‘Abusing China’s restraint’: Beijing accuses Australia of provocation at sea

Global Times quotes comments by foreign ministry spokesman Wang Wenbin on military encounters in the South China Sea

China has accused Australia of provocation in the South China Sea and said Australia – along with the United States and Canada – must “refrain from abusing China’s restraint”.

Foreign ministry spokesman Wang Wenbin was responding to a question about recent military encounters in the South China Sea, including reports in Politico that a Chinese fighter jet had an “unsafe” and “unprofessional” interaction with an American C-130 aircraft.

Politico reported that the interaction came amid more aggressive military actions by Chinese pilots involving Australian and Canadian planes.

Just after the May Australian election, an RAAF P-8 maritime surveillance aircraft was intercepted by a Chinese fighter jet, which the prime minister, Anthony Albanese, called “an act of aggression and a dangerous act”.

Wang’s comments on the interactions were reported in the Global Times, owned by China’s ruling Communist party.

“We … urge the relevant parties to respect facts, refrain from abusing China’s restraint, and immediately stop any actions that endanger China’s national sovereignty and security in the name of implementing UN security council resolutions,” he was quoted as saying.

The Global Times reported that Wang had previously said the actions were a “complete provocation” to China.

Relations between Australia and China have shown some signs of a thaw, particularly after the foreign affairs minister, Penny Wong, met her Chinese counterpart, Wang Yi, in Bali earlier this month.

However, tensions remain over trade, as well as China’s militarisation in the South China Sea, the artificial islands it has built and its claims to territory contested by other Asian nations.

The US regularly runs freedom of navigation operations (Fonops) in the region, as it does all over the world to challenge other countries’ claims to territorial rights.

It has put some pressure on Australia to do the same. But Australia, while it regularly exercises its right to send warships and planes through the area (which covers critical trade routes), does not venture within 12 nautical miles of territory claimed by China.

Some have speculated that something closer to a US-style program could begin under the new defence minister, Richard Marles. Donald Rothwell, an international law professor at the Australian National University, said the ministerial language has become more assertive.

In response to an ABC story earlier this month about an Australian warship being tracked by a Chinese submarine, Marles declined to address the incident but said Australia routinely sent warships.

“It’s been doing it for decades, and it is focused on asserting the UN convention on the law of the sea: freedom of navigation, freedom of overflight, the global rules-based order, which I’ve been describing as being so important for our national interest,” he said.

Rothwell said the statement seemed like a “hardening” of the language. “We’ve never formally conducted Fonops like the US,” he said. “But now we’re actively ‘asserting’, because we believe we can do that under the law of the sea convention.”

Ben Scott, the director of the Australia’s Security and the Rules-Based Order Project at the Lowy Institute, agreed, saying usually a minister would use the word “exercise” freedom, rather than “assert”.

“If you compare what he’s said with what Defence has said officially, his take has been much more front-footed,” Scott said.

He also noted that in opposition Marles had called for Australia to start Fonops.

In 2016, Marles said the navy and air force should be authorised to conduct freedom of navigation exercises in the South China Sea, including within 12 nautical miles of the artificial islands China has built there.

“It is important that we are asserting our rights to navigate the high seas under international law,” he told the Sydney Morning Herald.

Marles has been contacted for comment.

Sign up to receive the top stories from Guardian Australia every morning

John Blaxland, a professor of international security and intelligence studies at the Australian National University, said it was important that Australia continued its existing missions because “if you don’t exercise a right, you eventually forfeit it”. But he said Australia’s approach was “consistent” and had been so for 40 years.

“We appreciate we’re potentially a target if we stick our heads too far above the parapet,” he said.

While Australia has been consistent, China keeps expanding the size of the zone it claims, including by its so-called nine-dash line.

“China’s trying to scare away, intimidate away, these rights of navigation, rights of transit,” Blaxland said.

Contributor

Tory Shepherd

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Australia sees climate crisis as a national security issue, defence minister tells US
Richard Marles delivers speech in US warning of increased militarisation in South China Sea and importance of climate action to Pacific allies

Paul Karp and Adam Morton

12, Jul, 2022 @4:58 AM

Article image
Australia giving 'serious consideration' to US request to help it confront Iran
Mike Pompeo hails ‘unbreakable’ relationship between Washington and Canberra as he urges Australia to join coalition to protect shipping in the Gulf

Katharine Murphy Political editor

04, Aug, 2019 @6:43 AM

Article image
South China Sea: Australian warships encounter Chinese navy in disputed waters
Canberra downplays the ‘unplanned interactions’ amid ongoing diplomatic tensions between two countries

Daniel Hurst

23, Jul, 2020 @4:44 AM

Article image
Australia calls for ‘return to calm’ amid Taiwan drills as Beijing demands Canberra ‘respect China’s core interests’
Defence minister Richard Marles says a halt to live-fire drills is ‘what everyone in the world wants’

Tory Shepherd

09, Aug, 2022 @9:41 AM

Article image
China’s targeting of Australian military planes ‘aggressive and irresponsible’, US says
Defense department’s Ely Ratner says such incidents represent ‘one of the most significant threats to peace and stability in the region’

Tory Shepherd

28, Jul, 2022 @2:35 AM

Article image
‘We don’t have limitless resources’: Australian government prepared to scale back defence projects
While Labor has committed to an increase in defence spending, Richard Marles refused to rule out building first nuclear-powered submarines offshore

Daniel Hurst Foreign affairs and defence correspondent

23, Jan, 2023 @2:00 PM

Article image
Australian officials warned in 2021 about possible recruitment of ex-ADF members by Chinese military
Unclear what action, if any, then defence minister Peter Dutton took at the time

Daniel Hurst Foreign affairs and defence correspondent

16, Jan, 2023 @2:00 PM

Article image
Acting PM says Australia will stand up for national interest amid fading hopes of China reset
Richard Marles signals change in tone with biggest trading partner but pledges to avoid Coalition’s ‘chest-beating’

Daniel Hurst Foreign affairs and defence correspondent

01, Jul, 2022 @3:42 AM

Article image
US senators urge Joe Biden not to sell ‘scarce’ nuclear submarines to Australia
Democrat and Republican lawmakers reportedly warned president that Aukus security pact could stress US submarine industrial base ‘to breaking point’

Paul Karp

06, Jan, 2023 @5:51 AM

Article image
What happened when a Chinese ship shone a laser at an Australian plane – and why does it matter?
With the stakes rising and an election looming, Beijing’s apparent escalation must be handled firmly but delicately

John Blaxland for the Conversation

21, Feb, 2022 @1:07 AM