My family’s Holocaust legacy taught me that racism grows where it is enabled | Letters

Nick Howson and Katy Rodda respond to James Bulgin’s article about how ordinary people were active participants in Nazi atrocities

My mother and her sister are child Holocaust survivors. Not a day goes by that doesn’t involve Holocaust remembrance in some form, casting a long shadow across her life and a ripple through the generations of her family. Her father was murdered in a slave labour camp near Lviv in 1942, a memory too painful for her own mother to talk about after the war, though her postwar diary recalls his last days with agony and lament. She and her two girls survived in hiding, both because of and despite the actions of ordinary strangers around her.

No other relatives escaped, perishing either in Belzec extermination camp or in the shooting pits of Janowska, Lviv. I have visited their unmarked graves.

James Bulgin tells an important story that highlights how, to many people, the above placenames might sound unfamiliar, as Auschwitz fills Holocaust consciousness for the sheer scale of its horror (Hitler didn’t build the path to the Holocaust alone – ordinary people were active participants, 27 January). But in truth, all sense of scale is lost when imagining the implications of the Nazis’ genocidal politics, while the human psyche is overwhelmed by the implication of such murderous intent to humanity itself. More importantly, he correctly emphasises that evil can, under particular circumstances, look very much like any one of us. This is, as Hannah Arendt describes, the sheer “banality of evil”.

As a second-generation inheritor of my family’s Holocaust legacy, I firmly believe that racism grows where racism is enabled. The enablers can be active, or by virtue of apathy and indifference, passively looking away. Human beings might never rid themselves entirely of prejudice, being of itself a distortion of our own nature, but Bulgin touches on something fundamental: never to take for granted that our common humanity can only be preserved by us all challenging the very tolerance of hatred, as well as facing down the hatred itself.
Nick Howson

• In response to James Bulgin’s excellent piece about wider active participation in the Holocaust, there’s another element that is also often overlooked. Hitler’s dehumanising methods, pitting Germans against minorities who were easy targets for whipped-up blame and hatred, involved attacks on physically and mentally disabled people. They were included in the racist legislation forced on Jewish people, with the addition of enforced sterilisation.

It was a fairly short journey from pointing out the costs of care for people he tagged “life unworthy of life”, while labelling “degenerates” as enemies of Germany, to his first mass-murder programme, Aktion T4. Between 275,000 and 300,000 disabled Germans were murdered by the Nazis between 1939 and 1945.

Charlie English’s book The Gallery of Miracles and Madness, which follows the stories of artists in asylums studied by Hans Prinzhorn, suggests that the fusion of Hitler’s attitudes to disability and art (particularly artists’ explorations of insanity in the 1920s and 30s, which were prompted by Prinzhorn’s study) was an essential feature of his grotesque vision for Germany that led to the programmes of murder and genocide.

People who are aware of the language used by the Nazis to dehumanise vulnerable minorities are rightly sensitive about seeing similar terms and divisions being encouraged and normalised in current contexts.
Katy Rodda

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Polish Holocaust law is about the truth | Letters
Letters: Poland’s ambassador Arkady Rzegocki defends his country’s new legislation related to the fight against the term ‘Polish camps’ in foreign media


09, Feb, 2018 @4:42 PM

Article image
Poland shares no responsibility for the Holocaust | Letters
Letters: Anna Mlynik-Shawcross and Richard Butterwick-Pawlikowski respond to a Guardian editorial that suggested Poland could not wholly escape blame for the Holocaust


21, Feb, 2018 @4:50 PM

The best answer to Holocaust denial is getting the facts right | Letters
Professor Eve Rosenhaft of the University of Liverpool writes to correct a historical error in a piece about the vandalising of Elie Wiesel’s house in Romania


10, Aug, 2018 @3:03 PM

Article image
Battling the myths of national identity | Letters
Letters: Diana Neslen on the dangers of whitewashing the past, and Jim Grozier on the benefits of forgetting where we have come from, and concentrating on where we are going


05, Feb, 2019 @6:29 PM

Article image
How we can ensure Holocaust survivors continue to be heard | Letter
Letter: Prof Sara Jones writes of the challenges of teaching the Holocaust when its witnesses are no longer with us, and the importance of preserving their testimonies for future generations


28, Jan, 2020 @6:42 PM

Article image
The Holocaust refugee who was driven to pacifism | Letter
Letters: Albert Beale recalls pacifist group meetings hosted by a German-Jewish woman whose family members had been murdered by the Nazis


17, Aug, 2022 @4:57 PM

Article image
The value of photographic evidence of Nazi crimes | Letter
Letter: Toby Simpson, the director of the Wiener Holocaust Library, on the new Seeing Auschwitz exhibition in London


21, Oct, 2022 @3:55 PM

Article image
Polish law denies reality of Holocaust | Letters
Letters: Why should the victims and witnesses of the Holocaust have to watch what they say for fear of being arrested?


05, Feb, 2018 @6:03 PM

Article image
Polish antisemitism during the second world war | Letters
Letters: Andy Stelman on the prejudice suffered by his father and other Jews in the Polish army, and Zaki Cooper on Poland’s attempt to outlaw discussion of its role in the Holocaust


06, Feb, 2018 @6:22 PM

Article image
A more fitting memorial to the Holocaust | Letter
Letter: Historian and Holocaust educator Trudy Gold says a more radical solution that the proposed memorial in Westminster is needed to tackle the scourge of antisemitism


20, Feb, 2020 @6:34 PM