Angela Merkel says she lost influence over Putin as a lame duck leader

Germany’s former chancellor defends her actions amid barrage of accusations since Russia’s invasion of Ukraine

Angela Merkel has insisted that her position as a lame duck in the last months of her time in office made it more or less impossible for her to influence the behaviour of Vladimir Putin.

The former German chancellor appeared both defensive and quietly defiant about her inability to change the course of the Russian president’s decision-making in the run-up to the invasion of Ukraine in February.

In an interview with the German news magazine Spiegel, Merkel said she felt acutely aware that her ability to negotiate with Putin was minimal, owing to the fact it was known she would not stand for a fifth term in office.

“I no longer had the power to push my ideas through because everyone knew ‘she’ll be gone by autumn’,” she said, describing how she had tried to establish a round of European talks after a meeting in the summer of 2021 between the US president, Joe Biden, and Putin. “Had I been standing again in the September I’d have kept drilling down, but … at my final meeting in Moscow [with Putin and his foreign minister, Sergei Lavrov], the feeling was clear: from a political power point of view, you’re finished. For Putin it is only power that counts.”

In her interviews with Alexander Osang, which took place over a period of a year and in various locations, Merkel insisted that her stance on the Minsk agreement – which brought a ceasefire after Russia’s 2014 annexation of Ukraine’s Crimea peninsula – had been right. Key points of the Minsk peace talks, including disarmament and supervision by an international body, were never followed through. But Merkel said the agreement had nevertheless helped buy Kyiv time to arm itself better against the Russian military.

According to Osang, she repeatedly implied that she felt misunderstood over what she had tried to achieve as German leader, facing as she now does a barrage of accusations over some of her choices, such as her decision to block Ukraine’s admission to Nato in Bucharest in 2008, seen by many as having harmed its ability to defend itself. Her refusal to acknowledge her mistakes in allowing Germany to become ever more dependent on Russian gas supplies is another major criticism.

Merkel also appeared to be loosely comparing her behaviour to that of Neville Chamberlain, the British prime minister associated with the flawed policy of appeasement towards Adolf Hitler by allowing him to expand the territory of Nazi Germany in the 1930s.

Having watched the Netflix drama Munich – the Edge of War, based on the Robert Harris novel, in which the actor Jeremy Irons plays Chamberlain, Merkel said she had been intrigued to see him portrayed in another, more positive light – “not as a fearful stirrup-holder for Hitler but as a strategist who used his country to create a buffer so that it could better prepare for German attack”.

Merkel added it was unfair to suggest she had not paid Ukraine enough attention in 2013 and 2014. “People write about 2013 and 14 as if I had had nothing else to concern myself with than the Minsk agreement, and ask: ‘How could you have taken your eye off Ukraine?’ But this is too simple. We had elections [in Germany], there was always something going on with Greece at the time, and I broke my pelvic bone,” she said, referring to an injury incurred while on a cross-country skiing holiday in 2014.

Among the anecdotes she relays in a wide-ranging interview in which she is reflective and sometimes gloomy about her time in office, are encounters with the Queen – though Merkel said she was never able to establish what the British monarch thought about Brexit – and a G7 meeting with Boris Johnson, who she said had been attempting to undermine the Northern Ireland protocol. On warning him, apparently half in jest, that he was on his way to becoming a sinister Shakespearean figure, Johnson went out of the room, returning five minutes later to tell her: “If that is the case, then I want to be Hamlet.”

She said she was currently in a “period of pupation”, trying to reinvent herself. “I’ve entered a period of reflection, and the hamster wheel phenomenon is getting less.”

She said the activities she had found time for since leaving her post included watching the series The Crown, and Babylon Berlin. She had also watched the Queen’s funeral on television, and taken an interest in many of the guests she had recognised, including Tony Blair, whom Osang said she referred to as a “great political talent who had lost his reputation” over the Iraq war. She refers to reading Schiller and Shakespeare as well as Sebastian Haffner’s biography of Winston Churchill and said she was now reading Churchill’s mammoth war diaries, together with Beate Baumann, her longtime office manager. She and Baumann are also writing a book together about her chancellorship for which they have reportedly received a large advance.

One of her first out-of-post holidays had been a tour of Tuscany last spring with an art historian friend, she said.

Merkel said she had no regrets about not standing for office again, after 16 years at the helm. “Somebody new was needed. Domestically it was high time and from a foreign policy perspective… (there were) so many things we tried again and again, but were not moving a millimetre on. Not just over Ukraine, but also Transnistria, Moldova, Georgia, Abkhazia, Syria and Libya. It was time for a new approach.”

She said she sometimes woke in the night and worried about many of the dramatic events taking place in the world. “I think about how history doesn’t repeat itself, but how the horror disappears as the eye witnesses die. And the spirit of reconciliation also disappears.”

Of her meeting with Barack Obama in Washington in June when the former leaders visited a museum together and dined in an Italian restaurant, Merkel said: “I think he’s more in tune with himself. He knows he’ll always be something of a special personality. I’m still rather more in the searching phase. To put up with criticism is part of democracy but my impression is at the same time that an American president, after he leaves office, is treated with more respect in the public eye than a German chancellor.”


Kate Connolly in Berlin

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Germany agonises over Merkel’s legacy: did she hand too much power to Putin?
The war in Ukraine has prompted criticism of former chancellor’s decisions on Nord Stream pipeline and Russia

Philip Oltermann in Berlin

05, Mar, 2022 @3:00 PM

Article image
No regrets over handling of Vladimir Putin, says Angela Merkel
Former German chancellor claims her opposition to Ukraine’s Nato membership helped country

Philip Oltermann in Berlin

07, Jun, 2022 @9:54 PM

Article image
How Angela Merkel became Europe’s undisputed leader | Franziska Augstein
The German chancellor has done well over Ukraine. But she owes a lot to others

Franziska Augstein

15, Feb, 2015 @2:30 AM

Article image
Germany must shake off its torpor and play its full role against Putin | Simon Tisdall
Only the boldest leadership can unite the EU against the delusional tyrant in Moscow. The German chancellor has the chance to provide it

Simon Tisdall

10, Apr, 2022 @6:30 AM

Article image
Navalny poisoning forces Merkel’s party to ask: how to hit back at Putin?
The strength of the German chancellor’s condemnation of Russia was a surprise – and the multi-billion Nord Stream project could now be at risk

Philip Oltermann in Berlin Daniel Boffey in Brussels

05, Sep, 2020 @4:16 PM

Article image
Russia suspends Ukraine grain deal after attack on Sevastopol naval base
Move comes after assault by airborne and underwater drones in which flagship may be been damaged

Dan Sabbagh

29, Oct, 2022 @4:46 PM

Article image
Merkel tells Putin not to exclude Ukraine from gas pipeline route
German chancellor says Nord Stream 2 project is not possible without clarity on Ukraine’s role

Kate Connolly in Berlin

10, Apr, 2018 @4:40 PM

Article image
Putin has gambled away gas leverage, says German vice-chancellor
Robert Habeck says ‘half of our eggs were in the basket of Putin’ but Germany is now recovering capacity

Philip Oltermann in Oslo

05, Jan, 2023 @4:11 PM

Article image
Putin has to escalate to survive. There can be no peace until he falls
German chancellor Olaf Scholz’s vision of restoring the unity the continent had before the invasion of Ukraine cannot be achieved without removing Russia’s president

Simon Tisdall

11, Dec, 2022 @9:00 AM

Article image
‘I was born to do this’: Ukraine’s 2016 Eurovision winner Jamala on why Putin fears her people, Crimean Tatars
Jamala tells how her 2016 song shone a light on Stalin’s deportations and helped to dispel the myths that Crimea is historically Russian

Emma Graham-Harrison in Kyiv

13, May, 2023 @3:29 PM