Nato official apologises over suggestion Ukraine could give up land for membership

Secretary general’s chief of staff says statement was ‘mistake’ and part of wider discussion – but does not completely rule out idea

A senior Nato official has apologised and clarified his comments a day after he said publicly that Ukraine could give up territory to Russia in exchange for Nato membership and an end to the war.

Stian Jenssen, the chief of staff to the Nato secretary general, Jens Stoltenberg, told a Norwegian newspaper that he should not have spoken as simplistically as he did, after his initial comments prompted an angry reaction from Kyiv.

At a panel event in Norway on Tuesday, Jenssen had said that while any peace deal reached would have to be acceptable to Ukraine, alliance members were discussing how the 18-month war might be brought to an end.

“I think that a solution could be for Ukraine to give up territory and get Nato membership in return,” Jenssen told his audience, noting that discussions about Ukraine’s postwar status were continuing in diplomatic circles.

A day later, he gave an interview to the same newspaper, VG, that had reported on his original comments. “My statement about this was part of a larger discussion about possible future scenarios in Ukraine, and I shouldn’t have said it that way. It was a mistake,” he said.

But Jenssen did not walk back the idea that a land-for-Nato-membership deal could ultimately be on the table. If there were serious peace negotiations then the military situation at the time, including who controls what territory, “will necessarily have a decisive influence,” the chief of staff said.

“Precisely for this reason, it is crucially important that we support the Ukrainians with what they need,” the official continued as he sought to emphasise that Nato members remained behind Ukraine.

Ukraine has consistently called for a restoration of its internationally recognised pre-2014 borders and is engaged in a counteroffensive in an attempt to recapture large parts of its territory seized by Russia.

Jenssen was careful in his initial comments to stress that he was simply airing an idea and that “it must be up to Ukraine to decide when and on what terms they want to negotiate”, reflecting Nato’s position that no peace settlement with Ukraine should be agreed without Ukraine.

But this was not enough for Kyiv, unhappy that Jenssen, an important figure and close ally of Stoltenberg, was even discussing the proposition in public.

Kyiv said any land-for-Nato deal would reward Russian aggression. Mykhailo Podolyak, a senior adviser to Ukraine’s president, Volodymyr Zelenskiy, said: “Trading territory for a Nato umbrella? It is ridiculous. That means deliberately choosing the defeat of democracy, encouraging a global criminal, preserving the Russian regime, destroying international law and passing the war on to other generations.”

Podolyak said that unless Russia took a heavy loss in the war, it would continue to pose a long-term problem for the west. “If Putin does not suffer a crushing defeat, the political regime in Russia does not change and war criminals are not punished, the war will definitely return with Russia’s appetite for more.”

Ukraine’s position is being tested by the slow progress of its counteroffensive, which began in June. Although Kyiv has received donations of western tanks and long-range rockets and artillery, its forces have so far made only limited territorial gains against heavily defended Russia positions.

Nato put out a clarifying statement on Tuesday night aimed at cooling the Jenssen row. “We will continue to support Ukraine as long as necessary, and we are committed to achieving a just and lasting peace. The position of the alliance is clear and has not changed,” a spokesperson said.

Discussions about how peace might be achieved are unlikely to subside, particularly given the relative deadlock on the battlefield. “I’m not saying it has to be like this. But that could be a possible solution,” Jenssen said on Tuesday.


Dan Sabbagh in Kharkiv

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Nato chief downplays idea Ukraine could give up land for membership
Jens Stoltenberg says comments by key Nato aide are not policy and path to peace is to support Ukraine militarily

Dan Sabbagh in Kharkiv

17, Aug, 2023 @1:27 PM

Article image
Nato allies back fast-track membership for Ukraine, says Cleverly
UK foreign secretary says Ukraine has ‘evolved quickly’, as Zelenskiy tells summit it can be engine of green growth

Patrick Wintour Diplomatic editor

21, Jun, 2023 @3:54 PM

Article image
Biden lays bare Nato divide over Russian aggression against Ukraine
Analysis: Greatest tension is between US and Germany over arms sale and energy dependency

Patrick Wintour Diplomatic editor

20, Jan, 2022 @11:13 AM

Article image
Turkey has made its mind up about our Nato membership, says Finland
Swedish prime minister also said he hopes Sweden’s accession will be ratified by Ankara after May elections

Jon Henley Europe correspondent

15, Mar, 2023 @4:28 PM

Article image
Ukraine defence minister expects Nato guarantee for after war
Exclusive: Oleksii Reznikov says entry to alliance non-negotiable and pledges need to be made now

Daniel Boffey Chief reporter

28, Jun, 2023 @9:06 AM

Article image
Nato chief warns Russia against ‘further provocation’ amid Ukraine tensions
Jens Stoltenberg says large Russian military buildup has been seen near Ukraine border

Andrew Roth in Moscow

15, Nov, 2021 @9:15 PM

Article image
Ukraine pessimistic about joining Nato ahead of Vilnius summit
The US and Germany are unwilling to support Ukraine’s membership while the conflict with Russia is ongoing

Dan Sabbagh Defence and security editor

09, Jul, 2023 @5:48 PM

Article image
Ukraine urges Nato to hasten membership as Russian troops gather
President calls for his country to be put on pathway to membership of western military alliance

Dan Sabbagh Defence and security editor

06, Apr, 2021 @6:37 PM

Article image
Blinken says Nato united on Ukraine as EU ministers prepare to meet
US secretary of state says Germans ‘share our concerns’ after navy chief’s comments rattle alliance

Jennifer Rankin in Brussels

23, Jan, 2022 @7:24 PM

Article image
Nato chief warns of ‘real risk of conflict’ as talks with Russia over Ukraine end
Moscow says relations with the alliance are at ‘critically low level’ with ‘no positive agenda at all’

Jennifer Rankin in Brussels, Luke Harding in Kyiv and Julian Borger in Washington

12, Jan, 2022 @4:27 PM