Study finds evidence of ‘considerable’ presymptomatic spread of monkeypox

Research could help explain how virus got so out of control this year, while also refining efforts to combat it

British researchers have identified evidence of “considerable” transmission of monkeypox in the few days before symptoms of the virus emerge.

If replicated, the finding would upend received wisdom about how the virus spreads. It could help explain how monkeypox, which causes sometimes excruciatingly painful lesions, got so out of control this year, while also refining efforts to combat it.

US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) guidance on monkeypox currently indicates that people “can spread it to others from the time symptoms start until the rash has fully healed”. While the CDC states that to date “there is no evidence that monkeypox spreads from people with no symptoms”, the agency is monitoring for new information.

Researchers from the UK Health Security Agency (UKHSA) published such new information in the BMJ, the British Medical Association journal, on Wednesday.

“It’s an important and potentially controversial paper,” said Dr Esther E Freeman, director of Global Health Dermatology at Harvard Medical School and a co-author of an accompanying editorial.

“It provides evidence that there may be presymptomatic transmission of monkeypox going on. But like any modeling paper, it still needs to be reproduced and validated using other real-world data.”

A relative of smallpox, monkeypox was first identified in humans in 1970 and is endemic to 11 African nations. During an unprecedented global outbreak first identified in the UK in May, the virus has largely been transmitted through sexual contact between men.

Globally, 77,174 people have been found to have monkeypox in 109 countries, including 28,442 in the US, according to the CDC. Global and US cases have been declining steadily since peaking in August, probably driven down by vaccination, sexual behavioral change and acquired immunity.

The authors of the new study examined routine surveillance data collected by UKHSA on 2,746 people diagnosed with monkeypox in Britain between 6 May and 1 August, in particular 650 who completed questionnaires. Of the 1,213 overall cohort members about whom there was such information, 95% were men who reported sex with men.

According to the accompanying editorial, the study authors made “appropriate statistical adjustments” to the data in their analysis. Specifically, they used mathematical models to control for various factors that might introduce bias, such changing UK infection rates.

The investigators analyzed questionnaire data regarding 54 members of the cohort to estimate the monkeypox incubation period – the time from infection to symptom onset. They further looked at data on 79 individuals to estimate the so-called serial interval, the period between one person’s first symptoms and the symptom onset of a person to whom they probably passed the virus.

Depending on the mathematical models used, the median serial interval was 0.3 to 1.7 days shorter than the median incubation period, which was typically about a week. This suggested that a “substantial” proportion of cases – an estimated 53% –transmitted presymptomatically.

Validation of this finding came from an analysis of 13 pairs of people between whom monkeypox was probably transmitted. Ten of these cases suggested presymptomatic transmission, occurring a maximum of four days before symptom onset.

Such findings, the authors write, suggest that efforts to trace the close contacts of people with monkeypox should not remain restricted to contacts dating back to the day symptoms began.

The investigators suggest that while monkeypox viral load might be relatively low during the presymptomatic period, “specific types of high intensity interactions” such as sexual contact might effectively overcome this obstacle and facilitate transmission.

People might also transmit the virus when they first have symptoms but before they become aware of them.

If presymptomatic transmission is indeed a major driver of the monkeypox outbreak, this calls into question the impact of public health policies compelling people to isolate while symptomatic, the study authors write. Some infectious disease experts have suggested that isolation policies might have a limited curbing effect on a virus that does not typically spread through casual contact.

Dr Boghuma Titanji, an infectious disease specialist at Emory University in Atlanta, called the study “very well done” and said it “makes a very strong argument that there is some presymptomatic transmission”.

Noting that infections that can pass silently like this are harder to control, Titanji said the study’s main finding “throws a curveball into modeling what the outbreak will look like in coming months”.

The study is limited by the fact that it depended on potentially unreliable recollections of sexual contacts and the timing of symptoms.

A French study released in a pre-print in July and published in October raised the specter of monkeypox transmitting without any symptoms. Among anal swabs taken from 200 men who have sex with men who had no monkeypox signs, 13 tested positive for the virus. At least two ultimately developed symptoms.

In a statement, Dr Nachi Arunachalam, UKHSA monkeypox incident director, said “there is still more work needed to understand presymptomatic and asymptomatic infections and what that might mean for future policies and management of the monkeypox outbreak”.


Benjamin Ryan in New York

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Monkeypox: Schiff demands to know why US does not have more vaccines
Ashish Jha, coronavirus response coordinator, defends Biden administration response but California Democrat wants answers

Guardian staff and agencies

24, Jul, 2022 @4:57 PM

Article image
Thai researchers test wastewater to track spread of monkeypox
Monitoring sewage thought to be a quicker, more cost-effective way to understand the spread of the virus

Rebecca Ratcliffe in Bangkok

28, Jul, 2022 @10:04 AM

Article image
Monkeypox cases put UK's tropical disease response to the test
Unprecedented diagnoses show system set up after Ebola works well, medics says

Nazia Parveen North of England correspondent

07, Oct, 2018 @1:48 PM

Article image
We will see more cases of monkeypox, warn British scientists
The range and number of cases has puzzled doctors, who are asking why the virus has spread to the west

Robin McKie Science Editor

21, May, 2022 @10:04 PM

Article image
Smallpox vaccines may not protect against monkeypox for life
Researchers say some patients had childhood jab, and HIV infection could erode protection

Nicola Davis Science correspondent

15, Aug, 2022 @11:25 AM

Article image
More monkeypox cases detected in UK ‘on daily basis’, says scientist
Twenty cases confirmed in UK amid reports of child being admitted to intensive care in London hospital

Ian Sample Science editor

22, May, 2022 @1:40 PM

Article image
Monkeypox patients advised to avoid contact with pets for three weeks
UK experts urge confirmed cases to avoid handling household pets as precautionary measure

Nicola Davis Science correspondent

27, May, 2022 @5:10 PM

Article image
First trial of antiviral monkeypox drug that could speed recovery begins in UK
Clinical trial will explore whether Tecovirimat can reduce time it takes for skin lesions and ulcers to heal

Nicola Davis Science correspondent

23, Aug, 2022 @12:45 PM

Article image
What is monkeypox and how worried should we be?
With cases being identified around the world, WHO has declared the outbreak a global emergency

Nicola Davis Science correspondent

23, Jul, 2022 @4:11 PM

Article image
Monkeypox is truly an emergency. The WHO was right to raise the highest alarm | Devi Sridhar
Supporting the people most at-risk of this awful disease is the only way to reduce its impact and stop its spread, says global health expert Devi Sridhar

Devi Sridhar

25, Jul, 2022 @1:07 PM