History revisited: what the isolationist Qing dynasty tells us about Xi Jinping’s China

Promotion of historian who spearheaded rehabilitation of the Qing period prompts speculation that the past is being reinterpreted to bolster President Xi

At the height of the Qing dynasty, the Chinese empire was one of the great powers of the world. Its territory spanned all the way to Inner Asia and its economic prosperity and military might was the envy of the world.

But despite its success, rampant corruption, weak governance, internal revolts and foreign invasion led to the decline of its national power and its eventual collapse. The beginning of the 20th century would mark the end of China’s centuries-long dynasties, ruled over by emperors.

For decades, the Qing imperial dynasty’s isolationist policies have been widely blamed for the country’s downfall, but that history is now being revisited.

The recent promotion of a historian – who spearheaded a rehabilitation of the period – to the highest levels of Chinese society has led to speculation that the past is being reinterpreted to bolster President Xi Jinping’s ideological and political authority.

Historian Gao Xiang was appointed president, as well as the more powerful role of secretary of the Communist party, at the influential Chinese Academy of Social Sciences (Cass) just before the new year. The Cass is the top national research institution that formulates ideology and advises leaders on policymaking.

At the 2019 launch of the Chinese Academy of History, of which Gao is also president and party chief, Xi stated its mission was to push a historical narrative with “Chinese characteristics”.

Chen Daoyin, a former associate professor at Shanghai University of Political Science and Law, says Cass is not so much an academic institution but a body to formulate party ideology to support the leadership. “[Xi] needs experts to reinterpret Chinese history to bolster his credibility,” Chen says.

Xi regards history as a highly contentious issue and has repeatedly emphasised the importance of upholding the party’s own version of the past. Since he took power, authorities have pulled out all the stops to suppress unorthodox versions of history that they fear would tarnish the image of the party and threaten its legitimacy.

In 2013, an internal Communist party edict known as Document No 9 denounced “historical nihilism” among the seven supposedly subversive influences on society. In 2016, the authorities forcibly took over the management of a political magazine, Yanhuang Chunqiu, which often contested official versions of history with eyewitness accounts. In 2017, the country legislated against defaming the Communist “heroes and martyrs” to punish those who challenge the official history.

The Chinese Communist party has a record of manipulating historical records as well. Photos in state press were often altered to cut out purged individuals and historical documents were tampered with to suit the latest political needs.

Gao, an expert on China’s two last imperial dynasties – Ming and Qing, which ruled from late 14th to the early 20th centuries – is known for his loyalty to Xi and his defence of Xi’s ideology and policies.

Last summer, an article written by a panel led by Gao at the Chinese Academy of History created a furore. Readers saw it as an oblique justification of China’s isolationist foreign policy amid the Covid lockdowns and escalating tensions with the west.

The article was a defence of biguan suoguo (“closing and locking up of the country”), an isolationist policy implemented by the imperial rulers of the Ming and Qing dynasties that is widely blamed for China’s decline in the late 19th century. The article contends that the popular depiction of the closed-door policy as backwards and barbaric is a “western-centric” historical narrative.

It argues that the policy should be seen in historical context as a self-defence strategy to fend off the “threatening aggressive western colonial forces”. A video clip embedded in the official social media post highlights the message of China under siege under western colonialism with images of warships and colonial invaders in 19th-century costume.

Gao has also penned numerous articles in the state press in support of Xi’s rhetoric and his vision of the “rejuvenation of the Chinese nation”. Last week, an article by Gao touted on the website of Cass insisted that “one cannot stray from the party’s firm leadership and the firm discipline for a moment … the nation can only be strong when the party is strong”.

Prof Steve Tsang, the director of the SOAS China Institute, says Xi’s appointment of Gao was not due to his academic merits but, rather, his political loyalty. His appointment was in the same vein as Xi’s promotion of his allies to the party’s top political decision-making body at the 20th party congress last year, he says.

“Under Xi, be it history, literature or music, everything has to serve the purpose of patriotism, and Xi personifies the state … If history doesn’t dovetail with Xi’s rhetoric, that’s unpatriotic.”


Verna Yu

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Who’s who in Xi Jinping’s China as leader cements power
An introduction to loyal Xi acolytes on politburo standing committee who will now shape Xi’s vision for China

Verna Yu and Emma Graham-Harrison in Taipei

23, Oct, 2022 @8:47 AM

Article image
China is angry, but what can it do about North Korea?
Xi Jinping has few options to bring Kim Jong-un into line but he also has to contend with the unpredictable Donald Trump

Tom Phillips in Beijing

04, Sep, 2017 @5:15 AM

Article image
Xi Jinping’s pilgrimage to ‘red Mecca’ brings back the Mao factor
Yan’an is where Mao Zedong definitively – and brutally – stamped his supreme authority on China’s Communist party. Experts explain how Xi continues to shape himself as today’s embodiment of the ‘great leader’

Verna Yu

04, Nov, 2022 @5:58 AM

Article image
Xi Jinping’s Leninist quest for a dynasty inspires congressional love-in
While the explosion of sycophancy over China’s president may seem almost comical, his reign will have ramifications far beyond the country’s borders

Tom Phillips in Beijing

20, Oct, 2017 @10:15 AM

Article image
Xi Jinping’s cordial tone at G20 does not herald softer foreign policy
Apparent rapprochement with western leaders does not mean China is about to ditch its ‘wolf-warrior’ diplomacy

Verna Yu

16, Nov, 2022 @6:27 PM

Article image
Beijing tells Theresa May not to close door on China amid Hinkley Point tensions
As the British PM prepares for her first G20 summit this week, China’s UK ambassador urges her to make ‘wise choices’

Tom Phillips in Beijing

01, Sep, 2016 @4:36 AM

Article image
Chinese Communist party congress: who’s in and who’s out of Xi Jinping’s inner circle
A major reshuffle will take place in the Chinese Commmunist party’s top echelon this week – here’s a who’s who of the main players

Verna Yu

17, Oct, 2022 @4:20 AM

Article image
The Guardian view on Xi Jinping’s China: rectification, not revolution | Editorial
Editorial: A wide-ranging crackdown and leftist rhetoric have stirred fears of a return to the apogee of Maoism


12, Sep, 2021 @4:58 PM

Article image
Biden tells Xi US and China must not ‘veer into conflict’
White House says leaders agree to engage ‘openly and straightforwardly’ amid US frustration at lack of progress in relations

Vincent Ni, and Helen Davidson in Taipei

10, Sep, 2021 @12:39 PM

Article image
What to expect from President Xi Jinping’s visit to Britain
First official visit by Chinese head of state in 10 years will include a City summit, details of London’s role in Beijing’s financial plans and a royal banquet

Aisha Gani

19, Oct, 2015 @6:00 AM