Russia’s ‘warning’ of Ukraine’s biological weapons sounds just like Syria

Analysis: Putin used the same false justification for brutal bombings in Syria, in the glare of western media

When a Russian spokesperson took to a podium in Moscow on Wednesday and warned of a “biological weapons programme” in Ukraine, fighters on another battlefield – Syria – understood what she meant.

The anti-Assad opposition groups that still held northern Syria had heard it all before. From 2015, when Russia took a prominent stake in the conflict, and throughout the gruesome years that followed, claims that they, instead of the Assad regime, had used chemical weapons were a ready-made slur that put them on notice of an imminent assault. The allegations were made by Moscow, whenever ground forces it was supporting wanted to clear a town or city. Brutal, indiscriminate bombardment followed. So did impunity.

Even in its infancy, the Russian war in Ukraine has many parallels with the conflict in Syria: barely restrained savagery, the mass flight of terrified civilians, and wanton destruction. Now the use of foreboding pretexts can be added to a growing list, which was born amid the ruins of Grozny, Crimea and Donbas and fine-tuned on the civilian population of Syria’s beleaguered north.

The Pentagon and Ukraine’s leadership both disdainfully denied the Russian claim, which had been accompanied by a call for answers, and there seemed little likelihood of it cutting through an international discourse that has run heavily against the Kremlin and its disinformation programmes.

It was a very different story in Syria, where each claim of chemical weapons use by rebels was received with credulity in parts of the UK and Europe and there was little interest in exposing Moscow’s lies. Winning the war of misinformation was a Russian success in Syria, in a theatre that wasn’t short of wins for a military with no one apart from outgunned rebels and jihadists willing to stand in its way.

“Ukraine today is part of a much longer continuum than Syria,” a former senior Nato officer told the Guardian. “It goes back further than Chechnya – politically, in terms of foreign policy, in terms of Russia’s internal dynamics and in terms of the tactics of the Russian war machine. The only surprise over the past fortnight is quite how useless the Russian armed forces have been – thankfully. They have been utterly dire in every respect, which is very good news all round.

“We are all victims of our experience, and Putin’s experience is of being able to get away with almost anything he wants in every dimension of warfare. The blatant fostering of frozen conflicts in high-profile nations such as Georgia and Ukraine, the widespread and hardly concealed undermining of governance through hybrid warfare, the use of the most brutal tactics, crushing of whole towns and cities along with their populations.

“His experience is that you can grind out a win using heavy explosives in the full glare of western media attention. And with an extremely effective control of his own [patriotic] population, he has little to fear at home.”

Compared with the quagmire it has found in Ukraine and the blistering international reaction to its invasion, Syria was a relatively low-cost intervention for Moscow. Its pilots ran bombing runs without serious fear of being shot from the skies, its heavy weaponry had the run of towns and cities and its disinformation machine won at a canter.

“The scope of the Ukraine war is different,” said Charles Lister, the director of the Syria and counter-terrorism programme at the Middle East Institute. “But some of the tactics were definitely learned and deployed in Syria.

“The broad assumption of impunity unquestionably drove this forward and put Putin in a psychological position where he believed something like this was feasible. He learned to pay no regard to international red lines. The sustained and overwhelming use of heavy bombardment aimed at undermining public confidence and as a tool of intimidation now being seen in Mariupol was honed in Syria, where Russia barely used precision-guided munitions.

“The vast majority have been dumb bombs. To use these, they need to fly at a lower level. And that’s why we are seeing Russian planes shot down, by Stingers and other ground-to-air missiles that were not supplied to the rebels in Syria.”

Another parallel has emerged in recent days – an often cynical use of human corridors as tools of coercion. “It is the shock and awe effect on the population, and one that leads to a greater number of war crimes.

“We saw this in Aleppo and now we are seeing it in places like Mariupol. It is clearly a tactic of intimidation and subjugation. … In both cases, it’s shell to hell, surround and besiege, then shell to hell again and offer concessions.”


Martin Chulov Middle East correspondent

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Syria chemical attack: US and Russia fail to reach UN agreement as tensions rise
Russia and western allies clash at the UN security council and vote against each other’s proposals

Julian Borger in Washington and Patrick Wintour in London

10, Apr, 2018 @10:56 PM

Article image
Syria ceasefire appears to hold after rivals sign Russia-backed deal
Despite some early clashes, all sides say they hope this time the pact will hold in the run-up to talks in Kazakhstan that could lay out path to peace

Shaun Walker in Moscow and Kareem Shaheen in Istanbul and agencies

30, Dec, 2016 @7:47 AM

Article image
Obama's Hanover talks unlikely to yield new line on vexed issues
US president expected to discuss Syria, Isis, the refugee crisis and Libya with French, German, Italian and British leaders

Simon Tisdall

25, Apr, 2016 @6:00 AM

Article image
Syrians join Russian ranks in Ukraine as Putin calls in Assad’s debt
Analysis: Safe in his palace, Syrian leader appears to have given Moscow carte blanche to airlift his army

Martin Chulov Middle East correspondent

18, Mar, 2022 @2:47 PM

Article image
Vladimir Putin: from pariah to powerbroker in one year
At the 2014 G20 summit in Brisbane, the Russian president was browbeaten by western leaders. But now they know they need him

Simon Tisdall

17, Nov, 2015 @12:58 PM

Article image
Loose ends in efforts to untangle the Gordian knot of Syria | Letters
Letters: We have had ‘Saddam must go’ and ‘Gaddafi must go’: surely opinion-makers cannot repeat those failed mantras without being clear about an alternative that does not mean chaos and unending bloodshed?


06, Oct, 2015 @7:54 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on Russia’s Syria U-turn: no kind of victory | Editorial
Editorial: Vladimir Putin has made a geopolitical point for the Kremlin at the expense of hundreds of fresh Syrian dead and the military strengthening of Isis


15, Mar, 2016 @7:05 PM

Article image
Syria crisis: Vladimir Putin under growing pressure

Russian president to be urged at G20 summit to come closer to accepting that Bashar al-Assad has to stand aside

Patrick Wintour and Kim Willsher in Paris

03, Sep, 2013 @6:47 AM

Article image
Moscow: Syria airstrikes 'significant blow to Russian-US relations'
Missile launches in violation of international law, says Vladimir Putin spokesman Dmitry Peskov

Shaun Walker in Moscow

07, Apr, 2017 @4:12 PM

Article image
Vladimir Putin orders withdrawal of Russian troops from Syria
Russian president says soldiers should begin pulling out of country as military intervention has largely achieved its aims

Patrick Wintour in Geneva and Shaun Walker in Moscow

15, Mar, 2016 @7:11 AM