Dom Phillips and Bruno Pereira: anger at ‘far-fetched’ self-defence claim

Brazilian activists accuse defence lawyers for three accused in double murder case of smearing victims

Brazilian activists have condemned the “far-fetched” attempt by the alleged murderers of Bruno Pereira and Dom Phillips to contend they committed the crime in “self-defence” after supposedly being shot at by the Indigenous activist.

Pereira and Phillips, a British journalist and longtime Guardian contributor, were killed on the Amazon’s Itaquaí River last June while returning from a reporting trip to the remote Javari Valley region, where Pereira had worked defending Indigenous communities from illegal fishing, poaching and mining gangs.

Three local fishermen are being held in high-security prisons awaiting a possible trial for murder: two brothers called Amarildo and Oseney da Costa de Oliveira and a third man called Jefferson da Silva Lima.

Amarildo and Jefferson confessed to the murders in the days after the disappearance of Pereira and Phillips caused an international scandal.

In his signed six-page confession, seen by the Guardian, Amarildo told police he decided to commit the crime after seeing red when he saw Pereira photograph his boat as he and Phillips travelled past his riverside home.

“There goes that guy. Let’s kill him?” Amarildo admitted telling Jefferson, according to that 16 June statement.

Amarildo told police Jefferson had fired the first shot, hitting Pereira in the back, before both victims were killed and buried in a shallow grave in the rainforest. Two days later, on 18 June, Jefferson offered an almost identical version, although he claimed Amarildo had fired first as they chased Pereira’s boat down the river.

However, the pair offered a dramatically different account this week when they appeared before a federal judge who is preparing to rule on whether there is sufficient evidence for the trio to face a full jury trial.

Amarildo and Jefferson claimed they had only shot at Pereira after the Indigenous activist opened fire on them when they passed his boat as they went out to fish. “He started to shoot at us for no reason,” Jefferson said.

Amarildo told the court murdering Pereira “never went through my mind” and that they had acted in self-defence.

Both men claimed their confessions had been given under duress and that Oseney da Costa de Oliveira had played no role whatsoever in the crime.

Activists from OPI, the Indigenous protection group which Pereira helped found, reacted to those claims with anger and derision.

“The thesis of self-defence has no basis in reality,” the group said in a statement on Wednesday, denouncing the defence lawyers’ attempt to portray the respected former government official as an “aggressive, violent” person who had stirred up tensions between Indigenous and non-Indigenous communities along the Itaquaí River.

“The families and friends of Bruno and Dom, as well as OPI … reject the attempt to smear their memories with this defence strategy,” the group added, noting how similar “defamatory” tactics had been used in past cases involving the murders of Amazon defenders such as the American Dorothy Stang.

One of the lawyer’s representing the alleged killers of Pereira and Phillips is Américo Leal, an Amazon-based lawyer who defended the rancher sentenced to 30 years in jail for helping mastermind Stang’s 2005 murder. During that trial, Leal notoriously accused 73-year-old Stang of being a fake nun who had come to the Amazon to promote a supposed US plot to colonize the region.

OPI urged the media to contrast the defence team’s “far-fetched and deceitful versions” with “the truth of the facts, scientific evidence, and concrete information” surrounding the murders.

In a statement, the legal team representing Phillips’s family said it was convinced sufficient evidence existed to prove that all three men were involved in the double homicide.

A decision over whether the trio will face trial by jury is expected in the coming weeks.


Tom Phillips in Rio de Janeiro

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Indigenous groups scour forests and rivers for Dom Phillips and Bruno Pereira
Indigenous activists have been searching for the missing pair since just hours after they vanished, with support from armed members of the military police

Tom Phillips on the River Itaquaí

10, Jun, 2022 @2:12 PM

Article image
How the final journey of Dom Phillips and Bruno Pereira ended in tragedy
The journalist and Indigenous expert travelled upstream in Brazil’s far western Amazon region, a trip from which they did not return alive

Tom Phillips in Atalaia do Norte

17, Jun, 2022 @5:37 PM

Article image
Bolsonaro says ‘something wicked’ done to Dom Phillips and Bruno Pereira
Brazil president comments on journalist and Indigenous expert’s fate amid unconfirmed claims bodies have been found in Amazon

Tom Phillips in Atalaia do Norte

13, Jun, 2022 @6:00 PM

Article image
Brazil Indigenous agency staff strike over Bruno Pereira disappearance
Employees walk off the job amid anger over statements criticising the former Funai employee who went missing with Dom Phillips

Andrew Downie in São Paulo

14, Jun, 2022 @7:00 PM

Article image
Last images of Dom Phillips and Bruno Pereira found on recovered phone
Photos and videos on phone found near site of men’s killing show some of their last movements in Brazilian Amazon

Tom Phillips in Rio de Janeiro

01, Jun, 2023 @12:00 PM

Article image
Dom Phillips and Bruno Pereira remembered in Lancaster exhibition
Exhibition at Halton Mill is part of a month of activities about the Amazon commemorating Phillips and Pereira

Helen Pidd North of England editor

29, Oct, 2022 @6:00 AM

Article image
Bruno Pereira: the dedicated defender of Indigenous rights missing in Brazil
Indigenous expert last seen travelling with British journalist Dom Phillips was ousted from official role after Bolsonaro took office

Andrew Downie in São Paulo and Caio Barretto Briso in Rio de Janeiro

08, Jun, 2022 @1:52 PM

Article image
Brazilian police name alleged ‘mastermind’ behind murders of Dom Phillips and Bruno Pereira
Police chief says Rubens Villar Coelho, whose nickname is Colômbia, ordered the murders of the British journalist and Brazilian Indigenous expert

Tom Phillips in Rio de Janeiro

23, Jan, 2023 @9:45 PM

Article image
Man linked to killing of Dom Phillips and Bruno Pereira arrested over fake ID
Rubens Villar Coelho ‘produced a fake Brazilian ID’ to investigating officer and had other aliases in Peru and Colombia

Andrew Downie

08, Jul, 2022 @7:11 PM

Article image
The writer and the activist: how Dom Phillips and Bruno Pereira bonded over the Amazon
The two men spent years traveling together in canoes and on foot. They disappeared on what was supposed to be a final trip

Andrew Downie in São Paulo and Tom Phillips in Atalaia do Norte

13, Jun, 2022 @6:24 PM