The Guardian view on Afghanistan’s future: withdrawal should not mean abandonment | Editorial

Last week’s massacre of schoolgirls showed just how grim the years ahead could be. The US and its allies cannot disclaim responsibility

The three-day Eid ceasefire announced by the Taliban is a rare and brief respite for Afghans. The country is reeling from last week’s devastating suicide bombing of a school in Kabul that killed at least 85 people, mostly girls aged between 11 and 17. The massacre took place in the same neighbourhood where a maternity unit was lethally attacked a year ago, and which is home to many from the predominantly Shia Hazara minority, who in recent years have been repeatedly slaughtered in attacks on civilian targets. Coming shortly after the US and Nato announced the withdrawal of all troops by 11 September this year, it is another terrifying indication of what lies ahead for Afghans.

“It’s time to end the forever war,” the US president, Joe Biden, said as he announced the US’s departure last month. Americans can walk away, but Afghans cannot. They have lived through conflict for four decades, not two: the vast majority have never known peace. Civilian casualties have already returned to their 2019 levels and analysts predict that it is likely to worsen as the Taliban battle with the Afghan national security forces, and Islamic State fights both.

Many of those who refused to leave their country, at immense personal cost over the past decade, are finally concluding that they cannot stay, given the rising violence, the likelihood of increased Taliban control and the group’s rule in the swathes of territory that it already holds. The great fear is that history will repeat itself. After Soviet troops withdrew in 1989, the country slid into civil war, destroying lives, homes and families and helping give birth to the Taliban. Instability in Afghanistan can ripple out far more widely.

Though the US has finally acknowledged that it cannot determine Afghanistan’s future, it should not pretend that it has no responsibility for what happens to its inhabitants. There is a widespread longing for peace, security and access to essential services. The US and UK invoked women’s rights to justify the invasion of Afghanistan. If that was cynical, it would be much more so to abandon them now, in a country where less than 30% of women can read, but girls and their families make immense sacrifices for an education.

The Biden administration and its allies must continue to press for human rights and for proper accountability for atrocities such as the school attack. The Afghan Independent Human Rights Commission’s call for a UN investigation should be strongly backed. Whoever rules the country, foreign aid will be required to give people access to services such as education and health. There is concern not only that funders are increasingly stingy, but also that they may not make good on existing promises. The west has walked away from the battlefield; it must not walk away from the Afghan people.

Contributor

Editorial

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The Guardian view on the Afghanistan withdrawal: an unwinnable war | Editorial
Editorial: Joe Biden has called time on America’s longest war. The decision exposes the limits of US power and leaves an uncertain future

Editorial

15, Apr, 2021 @5:30 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on Afghanistan withdrawal: a retreat into uncertainty | Editorial
Editorial: Joe Biden’s actions will be felt most keenly in Kabul, but they pose a broader question for an army-dominated Pakistan

Editorial

05, Jul, 2021 @6:20 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on Afghanistan: war and peace talks | Editorial
Editorial: The government and its foreign allies have taken more civilian lives than the Taliban and others this year. A deal is needed to end America’s longest-running conflict – but not a botch job

Editorial

30, Jul, 2019 @5:38 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on Afghanistan: unnecessary suffering | Editorial
Editorial: A reckless western withdrawal timetable has let a people down

Editorial

16, Aug, 2021 @6:29 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on the G7’s great game: the Taliban rules in Kabul | Editorial
Editorial: Ordinary Afghans will pay the highest price for the west’s defeated ambitions

Editorial

24, Aug, 2021 @6:01 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on the Taliban’s advance: not an American debacle but Afghans’ tragedy
Editorial: People are losing their homes, their freedom and their hope. That should be more of a priority than US credibility

Editorial

13, Aug, 2021 @5:03 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on Britain’s Afghan failure: a military and political disaster | Editorial
Editorial: The fall of Kabul to the Taliban should spark a more honest debate about the UK’s unconditional support for US plans

Editorial

17, Aug, 2021 @6:18 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on the Taliban’s advance: we still have a responsibility to Afghans | Editorial
Editorial: The human cost is accumulating with the withdrawal of US and British troops

Editorial

06, Aug, 2021 @5:25 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on Afghanistan: chaos turns to carnage | Editorial
Editorial: The attack on Kabul airport underlines the west’s obligations, which do not end with the occupation

Editorial

27, Aug, 2021 @5:30 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on the G7 Afghanistan talks: desperate damage limitation | Editorial
Editorial: Lack of planning and coordination has left the west scrambling to do the right thing

Editorial

23, Aug, 2021 @5:30 PM