Why Israel faces new dangers in shadow war against Iran if nuclear deal is agreed

Analysis: a new pact will be worse for Israel than the old one and Iran’s influence in the region has grown in recent years

The US decision to withdraw from the Iran nuclear deal was an immense personal achievement for former Israeli prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu. In a leaked video, he boasted that he had personally convinced Donald Trump to scrap the 2015 accord between Tehran and world powers.

“I had to stand up against the whole world and come out against this agreement,” Netanyahu told members of his Likud party in the clip from 2018. “And we didn’t give up.”

But four years on, the Israeli leader has been booted out of office – as has Trump. Both Congress and the Knesset contain more leftwing voices, while in Iran, moderate Hassan Rouhani lost last year’s presidential election to hardliner Ebrahim Raisi.

Hossein Amir-Abdoulahian and Sayyid Badr Albusaidi
Iranian foreign minister Hossein Amir-Abdoulahian (r) and his Omani counterpart Sayyid Badr Albusaidi in Tehran giving an update on the Vienna nuclear talks on 23 February. Photograph: Abedin Taherkenareh/EPA

International negotiators in Vienna are edging closer to what amounts to a watered-down version of the original deal. In the process, what a short time ago was believed by many Israelis to be Netanyahu’s major geopolitical victory has instead become a growing source of concern for Israel’s political and security establishment.

“The US has tried maximum pressure with sanctions, Israel has assassinated nuclear scientists and carried out attacks designed to limit Iranian military activity around the region. But none of it has worked,” said Danny Citrinowicz, who led Israel’s military intelligence research between 2013 and 2016.

“All it’s done is push Iran forward with its nuclear programme. Now we are out of options, and I worry that Israel and Iran are on a collision course in the near future.”

The 2015 agreement spearheaded by Barack Obama lifted crippling international sanctions on the Islamic Republic’s economy in exchange for 10-15 years of curbs on its nuclear activities.

Since it unravelled in 2018, Iran has raced ahead with uranium enrichment. Although the Iranian government maintains that its nuclear programme is peaceful, experts generally agree that should it choose to, Tehran could possess functional nuclear weapons within two years.

The restored deal is set to maintain the original’s timeframes, meaning limits on uranium enrichment will still expire in 2025.

For Israel, the outcome is much worse than the maligned 2015 accord.

Tehran has not just made significant technological progress, which will only be monitored for the next three years, it is also about to receive $7bn in released frozen assets, as well as sanctions relief on exports such as oil.

This money, Israel believes, will be funnelled to Iran’s proxies across the region, and the international legitimacy conferred by the nuclear accord could encourage the Islamic Republic to be bolder in its regional ambitions.

Israel is already engaged in longstanding land and air campaigns on its borders against Lebanon’s Hezbollah, Iranian-funded groups in Syria and Palestinian militants in the Gaza Strip, as well as maritime skirmishes targeting Iranian and Israeli cargo ships in the Red and Mediterranean seas.

Iran also holds sway over Shia militias in Iraq, and sees Yemen’s Houthi rebels as partners of growing regional importance. In January the Houthis proved their drones and missiles were capable of reaching Abu Dhabi – which means Tel Aviv could soon be a target within their reach.

“Iran is entrenched in many theatres in the region now, and it’s not only military – we are talking about economic and cultural ties too. Combined with the proliferation of UAVs [unmanned aerial vehicles, or drones] and UASs [unmanned aerial systems], this is hybrid warfare,” said an IDF official who asked not to be named.

“If they want to hurt Israelis, they already have numerous axes to attempt it.”

Compared with the Netanyahu era, this time around Israeli officials have been watching quietly on the sidelines as the nuclear negotiations unfold. Aware there is little it can do to influence the outcome, the Israeli government instead appears to be pushing its US allies for a bilateral day-after agreement to address Israeli worries.

This week, President Naftali Bennett reiterated Israel’s longstanding position that the country “will always maintain its freedom of action to defend itself”.

In November the Knesset passed a budget featuring a 7bn shekel (£1.6bn) increase in spending for the defence establishment to prepare for the threat posed by Iran. Israel is also poised to deepen security ties with its new Abraham Accords partners in the Gulf, who also fear Iranian military capability: this month, a security pact was signed with Bahrain.

And while bringing the nuclear deal with Iran back to life may represent a limited success for the Biden administration, the stakes in the Middle East are still rising.

“These issues don’t exist in isolation any more. For example, during Operation Guardian of the Walls [the May 2021 war between Hamas and Israel], we saw that you can’t just attack Hamas. Hezbollah got involved too, and we had rocket fire from Lebanon,” said Citrinowicz.

“We are active in the shadow war, but we must preserve the rules of the game. If we do something dramatic in Iran, like striking nuclear facilities, it will trigger a severe escalation on many fronts.”


Bethan McKernan in Jerusalem

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Ex-Mossad chief signals Israel culpability for Iran attacks
Yossi Cohen reveals details of Iran nuclear programme attacks in interview timed to support Netanyahu

Peter Beaumont

11, Jun, 2021 @1:15 PM

Article image
Israeli PM in London to urge Johnson to end nuclear talks with Iran
British PM cleared his diary amid Brexit chaos to meet Benjamin Netanyahu

Patrick Wintour Diplomatic editor

05, Sep, 2019 @11:17 AM

Article image
Nuclear deal: Netanyahu accuses Iran of cheating on agreement
Israeli PM claims ‘new and conclusive proof’ shows Iran hid nuclear weapons, though evidence had been seen by UN watchdog

Oliver Holmes in Jerusalem and Julian Borger in Washington

30, Apr, 2018 @7:52 PM

Article image
Israel warns over Iran uranium capability with nuclear talks at halt
As IAEA board meets, Israel says Iran will be able to produce enough material for three warheads in weeks

Patrick Wintour Diplomatic editor

12, Sep, 2022 @5:05 PM

Article image
Netanyahu's theatrics help push Trump towards Iran deal withdrawal
The White House seized on Netanyahu’s dubious show-and-tell despite opposition from European allies desperate to keep the JCPOA afloat

Julian Borger World affairs editor

01, May, 2018 @7:19 PM

Article image
Israel tells UK and EU to drop ‘absurd’ backing for Iran nuclear deal
Netanyahu puts Dominic Raab under pressure over UK refusal to abandon nuclear agreement

Patrick Wintour Diplomatic editor

25, Aug, 2020 @2:57 PM

Article image
Trump and Netanyahu ready united assault against Iran nuclear deal
The two are bound by their mutual loathing of Obama’s foreign policy deal, even as it sets them apart from other world leaders at the UN general assembly

Julian Borger in New York

18, Sep, 2017 @6:00 AM

Article image
Europeans cast doubt on Israel's claims about Iran nuclear breaches
EU governments stand by 2015 deal with Tehran after presentation by Netanyahu

Patrick Wintour and Saeed Kamali Dehghan

01, May, 2018 @12:58 PM

Article image
Hawks in Iran and Israel agree: Biden’s bid to salvage nuclear deal must not succeed
With elections looming in both states, and hardliners out to ensure the collapse of the 2015 deal, time is running short for the US president to save it

Simon Tisdall

21, Feb, 2021 @7:00 AM

Article image
Iran scientist's assassination appears intended to undermine nuclear deal
Analysis: Shooting of Mohsen Fakhrizadeh will do more harm to diplomacy than it does to Iran’s nuclear programme

Julian Borger in Washington

27, Nov, 2020 @7:52 PM