Home Office crime warning blindingly obvious, says minister

Tony McNulty says there is nothing unusual about leaked letter warning of effects of economic downturn on crime and extremism

Tony McNulty, the policing minister, today said a leaked Home Office letter suggesting that the economic downturn could lead to an increase in crime and support for extremism was "a statement of the blindingly obvious".

Speaking on BBC Radio 4's Today programme this morning, McNulty said that there was nothing unusual about the draft letter, which was drawn up by officials for Jacqui Smith, the home secretary, to send to Downing Street.

Yesterday the Tories claimed that its contents showed that the government was being complacent about the scale of the problems facing Britain. It was released the day after Alistair Darling warned in Saturday's Guardian that the economic conditions are "arguably the worst" in 60 years.

The document warns that a downturn may lead to:

• an increase in support for "far right extremism and racism",

• a possible increase in support for radical Islamist groups from people who experience racism and possible unemployment,

• an "upward pressure on acquisitive crime", property crime, which increases during a downturn,

• an increase in public hostility to migrants as the job market tightens, and

• a fall in the use of cocaine and drunken disorder in town centres unless drinks companies respond to the downturn by aggressive price cutting.

Asked about the leak this morning, McNulty said he agreed with the assessment of the BBC's political editor, Nick Robinson, who had said that the letter could be seen as "a statement of the blindingly obvious".

McNulty explained: "Previous experience dictates that, to an extent, when you do have a slowdown in the economy, some aspects of crime may go up. There may be some difficulties in terms of how people interact with people coming into the country … but it's obvious stuff."

The minister said it was "perfectly normal" for the Home Office to keep the prime minister informed about the possible effects of the economic downturn. He said that people would be "astonished" if the Home Office was not looking into these issues.

He also stressed that the draft letter said that "we are better placed now than we were with equivalent problems in the 70s and 90s to tackle them."

Contributors

Nicholas Watt and Andrew Sparrow

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Crime warning raises pressure on Brown

Home office says slump will bring rise in racism, extremism and theft

Nicholas Watt, chief political correspondent

31, Aug, 2008 @11:01 PM

Article image
Riots policy warning from Lib Dem Home Office minister
Lynne Featherstone writes in her local newspaper that government must not 'jump to conclusions' in riots postmortem

Allegra Stratton

25, Aug, 2011 @12:52 PM

Rise in violent crime due to police undercounting, Home Office says

Inaccurate record-keeping blamed for 22% rise in number of most serious violent crimes in England and Wales

David Batty

23, Oct, 2008 @10:00 AM

Article image
Home Office blames violent crime rise on police undercounting

Officials say at least 13 forces in England and Wales have been undercounting crimes that should have been classified as GBH

Alan Travis, home affairs editor

23, Oct, 2008 @11:23 AM

Minister branded 'out of touch' for unemployment comment
Conservatives criticise employment minister Tony McNulty for saying there was 'light at the end of the tunnel' after new data showed UK jobless total nearing 2 million

Staff and agencies

21, Jan, 2009 @3:19 PM

Minister admits crime failures
Britain's criminal justice system is failing people with lawyers cynically manipulating the system and too many offenders slipping through the net, says a damning assessment by Lord Falconer, the minister in charge of overhauling it.

Jackie Ashley and Alan Travis

17, Jun, 2002 @10:25 AM

Home Office drive to keep crime down during recession

Jacqui Smith launches £1.6m national crime prevention campaign

Deborah Summers

17, Feb, 2009 @12:48 PM

Home Office

Target

15, Jul, 2002 @8:07 AM

Article image
'Bad parent' state is failing to halt crime, says policing minister
Nick Herbert says 'today's offenders grew up in New Labour's years' as he outlines approach to cutting reoffending

Nicholas Watt, chief political correspondent

22, Apr, 2012 @9:08 PM

Home Office holds up probation privatisation
The government drops its plans to privatise the probation service after criticism from judges, magistrates and more than 80 backbench Labour MPs

Alan Travis, home affairs editor

19, Jan, 2006 @2:07 AM