‘We all demand justice’: the unsolved murder of the man Bruno Pereira mentored

The deaths of Dom Phillips and Bruno Pereira echo that of Maxciel Pereira dos Santos, the Indigenous protection agent killed in cold blood three years ago

When Noemia Pereira dos Santos heard that Dom Phillips and Bruno Pereira had been murdered, she wept and thought of her own son Maxciel.

An officer in Brazil’s Indigenous protection agency, Funai, Maxciel Pereira dos Santos had worked closely with Bruno Pereira patrolling the increasingly perilous waters of the Javari valley region in remote Amazonas. Tracing illegal fishing and hunting operations, seizing guns and ammunition – it was poorly paid, precarious work, which many believe cost both men their lives.

In September 2019 Maxciel was shot dead in cold blood on the streets of the Brazilian city Tabatinga, which sits on the tri-state border between Peru and Colombia. Almost three years later, the murder remains unsolved.

“He never told us about the dangers of the work, so that we would not worry,” said Noemia, 65, at her small home in Tabatinga as she clutched her son’s green uniform. “But he said it was a job for brave men.”

“I believe his death was ordered by the same people who ordered Bruno’s death,” she said.

Noemia had not spoken publicly since Maxciel’s murder but said the deaths of Phillips and Pereira helped her to speak out and call for justice for her son. She has received no word on the ongoing police investigation in years, and the family does not have funds to pay for a lawyer.

“When I heard about Bruno and Dom, it was the very same sadness that came to me once again,” she told the Guardian. “We all demand justice.”

Maxciel Pereira dos Santos was her youngest of 11 children, whom she raised as a single mother. A photograph of him, stood rigid in his Funai uniform, adorns a wooden shelf in the corner of the living room next to a vase of flowers.

During a career at Funai that spanned 12 years, Santos earned a reputation as a diligent enforcer of federal laws protecting Indigenous people in the region. He was involved in a number of seizures – of ammunition, meat and salt –in the valley shortly before he was shot dead, said members of the Indigenous rights advocacy group Univaja, who share the family’s belief that Santos was murdered because of his work.

The area, almost the size of Ireland and Wales combined, has just a handful of Funai outposts and has seen a rise in illegal logging, gold mining, hunting and drug trafficking. Documents seen by the Guardian show that Santos’s assignment at the time he was killed was to “execute territorial monitoring and surveillance” in Indigenous territory.

“Bad people don’t die the way he was killed,” said Manoel Chorimpa, a Univaja member and former councilman in the riverside town of Atalaia do Norte.

Santos was shot twice in the head, according to an autopsy report. Family members said he was killed execution-style while riding his motorcycle on the street, with his partner sat behind him. He had been called back to Tabatinga at short notice while on assignment with Funai, according to multiple sources.

The Brazilian federal police did not respond to a request for comment on the investigation.

Santos’s death came just a few weeks before Bruno Pereira, his friend and mentor, left Funai amid sweeping changes at the agency under the newly elected Bolsonaro administration, aimed at curtailing its power and limiting its enforcement capacity.

Upon election the far-right leader sidelined Funai by moving it from the justice department to a newly created women, family and human rights ministry. The agency has also lost significant expertise, with 37 of the 39 regional Funai coordinators now coming from outside the office, most from the military and six with no government experience at all, according to a recent report by Indigenistas Associados and Inesc.

The report alleges many of the agency’s experts have been sidelined or fired under Bolsonaro with meaningful enforcement action now “impossible due to insufficient budget”.

In an unedited interview transcript with Bruno Pereira published by the newspaper Folha after his death, the former Funai official slammed the agency’s leadership under the current president.

“The more he [Bolsonaro] destroys, messes with internal regulations and threatens employees, the more he succeeds,” Pereira said in comments that were off the record at the time.

Internal Funai documents, written in the wake of Santos’s murder and reviewed by the Guardian, reveal that agents working in the Javari valley had pleaded with supervisors to send more resources to the region.

In a letter dated 16 January 2020, two Funai agents posted to the region asked their seniors stationed in Brasília to send more law enforcement resources, claiming the security situation had become untenable.

The letter lists 27 points, including the murder of Santos, which they claim is “possible retaliation for … seizing environmental contraband” and states that one Funai checkpoint in the region had come under gunfire seven times “creating a climate of impunity and fear among professionals who act to protect that Indigenous area”.

A spokesperson for Funai did not respond to questions about Santos’s murder. The spokesperson said the agency had requested more resources in the Javari valley region as recently as February 2022, but did not provide specifics.

Before his death, Santos had shared few details with his family, but they had noticed how precarious his work had become.

“The whole family voted for Bolsonaro, but it all got worse after he was elected,” said his older brother Oziel Pereira dos Santos. But Maxciel kept doing his job “because he loved the knowledge that came from the Indigenous people”.

Sign up to First Edition, our free daily newsletter – every weekday morning at 7am BST

The family remain incensed that little has seemingly been done to solve the crime. They said that they have been told they are not entitled to any compensation after his murder.

Santos left behind two young daughters, 17-year-old Gabrielle Cristine and 11-year-old Maria Eduarda, whom he had supported throughout their lives.

“He was a good father, and my life changed a lot after his death,” said Gabrielle Cristine. “We don’t starve but we don’t have money for new clothes.”

Although he shielded his children from the risks he took at work, they had a sense of the perils out on the river.

“He never told us,” said Gabrielle Cristine. “But then he never invited us to come with him either.”


Oliver Laughland and Roberto Kaz in Tabatinga, Amazonas

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Indigenous groups scour forests and rivers for Dom Phillips and Bruno Pereira
Indigenous activists have been searching for the missing pair since just hours after they vanished, with support from armed members of the military police

Tom Phillips on the River Itaquaí

10, Jun, 2022 @2:12 PM

Article image
Calls for justice amid fears inquiry into killings of Dom Phillips and Bruno Pereira stalling
Three men are in custody and more arrests are planned, but the suspected murder weapon has not been found

Oliver Laughland and Roberto Kaz in Atalaia do Norte

23, Jun, 2022 @11:31 PM

Article image
Six months after Dom Phillips and Bruno Pereira were murdered, the Amazon remains unsafe for activists
Activists are cautiously hopeful that the incoming president will bring relief to Bolsonaro’s forest-wrecking administration

Tom Phillips in the Amazon

05, Dec, 2022 @10:00 AM

Article image
Brazil Indigenous agency staff strike over Bruno Pereira disappearance
Employees walk off the job amid anger over statements criticising the former Funai employee who went missing with Dom Phillips

Andrew Downie in São Paulo

14, Jun, 2022 @7:00 PM

Article image
Bruno Pereira and Dom Phllips were killed in the Amazon. Their Indigenous allies risk death to carry on the work
The Brazilian Amazon and its Indigenous people remain under siege but a patrol group the killed activist helped form is fighting back

Tom Phillips

01, Jun, 2023 @12:00 PM

Article image
Bruno Pereira: the dedicated defender of Indigenous rights missing in Brazil
Indigenous expert last seen travelling with British journalist Dom Phillips was ousted from official role after Bolsonaro took office

Andrew Downie in São Paulo and Caio Barretto Briso in Rio de Janeiro

08, Jun, 2022 @1:52 PM

Article image
Tuesday briefing: Hope all but lost for Dom Phillips and Bruno Pereira
In today’s newsletter: Amid conflicting reports over the fate of journalist Dom Phillips and Indigenous expert Bruno Pereira, friends and colleagues call for action

Archie Bland

14, Jun, 2022 @5:47 AM

Article image
Ex-chief of Brazil’s Indigenous agency charged over murders of Bruno Pereira and Dom Phillips
Marcelo Xavier accused of indirectly contributing on the grounds that he failed to take steps to protect workers in Amazon

Tom Phillips in Rio de Janeiro

19, May, 2023 @9:19 PM

Article image
The writer and the activist: how Dom Phillips and Bruno Pereira bonded over the Amazon
The two men spent years traveling together in canoes and on foot. They disappeared on what was supposed to be a final trip

Andrew Downie in São Paulo and Tom Phillips in Atalaia do Norte

13, Jun, 2022 @6:24 PM

Article image
Amazon forest guardians fulfil Bruno Pereira’s mission of Indigenous exchange
Pereira, who was murdered alongside British journalist Dom Phillips, planned to lead an Indigenous delegation 2,500km across Brazil to learn from veteran fellow defenders

Tom Phillips in the Araribóia indigenous territory, photography by João Laet

22, Aug, 2022 @9:00 AM