teacher exchange scheme shunned by Thatcher, Anke Neibig explains why fewer students are taking up languages, and Paul Tattam on how the media can help

Letters

14, Apr, 2019 @5:12 PM

Article image
Brexit cost us the only good thing Margaret Thatcher did | William Keegan
Now that the UK has been taken out of trade zone, we are left only with the damage she wreaked on the British polity

William Keegan

21, Jan, 2024 @7:00 AM

Article image
Margaret Thatcher’s supposed view on the EU will fire up the right | Matthew d’Ancona
For all that she’s seen as a champion for Brexiters, the in campaign will now try to claim her as their own

Matthew d'Ancona

07, Feb, 2016 @7:25 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on fishing and Brexit: still on the hook | Editorial
Editorial: Britain’s politicians have again been found out for making promises to fishing communities that they can’t deliver

Editorial

20, Mar, 2018 @6:47 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on Corbynomics: more creativity please | Editorial
Editorial: the Labour party should be congratulated for its progressive economic ideas. But as Tory MPs prepare to drop austerity and start spending, the opposition needs to be bolder

Editorial

27, May, 2018 @4:00 PM

Article image
Hard Brexit would leave British people poorer – Labour MPs | Letter
Letter: Advocates of a hard Brexit need to swap rhetoric for answers. Which sectors do they think can survive facing new trade barriers? Which new trade deals will be signed, when and with whom?

Letters

21, Nov, 2016 @7:00 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on the UK economy: before Brexit, rescue it from austerity | Editorial
Editorial: The public want the government to spend more, yet the Tories cannot grasp how this makes economic and political sense

Editorial

11, Feb, 2019 @6:30 PM