Outrage as Brazil law threatening Indigenous lands advances in congress

Critics denounced ‘lies, hatred and racism’ as legislation moves to senate after being overwhelmingly endorsed by lower house

Indigenous leaders and environmentalists in Brazil have voiced horror and indignation after lawmakers approved controversial legislation which opponents fear will strike a devastating blow to Indigenous communities and isolated tribes.

Members of Brazil’s conservative-dominated lower house overwhelmingly endorsed bill number 490 on Tuesday night, by 283 votes to 155.

“You will have Indigenous blood on your hands,” the Indigenous congresswoman Célia Xakriabá told its rightwing backers as leftwingers took to the podium to protest by smothering their hands in the red dye of annatto seeds.

Critics say the legislation, which now moves to the senate, poses a series of profound threats to Indigenous communities and the environment:

• It potentially opens the door to road-building, mining, dam construction, agricultural projects and the use of genetically modified crops on protected Indigenous lands, as well as authorizing contact with isolated Indigenous groups in certain circumstances.

• It would allow the government to reclaim land from Indigenous communities whose “cultural traits” are deemed to have changed.

• Perhaps most damagingly, the legislation would also invalidate Indigenous claims to lands such groups could not prove they physically occupied on the day Brazil’s constitution was enacted in October 1988. Activists say that “time limit trick” could scupper scores of legitimate claims for the delimitation of Indigenous lands, from groups who had already been evicted from their ancestral lands or whose presence had yet to be recognized at the cut-off date.

The Climate Observatory watchdog said Brazil’s parliament had witnessed “its most shameful day since the 2016 impeachment of Dilma Rousseff” – a “show of lies, hatred and racism” which signaled the environmental chaos caused by former president Jair Bolsonaro was far from over.

Lawmakers had sent “a clear message to the country and the world: Bolsonaro is gone but the extermination [of Indigenous communities and the environment] continues,” the Climate Observatory added.

Sarah Shenker, a campaigner at human rights group Survival International, said: “This catastrophic bill is the most serious attack on Indigenous rights in decades … Hundreds of Indigenous territories home to over a million Indigenous people could be destroyed.”

She added: “There are many examples of uncontacted tribes whose existence and location was not yet officially confirmed by government in October 1988 … so if [this] was approved it could be used by anti-Indigenous politicians who are desperate to steal [such territories].”

When Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva returned to Brazil’s presidency in January there was optimism South America’s largest country was entering a new era of sustainable development, environmental protection and respect for Indigenous rights. Lula named the veteran environmentalist Marina Silva as his environment minister and created a ministry for Indigenous peoples run by the Indigenous activist Sônia Guajajara. “We are going to reverse all of the injustices committed against Indigenous peoples,” Lula vowed in his inaugural address, claiming Brazil had a “historic debt” to such groups.

But the rowdy congressional debate that preceded the approval of Bill 490 brought such hopes crashing back down to earth and revealed a starkly divided country.

A succession of white, mostly male lawmakers took the microphone to claim they were supporting the legislation because they considered themselves Indigenous defenders who wanted to help such groups integrate into mainstream society. Many were staunch supporters of Bolsonaro and members of the powerful ruralista bloc linked to agribusiness which boasts 302 of the 513 seats in the lower house and 42 of 81 senators.

Bibo Nunes, a congressman from Bolsonaro’s rightwing Liberal party (PL), voiced outrage that nearly 14% of Brazil’s territory was in the hands of Indigenous people who represented only 0.4% of the population. “What’s the logic? Explain it to me, you lefties!” Nunes bellowed.

Leftist politicians countered that the legislation would endanger Indigenous lives as well as the global struggle against climate change given the crucial role Indigenous communities have in protecting the Amazon rainforest.

“This is a bill of death, backwardness and regression … This is a crime against Indigenous people,” said Juliana Cardoso, a congresswoman from Lula’s Worker’s party (PT).

But such arguments were ignored and the bill passed easily.

Guajajara told activists to remain mobilized in the face of what she called “a serious attack on Indigenous people and the environment”. “We will remain steadfast and united, as we always have been,” Lula’s Indigenous minister said in a video message.


Tom Phillips in Rio de Janeiro

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Brazil aerial photos show miners’ devastation of indigenous people’s land
Impact of thousands of wildcat goldminers shown as president Jair Bolsonaro is accused of trying to promote their illegal work

Tom Phillips and Flávia Milhorance in Rio de Janeiro

27, May, 2021 @12:16 PM

Article image
Brazil says illegal miners driven from Indigenous territory, but ‘war’ not over
Country’s top cop said 90% of miners despoiling Yanomami land had been expelled, though experts say they are only displaced

Tom Phillips in Belém and Bram Ebus in Leticia

10, Jul, 2023 @10:30 AM

Article image
Amazon gold miners invade indigenous village in Brazil after its leader is killed
Brazil’s police have been urged to investigate a ‘very tense situation’ in Amapá state

Dom Phillips in Rio de Janeiro

28, Jul, 2019 @5:00 AM

Article image
Outcry as Brazil congress moves to gut environment and Indigenous ministries
Plan to drastically dilute bodies’ powers would deal severe blow to Lula’s attempt to reverse Bolsonaro’s era of Amazon devastation

Tom Phillips in Rio de Janeiro

25, May, 2023 @3:25 PM

Article image
Amazon forest guardians fulfil Bruno Pereira’s mission of Indigenous exchange
Pereira, who was murdered alongside British journalist Dom Phillips, planned to lead an Indigenous delegation 2,500km across Brazil to learn from veteran fellow defenders

Tom Phillips in the Araribóia indigenous territory, photography by João Laet

22, Aug, 2022 @9:00 AM

Article image
Brazil: fears for isolated Amazon tribes as fires erupt on protected reserves
Campaigners say indigenous territories make easy targets for loggers and farmers seeking land or valuable wood

Dom Phillips in Rio de Janeiro

29, Aug, 2019 @5:55 PM

Article image
‘It’s dangerous work’: new generation of Indigenous activists battle to save the Amazon
Campaigners in Brazil use drones to document work of self-defence teams trying to stop environmental destruction caused by illegal mining

Tom Phillips in Raposa Serra do Sol

03, Sep, 2023 @11:13 AM

Article image
Bruno Pereira and Dom Phllips were killed in the Amazon. Their Indigenous allies risk death to carry on the work
The Brazilian Amazon and its Indigenous people remain under siege but a patrol group the killed activist helped form is fighting back

Tom Phillips

01, Jun, 2023 @12:00 PM

Article image
Brazil must recognise Munduruku lands | Letter from Lily Cole, Paul McCartney, Olivia Colman and 45 others
Letters: The Brazilian environment agency’s decision to stop the São Luiz do Tapajós dam marked a turning point in the struggle to protect this corner of the Amazon, but the fight isn’t over yet


10, Aug, 2016 @6:00 AM

Article image
Brazil: judge bans missionaries from indigenous reserve over Covid-19 fears
Indigenous leaders and activists hailed ‘historic’ decision after three missionaries and controversial group barred

Dom Phillips in Rio de Janeiro

17, Apr, 2020 @7:43 PM