‘It’s about ethics’: Nigeria urges British Museum to follow US and repatriate bronzes

Culture minister says UK institution ‘should learn from what has happened’ as Smithsonian returns 29 Benin artefacts

The culture minister of Nigeria has urged the British Museum to follow the example of the Smithsonian Institution, which on Tuesday returned ownership of 29 Benin bronzes to Nigeria at a celebratory event in Washington.

Lai Mohammed praised the move by the US National Museum of African Art, which follows a recent restitution agreement with Germany that included the handover of two Benin bronzes. Last year, Mohammed’s ministry formally requested the return of Benin artefacts from the British Museum in London.

“They should learn from what has happened today and what happened in Germany,” Mohammed told the Guardian, recalling how British MPs told him the museum was bound by law not to deaccession items in its collection.

statues on shelves
Benin bronzes on display in Berlin before their repatriation. Photograph: Jens Schlueter/AFP/Getty Images

“They used the law as a shield. This is not about law; this is about ethics.

“I told them the last time I was in London: it’s not if, it’s when. They will eventually have to return these because the campaign is gaining strength by the day and, when they look at what other museums are doing, they will be compelled to return them.”

The bronzes were stolen in 1897, when British forces sacked the Benin Kingdom, in modern-day Nigeria. The royal palace was burned and looted and the oba (ruler) exiled. The British confiscated all royal treasures, giving some to individual officers and taking most to auction in London. An estimated 3,000 objects eventually made their way into museums and private collections around the world.

The 29 Benin bronzes entered the Smithsonian through purchase, transfer, donation and bequest. On Tuesday, the institution transferred ownership to the National Commission for Museums and Monuments in Nigeria.

A ceremony was held in conjunction with the US National Gallery of Art, which returned the Benin bronze from its collection, and attended by Prince Aghatise Erediauwa on behalf of the oba. Speeches were punctuated by traditional dancing, drumming and singing by the Edo Association of DC. Guests were invited to take a last look at the intricate and richly textured works in a gallery space.

Mohammed said: “These are not just objects of beauty who have aesthetics. These are artefacts that speak to who we are and that speak to our history, our religion, our values and ethics.

A bronze sculpture called the Head of a King or Oba, probably from the 1700s.
A bronze sculpture called the Head of a King or Oba, probably from the 1700s. Photograph: Erik Gould/AP

“Returning them back home, especially for those who don’t understand or who are divorced from our cultural background, will serve many purposes. One, it will teach and educate; two, it will revive certain parts of our customs and tradition that have been long forgotten.”

The return of the bronzes is the first such action under a new Smithsonian policy that authorises museums to return collections to the community of origin based on ethical considerations, such as the manner and circumstances in which items were acquired.

Ngaire Blankenberg, director of the National Museum of African Art, which was founded in 1964 and whose sources include a 2005 gift of 525 objects from the Walt Disney Company, said she felt uncomfortable at the sight of the bronzes when she arrived last year and took them down from display.

A Smithsonian ethical returns working group had already been convened.

“It’s not like I was out of step with the institution,” Blankenberg said. “In my interviews coming in, they did ask me what my position was around repatriation and I said, ‘Give them back.’”

Blankenberg made contact with Nigerian officials, who welcomed the prospect of the bronzes’ return. Blankenberg visited the west African country and worked through the bureaucratic process. Some of the bronzes will eventually go on display in Benin City. Others will remain in Washington on long-term loan.

man speaks behind podium next to another man
Prince Aghatise Erediauwa of the Benin Kingdom, Nigeria, speaks at the Benin bronzes repatriation ceremony at the National Museum of African Art in Washington on Tuesday. Photograph: Shannon Finney/Getty Images

The repatriation is part of a worldwide movement by cultural institutions to return artefacts often stolen during colonial wars. In August, the Horniman Museum and Gardens in London announced the transfer of 72 Benin bronzes to the Nigerian government.

Blankenberg is now looking at other “objects of concern” in her museum’s collection and engaging with relevant parties.

The 51-year-old, a Canadian-South African dual national, said:We’re not the guardians of the world. Western museums are not the custodians of all things of the world.

“I don’t believe in the universal museum rationale and, in this day and age, there’s loans, there’s travelling exhibitions, there’s a whole bunch of different ways that are completely accepted within the museum world through which other people from other cultures can see work from around the world.”

She added: “The debate is so ridiculous because there’s so many false premises. People are like, ‘Oh, no, if you give everything back, that’ll be nothing in this museum.’ I mean, honestly, we have over 12,000 collections and if our whole museum is based on stolen objects, then frankly, we shouldn’t exist.

“I’m fine to give it all back but the point is that it really isn’t [that] and it will make no difference to the average person.”


David Smith in Washington

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
New museum in Nigeria raises hopes of resolution to Benin bronzes dispute
Artefacts held by British museum and other western institutions were looted by British forces in 1897

Mark Brown Arts correspondent

14, Nov, 2020 @11:54 AM

Article image
London museum returns looted Benin City artefacts to Nigeria
Six objects stolen by British soldiers in 19th century are handed over in ceremony at Horniman Museum

Harriet Sherwood Arts and culture correspondent

28, Nov, 2022 @6:55 PM

Article image
London museum to return 72 Benin treasures to Nigeria
Horniman museum is first government-funded institution to hand back artefacts looted by British forces in 1897

Josh Halliday

07, Aug, 2022 @9:31 PM

Article image
British Museum/Guardian public forum – Nigeria: Africa's superpower?

Audio: Jon Snow is joined by Father Matthew Kukah, Dr Abdul Raufu Mustapha, Chika Unigwe and Dele Ogun for a British Museum/Guardian public forum on the past – and future – of Africa's most populous country

09, Jun, 2010 @10:22 AM

Article image
Germany hands over two Benin bronzes to Nigeria
Two countries sign restitution agreement covering more than 1,000 items in German hands

Philip Oltermann in Berlin

01, Jul, 2022 @4:22 PM

Article image
Museum of African American History displays range from slavery to Prince
Opening next month in Washington, the Smithsonian National Museum of African American History and Culture investigates 400 years of US society

Jamiles Lartey

30, Aug, 2016 @8:22 PM

Article image
Cambridge University to return over 100 looted Benin bronzes to Nigeria
Move to see restitution of 116 historical objects taken by British during the sacking of Benin in 1897

Jane Clinton

14, Dec, 2022 @11:39 PM

Article image
Germany returns 21 Benin bronzes to Nigeria – amid frustration at Britain
Artefacts looted in 19th century by UK soldiers and sold on, with many more still held by the British Museum

Philip Oltermann in Abuja

20, Dec, 2022 @3:51 PM

Article image
Yes, I’m a trustee of English Heritage. And I want the Benin bronzes returned | David Olusoga
Black Britons are still supposed to keep out of the debate on the country’s colonial past

David Olusoga

15, Dec, 2018 @6:30 PM

Getty museum admits 350 more treasures may be looted
A scandal surrounding the looting of ancient artefacts deepened yesterday when it emerged that 350 items worth $100m (£54m) held by one of America's leading museums are of dubious provenance.

Dan Glaister in Los Angeles

19, Jun, 2006 @10:45 AM