People rescued in Italian waters spark row between Italy and France

French government calls Rome’s refusal to let boat carrying 234 asylum seekers dock ‘unacceptable’

The fate of hundreds of people rescued in the central Mediterranean by a charity vessel has sparked a diplomatic row between Italy and France, with the French government calling it “unacceptable” that Rome has refused to allow the ship, carrying 234 asylum seekers, to dock in an Italian port.

On Tuesday, the Ocean Viking rescue boat, operated by the European charity SOS Méditerranée under a Norwegian flag, began sailing towards France after Italy’s new far-right government refused to give it a safe port for more than two weeks.

The French government spokesperson, Olivier Véran, told FranceInfo on Wednesday: “The boat is currently in Italian territorial waters. There are extremely clear European rules which have been accepted by the Italians who are, in fact, the first beneficiary of a European financial solidarity mechanism.”

Véran added that the Italian government’s declarations were “unacceptable”, as was its refusal to allow the boat to dock. “We still have a few hours of discussions and, in any case, we are still at that stage. Obviously no one will let this boat run any risk, especially for the people on board,” he added. “We are following the situation minute by minute.”

Over the weekend, in its first test of migration policy, Italy’s new prime minister, Giorgia Meloni, the leader of a party with neo-fascist origins who once said Rome should “repatriate migrants and sink the boats that rescued them”, enacted its controversial anti-migration plan, which provides for the pushback of mostly male asylum seekers of adult age rescued in the central Mediterranean whom Italian authorities do not deem qualified for international protection.

On Saturday, Italy’s new interior minister, Matteo Piantedosi, initially allowed Humanity 1, a rescue boat run by the German NGO SOS Humanity, to enter the port of Catania in Sicily with 179 passengers onboard. However, Italian authorities began disembarking only children and sick people: 144 passengers were moved to a reception centre while the rest, all males over the age of 18, were left onboard with Rome threatening to push them back into international waters.

On Sunday, it was the turn of another rescue boat, the Geo Barents, run by Médecins Sans Frontières and carrying 568 asylum seekers. Again, after a quick inspection on board, 217 people were left on the ship, with volunteers reporting people sleeping on the decks, as fever-inducing infections and scabies spread.

After a two-day standoff, all remaining asylum seekers aboard the two charity vessels were allowed to disembark due to their physical and psychological condition.

On Tuesday, after unsuccessfully waiting for permission to dock in Italy since late October, Ocean Viking appealed to France, requesting authorisation to disembark its passengers.

Meloini said on Wednesday: “The people aboard the NGO vessels are migrants, not shipwrecked. We did not ask for the disembarkation of all the people aboard the vessels. That was the doctors’ decision after a second inspection on board, and we found that decision bizarre.”

Sophie Beau, the director general of SOS Méditerranée, said: “The situation aboard the Ocean Viking has reached a critical stage. We are now confronted with very serious consequences including the risk of loss of human life … after more than two weeks of being blocked at sea.”

The Ocean Viking is now sailing toward France and should reach international waters off the French Mediterranean island of Corsica by Thursday.

Gilles Simeoni, the president of the executive council on Corsica, said he was “ready if necessary” to allow Ocean Viking into one of the island’s ports temporarily. He said the row between the French and Italian governments was regrettable and playing out “at the expense of the health, and perhaps the lives, of hundreds of people who are in a state of distress”.

“Our position is dictated by the duty of humanity, by the emergency. We cannot, when there are people suffering and in absolute distress a few dozen kilometres from the Corsican coast, look the other way,” Simeoni said.

A French interior ministry source cited by BFMTV criticised the Italian authorities’ “unacceptable behaviour” that they said was “contrary to marine law as well as the spirit of European solidarity”.

On Wednesday, Piantedosi said its government “will not accept lessons on human rights”.

Meanwhile, Meloni thanked France for “sharing the responsibility of the migratory emergency, which up to now has been on the back of Italy and a few other states”.

“The immigration emergency is a European issue,” she said, “and it should be addressed as such.”


Lorenzo Tondo in Palermo and Kim Willsher in Paris

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Italian foreign minister calls off Paris visit over ‘insults’ from France
Move comes after French interior minister accuses Italy’s PM of lying to voters over migration

Angela Giuffrida in Rome and Angelique Chrisafis in Paris

04, May, 2023 @4:26 PM

Article image
Italian judge orders release of ship captain who rescued refugees
Money will go towards paying Carola Rackete’s legal fees if charges are brought

Lorenzo Tondo in Palermo and Josie Le Blond in Berlin

02, Jul, 2019 @9:36 PM

Article image
Sea rescue charities rebel against Italian anti-immigration rules
NGOs say measures including requirement to request port after first rescue could result in thousands of deaths

Angela Giuffrida in Rome

30, Dec, 2022 @12:08 PM

Article image
France summons Italian envoy over 'hostile' Africa remarks
Italian deputy PM blames migrant crisis on France’s ‘colonisation’ of Africa

Angela Giuffrida in Rome

22, Jan, 2019 @12:17 PM

Article image
EU migration row boils over as Italy and France trade insults
Austria calls for ‘axis of the willing’ to take action, and rifts widen in German coalition

Jon Henley, Angela Giuffrida and Kate Connolly

13, Jun, 2018 @4:49 PM

Article image
Europe’s far right praise UK’s illegal migration bill
Alternative für Deutschland leaders were among those lauding Sunak’s bill, while other EU figures raised doubts about its legality

Jennifer Rankin in Brussels

09, Mar, 2023 @11:24 PM

Article image
France to let migrant rescue ship dock as it criticises Italy’s refusal to help
Ocean Viking will bring 234 people to Toulon amid deepening row with Rome over Mediterranean rescues

Angelique Chrisafis in Paris

10, Nov, 2022 @5:50 PM

Article image
Migrant rescue ship barred from Italy seeks help from EU nations
NGO director appeals directly to France, Germany and Spain after Italy and Malta spurn boat

Stephen Burgen in Barcelona

08, Aug, 2019 @10:59 AM

Article image
Lake Maggiore deaths: why were Italian and Israeli secret service agents on a boat in northern Italy?
Four died after a vessel carrying 21 passengers – all with links to Italian and Israeli intelligence – capsized, and speculation is growing about the nature of the trip

Angela Giuffrida in Rome and Oliver Holmes

02, Jun, 2023 @7:49 AM

Article image
Italian coastguard in rescue of two fishing boats carrying 1,200 people
Operation comes as attempted crossings of Mediterranean from north Africa surge over weekend

Angela Giuffrida in Rome

10, Apr, 2023 @4:45 PM