Why isn’t there universal faith in female priests? | Letters

Women priests and bishops are here to stay, says Linda Hurcombe. Plus letters from the Rev Beth Honey and another female priest

Bravo to the Rev Martine Oborne for her clarifying piece about the appointment of Philip North as the next bishop of Blackburn (Why are female clergy cheering for a bishop who doesn’t believe in female priests?, 14 January).

Philip North does not believe that women should be ordained either as priests or bishops. He claims that he is supportive of female clergy and has “worked out a way to make mutual flourishing work”, albeit with “work still to do”, the Church Times reported last week.

Parishioners and priests alike need to know that their future bishop washes his hands of ordaining women as priests. He will also not receive bread and wine consecrated by a female priest, or indeed by a woman or man ordained by a female bishop. Interested readers may recall that the Church of England has approved the ordination of women to the priesthood since 1992 and to the House of Bishops since 2014.

What Oborne was gracious in not mentioning was that she herself had personal experience of the reality behind “mutual flourishing”, after her own previous diocesan bishop had refused to ordain her; she had to be ordained by a bishop from a different diocese. Even in her more positive present situation she finds the burden undermining, needing to explain to her parishioners that some clergy colleagues would not receive the bread and wine that she had consecrated.

Like other fuzzy-wuzzy buzz phrases – “forward in faith” and “cost of conscience” spring to mind – “mutual flourishing” proves in practice to be founded on shifting sand. I suggest that Philip North moves over to the rock of reality. Women priests and bishops are here, and we aren’t going away.
Linda Hurcombe
Founder member, Movement for the Ordination of Women

• I am a priest in the Church of England and have previously found myself subscribing to the idea of mutual flourishing, as I have seen much of the good work and integrity of those with differing views from mine on a number of theological issues, notwithstanding a sense of call to do so. However, unity within the church is a high price to pay for a culture that so often suppresses opportunities for so many gifted and talented minorities due to gender, class and sexuality that we now see dominant in our church. If senior leaders do not seek out those leaders for development and flourishing, they will not foster a culture where they will be the next leaders themselves. It’s as simple as that.
Rev Beth Honey
Skelton, Cumbria

• Ordained in my late 50s, I was unprepared for the animosity towards women as priests that I found. When I moved to a large evangelical church, I was relegated to doing the things no one else wanted to do, and never, in any circumstances, being allowed to preach. Everything was done with a smile, but it was clear that I was not considered to be a real priest, and I felt spiritually destroyed.

Needless to say, it all resulted in worse than tears, and after I left it, this church sadly fell apart. By the grace of God it is now coming back to life, without those who would not accept women’s ministry.

It is impossible to hold together a church in which two mutually exclusive views are held. As long as the church ordains men who do not believe that women can be wholly priests, our ministry will never be accepted as equivalent to men’s.
Name and address supplied

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The Guardian view on the Eadburg writings: the long lost female authors of English | Editorial
Editorial: A woman’s name found etched in a medieval copy of the Acts of the Apostles has importance beyond the thrill of discovery


02, Dec, 2022 @5:59 PM

Article image
Ban on gay author shows that Catholic church is still failing young people | Letter
Letters: Closing down debate on sexuality preserves a toxic culture the church should be leaving behind, says Dr Jeremy Oliver


10, Mar, 2022 @6:39 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on academic freedom: the right to be very wrong | Editorial
Editorial: Sometimes it takes a true believer to make clear the absurdities of a faith. An Oxford professor’s view on sexuality discredit his church’s doctrine


14, Jan, 2019 @6:37 PM

Letters: No place for prejudice in our schools
Letters: The Catholic Education Service should not be seeking to influence pupils to sign petitions against gay marriage

29, Apr, 2012 @8:00 PM

Article image
Slip-up leaves priests rolling in the aisles | Brief letters
Brief letters: Oxford University | English usage | Noel Coward | Driving in cities | Flavoured crisps


17, Jan, 2020 @5:16 PM

Article image
Progressive Muslims, Jews and Christians must stand together for LGBT rights | Michael Segalov
Reporting of the Parkfield school protests has focused on the Muslim community, but homophobia is rife in all faith groups, writes Huck contributing editor Michael Segalov

Michael Segalov

17, Apr, 2019 @9:00 AM

Article image
Sky-high pay in education isn’t just for university bosses. Look at academies | Warwick Mansell
Leaders of academy trusts often earn more than £200,000, while the profession struggles to recruit teachers, writes education specialist Warwick Mansell

Warwick Mansell

12, Mar, 2018 @3:54 PM

Article image
Jesus treated women with respect, and so should the church | Letters
Letters: Liam Keane feels that more support should be given to women; Rev Dr Donald W Norwood, Canon George Burgon and Doug Kessler also highlight room for improvement

18, Nov, 2022 @4:40 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on calls to reopen schools: a dangerous distraction | Editorial
Editorial: With more than 1,000 deaths from Covid every day for weeks, talk of looser restrictions is reckless. The prime minister should ignore his backbenchers


25, Jan, 2021 @7:08 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on educational inequality: no quick fixes | Editorial
Editorial: The disadvantaged pupils who lost out most during the pandemic will need targeted support to catch up


06, Sep, 2020 @5:30 PM