Putin welcomes China’s controversial proposals for peace in Ukraine

But US warns against ‘any tactical move by Russia to freeze the war on its own terms’

Vladimir Putin has welcomed China’s proposals for peace in Ukraine at a joint press conference with Xi Jinping in Moscow – a plan the west has warned would allow the Kremlin to “freeze” its territorial gains in the country.

Speaking at the Kremlin during a joint news conference after the second day of talks with China’s president, Xi Jinping, Putin said Beijing’s peace plan “correlates to the point of view of the Russian Federation” and said that Ukraine’s western allies so far have shown no interest in it.

China last month proposed a 12-point peace plan for dealing with the war. The paper largely reiterated Beijing’s talking points on the Ukraine war, with calls for dialogue, respect for all countries’ territorial sovereignty, and an end to economic sanctions. It urged all parties to avoid nuclear escalation but critically did not suggest Russia withdraw its forces.

On Monday, US secretary of state, Antony Blinken, voiced scepticism over China’s “peace” proposals, warning that they could be a “stalling tactic” to help Russian troops on the ground in Ukraine.

“The world should not be fooled by any tactical move by Russia, supported by China or any other country, to freeze the war on its own terms.”

On Tuesday, White House national security council spokesperson John Kirby said the US does not see China as capable of being an impartial mediator between Moscow and Kyiv over the war in Ukraine.

It was the most direct criticism yet of China’s aim to be a middleman in efforts to end the war.

“I don’t think you can reasonably look at China as impartial in any way,” he said.

He noted that China has refrained from criticising the Russian invasion of Ukraine and has continued to buy Russian oil even as the west piles sanctions on Moscow’s energy industry to starve the Kremlin of money to pay for the war.

China, Kirby added, also “keeps parroting the Russian propaganda”.

Kyiv has previously said that any talks would be contingent on the complete restoration of Ukraine’s territory.

Xi, who seeks to play the role of global peacemaker, on Tuesday repeated China’s position that it supported peace talks and said that Beijing has always taken an “objective” and “impartial” view of the conflict. He added that he and Putin have “established close relations and built strategic communication”.

Xi’s statements, which carefully repeated Beijing’s previous position on the war, suggested that the talks provided no major breakthrough in the peace efforts.

Still, Xi’s trip to Moscow, his first state visit since the invasion, has been viewed as a major boost for Putin and provides Moscow with an opportunity to emphasise that it has not been isolated by the global community.

Speaking after their meeting on Tuesday, Putin said that the relationship between Russia and China was “at the peak of its historical development”.

Xi in turn said that “our two sides must enhance communication and cooperate closely, promoting new and greater advancement in practical cooperation between our two countries”.

As expected, the two countries also discussed the growing economic ties and energy cooperation during their three-hour-long talks on Tuesday.

By evening, the two sides announced that Putin and Xi had signed two joint documents: a statement on plans for economic cooperation and a statement on plans for deepening partnership.

Putin further said the two countries were close to “finalising” an agreement on the Power of Siberia 2 pipeline, a major plan to reroute Russia’s gas exports from Europe to Asia. The pipeline has not been formally agreed but is expected to come online by 2030.

“We were just discussing a good project, the new Power of Siberia 2 pipeline via Mongolia. Practically all the parameters of that agreement have been finalised,” Putin told Xi.

Chinese government data this week showed that Russia overtook Saudi Arabia to be China’s top oil supplier in the first two months of 2023, as buyers bought up sanctioned Russian oil at steep discounts.

Earlier in the day Xi invited Putin to visit China this year in a symbolic show of support after the ICC arrest warrant dramatically restricted the Russian leader’s travel options.

The Chinese leader extended the invitation during a meeting on Tuesday morning with the Russian prime minister, Mikhail Mishustin, as part of his state visit to Moscow.

Since his troops invaded Ukraine in February last year, Putin has only ventured once outside the former Soviet Union, for a trip to Iran.

Alexander Gabuev, a senior fellow at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace said the warrant further pushes the Russian leader into the Chinese orbit.

“If anything, the ICC arrest warrant for Putin only increases Chinese leverage over Russia. With Putin likely to be more cautious about his international travel going forward, China will turn into a few safe destinations where the Russian president is always welcome,” Gabuev said.

The sit-down between Xi and Putin contrasted with a visit to Ukraine by Japanese prime minister Fumio Kishida, who met President Volodymyr Zelenskiy in Kyiv on Tuesday in a rare, unannounced visit by a Japanese leader that underscored Tokyo’s emphatic support for Ukraine.

Kishida had been the only G7 leader yet to visit Ukraine, which has seen an outpouring of popular support in Japan following the Russian invasion.

Zelenskiy posted footage of him greeting Kishida, whom the Ukrainian leader called “a truly powerful defender of the international order and a longtime friend of Ukraine”.

Earlier, Kishida toured the town of Bucha, where the mayor has said more than 400 civilians were killed last year by Russian forces and which is synonymous with Russian brutality during the war. He laid a wreath outside a church before observing a moment of silence and bowing.

“The world was astonished to see innocent civilians in Bucha killed one year ago. I really feel great anger at the atrocity upon visiting that very place here,” Kishida said. “I would like to give condolence to the all victims and the wounded on behalf of the Japanese nationals. Japan will keep aiding Ukraine with the greatest effort to regain peace.”

Kishida, who represents a seat in Hiroshima, has pledged to use his upcoming G7 presidency to promote nuclear disarmament amid fears that Russia has not ruled out the use of tactical nuclear weapons in Ukraine.

China has sought to portray itself as a neutral party in the Ukraine conflict, but Washington has said Beijing’s moves could be a “stalling tactic” to help Moscow. The US has accused Beijing of considering exporting arms to Moscow, claims China has vociferously denied.

Blinken said Xi’s Moscow visit “suggests that China feels no responsibility to hold the president accountable for the atrocities committed to Ukraine. And instead of even condemning, it would rather provide diplomatic cover for Russia to continue to commit those great crimes.”

Zelenskiy has said he would welcome talks with Xi, though there has been no indication from Beijing of any such plans.

Moscow and Beijing have over the past years ramped up cooperation, driven by a desire to counterbalance US global dominance.

Analysts said Xi’s efforts on Ukraine are unlikely to yield a cessation of hostilities, but his trip is being closely watched in western capitals.

Xi’s visit was lauded in state-run Chinese media on Tuesday, with most coverage focused on Xi’s comments and the strength of the bilateral relationship. None of the pieces mentioned the recent ICC arrest warrant for Putin over alleged war crimes.

“The two sides have set a fine example for developing a new model of major country relations featuring mutual respect, peaceful coexistence and win-win cooperation,” China Daily reported Xi as saying.

Official news agency Xinhua said exchanges between the two leaders were “the compass and anchor of China-Russia relations”, which were “brimming with new dynamism and vitality” under Xi and Putin. Multiple reports plastered the masthead’s online front page, and a separate page was dedicated to the visit.

Additional reporting by Justin McCurry in Tokyo


Pjotr Sauer, and Helen Davidson in Taipei

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Kremlin denies China’s president urged Putin not to use nuclear arms in Ukraine
Xi Jinping reportedly warned Russian counterpart against using such weapons on visit to Moscow in March

Pjotr Sauer

05, Jul, 2023 @12:46 PM

Article image
Xi-Putin summit: Russia inches closer to China as ‘new cold war’ looms
Fifty years after Nixon and Mao’s historic handshake, the geopolitical world order is again being reshaped

Vincent Ni and Andrew Roth

03, Feb, 2022 @12:44 PM

Article image
Macron urges Xi to bring Russia ‘back to reason’ over Ukraine
French president makes plea as two leaders hold first of series of high-level meetings in Beijing

Amy Hawkins, Angelique Chrisafis and agencies

06, Apr, 2023 @11:03 AM

Article image
Putin tells Xi he understands China’s ‘questions and concerns’ over Ukraine
Russian leader seems keen to curry favour with Chinese president as battlefield setbacks and sanctions bite

Helen Davidson in Taipei and Andrew Roth in Moscow

15, Sep, 2022 @5:08 PM

Article image
Year of war in Ukraine tests China’s ‘no limits’ relationship with Russia
There are signs Beijing wants a quick political resolution to conflict as its patience with Russia wears thin

Amy Hawkins Senior China correspondent

24, Feb, 2023 @11:32 AM

Article image
Putin defends invasion of Ukraine in Brics summit address
Russian president seeks to rally leaders meeting in South Africa to Moscow’s side by blaming west

Pjotr Sauer

23, Aug, 2023 @2:37 PM

Article image
Xi Jinping to send Chinese peace talks delegation to Ukraine
In phone call with Zelenskiy, Xi appears to pledge China will stay neutral in war, according to Chinese state media

Peter Beaumont in Kyiv, Emma Graham-Harrison in Dnipro and Amy Hawkins

26, Apr, 2023 @1:29 PM

Article image
Russia and China deepen economic ties amid surge in trade since Ukraine invasion
Russian PM holds talks with Xi Jinping and signs bilateral pacts to further investment, exports and sports cooperation

Amy Hawkins

24, May, 2023 @11:34 AM

Article image
Vladimir Putin says civilians must be evacuated from Kherson war zone
Russia digs in in preparation for expected attempt by Ukraine to take key southern city, setting scene for possible ferocious battle

Peter Beaumont

04, Nov, 2022 @3:37 PM

Article image
‘Good old friend’: Putin offers praise for Xi ahead of first trip to Russia since Ukraine invasion
Russian president lauds Xi ahead of meeting, while Beijing calls for a ‘rational way’ out of the crisis

Pjotr Sauer and Amy Hawkins

20, Mar, 2023 @1:00 AM