Benin bronzes made from metal mined in west Germany, study finds

Brass used for west African artworks was acquired from manilla bracelets, the grim currency of the slave trade

Scientists have discovered that some of the Benin bronzes were made with metal mined thousands of miles away in the German Rhineland.

The Edo people in the Kingdom of Benin, modern Nigeria, created their extraordinary sculptures with melted down brass manilla bracelets, the grim currency of the transatlantic slave trade between the 16th and 19th centuries.

While rarely found in archaeological excavations on land, they have been retrieved in substantial numbers from the wrecks of vessels that had been transporting them.

In carrying out the largest study of these bracelets, a team of German researchers compared their metal with metallic ores and mines across Europe before tracing them to the Rhineland in western Germany.

Dr Tobias Skowronek, who led the study, said: “This is the first time a scientific link has been made … The Benin bronzes are the most famous ancient works of art in west Africa. Where the enormous volumes of metal came from and how Benin got its brass has long been a mystery.”

Dr Sean Kingsley, an archaeologist and editor-in-chief of Wreckwatch magazine, which specialises in the sunken past, said: “[Skowronek has] discovered that the Benin bronzes were made from metal mined around Cologne. Nobody had a clue and it’s quite an eye-opener. It’s a big deal within the very high-profile Benin bronzes art and history world.”

Hundreds of Benin bronzes were seized by British forces in 1897 when the royal court of Benin was razed to the ground. Today, the sculptures are in museums and galleries in Britain and elsewhere.

Nigeria has long called for their return. Germany is one of the few countries that is actively repatriating its bronzes. Other institutions that have done so include the Horniman Museum in London.

Manillas, derived from the Latin for hand or bracelet, were a “currency” used by Britain, Portugal, Spain, the Netherlands, France and Denmark to trade with west Africa in gold and ivory, as well as enslaved people.

The scientific study focused on 67 examples collected from five shipwrecks off the UK, Spain, Ghana and the US. Dating between 1524 and 1843, these were ships of English, Portuguese and Dutch origin. They include a Royal African Company slaver that went down in the Channel.

Skowronek, based at the Technical University of Georg Agricola in Bochum, Germany, said: “Manillas were manufactured in staggering volumes. A contract between the German Fugger merchant house and the Portuguese king, dating back to 1548, lists an order for 1.4m manillas to be made ready within three years … Between 1519 and 1522, Lisbon sent 150,000 manillas a year to their trading fort at Elmina on the coast of Ghana, the heart of the gold and slave trade.”

He added: “European societies designed [manillas] solely to buy west African goods, from humans to animal hides … In the 16th century, the German mines were thought to be too exhausted to make it worthwhile deep mining and pumping out rivers of water. But the great volume of manillas that the slave trade needed made industrialists think again.”

Last October, the Guardian reported on his team’s previous findings, that the early British enslavers sourced copper from Cornwall to create manillas.

The latest findings will be published on Wednesday in the journal Plos One. Kingsley’s Wreckwatch is also screening a short film about the Benin bronzes story.

• The headline, subheading and main text of this article were amended on 6 April 2023 to remove references to brass being “mined”; brass is an alloy of copper and zinc.


Dalya Alberge

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Berlin's plan to return Benin bronzes piles pressure on UK museums
British Museum and Pitt Rivers under pressure to hand back sculptures looted from Nigeria

Philip Oltermann in Berlin

23, Mar, 2021 @1:22 PM

Article image
New museum in Nigeria raises hopes of resolution to Benin bronzes dispute
Artefacts held by British museum and other western institutions were looted by British forces in 1897

Mark Brown Arts correspondent

14, Nov, 2020 @11:54 AM

Article image
Regional museums break ranks with UK government on return of Benin bronzes
Aberdeen says it will repatriate a bust while Cambridge museum has ‘expectation’ its collection could be returned

Lanre Bakare

26, Mar, 2021 @6:36 PM

Article image
Germany first to hand back Benin bronzes looted by British
Culture minister says country is facing up to ‘historic and moral responsibility’ by returning artefacts to Nigeria

Philip Oltermann in Berlin

30, Apr, 2021 @9:58 AM

Article image
Germany hands over two Benin bronzes to Nigeria
Two countries sign restitution agreement covering more than 1,000 items in German hands

Philip Oltermann in Berlin

01, Jul, 2022 @4:22 PM

Article image
Germany returns 21 Benin bronzes to Nigeria – amid frustration at Britain
Artefacts looted in 19th century by UK soldiers and sold on, with many more still held by the British Museum

Philip Oltermann in Abuja

20, Dec, 2022 @3:51 PM

Article image
London museum to return 72 Benin treasures to Nigeria
Horniman museum is first government-funded institution to hand back artefacts looted by British forces in 1897

Josh Halliday

07, Aug, 2022 @9:31 PM

Article image
Digital Benin project reunites bronzes looted by British soldiers
Comprehensive database of Benin bronzes held by museums raises questions about where they belong

Philip Oltermann in Berlin

10, Nov, 2022 @5:30 AM

Article image
My ancestors were pillaged to bring the Benin bronzes to England. It is white supremacy that keeps them here | Noah Anthony Enahoro
For me, as a descendant of the kingdom’s rulers, repatriation isn’t just diplomatic – it’s personal , asks Noah Anthony Enahoro, a freelance writer based in London

Noah Anthony Enahoro

05, Feb, 2023 @1:23 PM

Article image
British Museum 'has head in sand' over return of artefacts
Authors of major report accuse institution of hiding from issue of looted colonial-era objects

Lanre Bakare

21, Jun, 2019 @9:45 AM