Forty potential ministerial code breaches never investigated, report reveals

Next ethics adviser, when appointed by Rishi Sunak, will probably face calls to open at least two complex cases

Forty potential breaches of the ministerial code have never been referred for investigation by the ethics adviser, data shows.

It comes as a parliamentary committee warned historical breaches of the code may never be investigated or resolved, including the conduct of the home secretary or Islamophobia claims against a former chief whip.

Rishi Sunak has launched a hunt for a new adviser on ministerial interests but the Guardian reported last week several candidates have turned down the role. Sunak is not offering any enhanced powers – which means advisers would not be able to launch their own investigations.

The ethics adviser, when appointed, would probably face calls to renew or open at least two complex investigations – including concluding one into alleged Islamophobic comments made by the then chief whip, Mark Spencer, to the Conservative MP Nusrat Ghani.

There will also probably be pressure to open an investigation into the home secretary, Suella Braverman, who was sacked for a potential security breach by Liz Truss though reinstated by Sunak.

In a new report, the public administration and constitutional affairs committee, said it would be concerning if the prime minister’s new adviser was not allowed to examine historical cases. It suggests the inquiry into allegations of racism towards Ghani will not be concluded, which the committee says is “unsatisfactory”.

It recommends that former ministers and civil servants who break the rules regulating the “revolving door” between government and private sector jobs should face legal action, to act as a “sufficient deterrent” for improper conduct.

It said primary legislation should be introduced to establish the independent adviser as a statutory position and they should retain the power to initiate investigations and complete any legacy inquiries they inherit.

The committee’s chair, the Conservative MP William Wragg, said: “Our inquiry has found that although we have a sophisticated landscape of ethics watchdogs in the UK to safeguard standards in public life, they lack the power to enforce the rules. The prime minister is rightly the ultimate arbiter of the rules in our system. We urge him to show leadership and give legal status to all the ethics watchdogs.”

The pressure group Transparency International has been among those calling for the role to have significantly enhanced powers since it was vacated by Christopher Geidt five months ago under Boris Johnson.

In analysis of media reports, the group found 40 potential breaches of the ministerial code have not been investigated over the past five years. Those included:

All the ministers have claimed donations and meetings were recorded accurately, but Transparency International said each one represented a potential breach that should be investigated where a perceived conflict of interest could arise.

The group has also called for appointments to the role to be made with a competitive process and for the position to be defined in law – rather than both being at the whim of the prime minister.

Daniel Bruce, the chief executive of Transparency International UK, said: “This is further evidence the conventions-based system that is supposed to uphold standards in high-office is simply not fit for purpose. The extent of potential misconduct at the heart of government may be a shock to many, but equally concerning should be the lack of transparency over why these cases were never investigated independently.”

Sir Alex Allan, a former independent adviser, resigned after Boris Johnson refused to take action after an investigation into bullying by the then-home secretary Priti Patel.

Truss, during her short tenure as prime minister, expressed no interest in appointing a successor to Geidt. No transparency data on ministers’ interests has been published since May, despite multiple changes of government including three prime ministers.

While Sunak searches for Geidt’s successor, a separate independent investigation has been launched into the conduct of the deputy prime minister, Dominic Raab, by the senior employment barrister Adam Tolley KC, who is examining three bullying complaints.

A government spokesperson said: “We have been clear that this government will have integrity, professionalism and accountability at every level and have committed to appointing an independent adviser on ministerial interests. This process is ongoing.”

  • This article was amended on 2 December 2022. Michael Gove accepted £120,000 in donations while chancellor of the duchy of Lancaster, not as housing secretary, as an earlier version stated.


Jessica Elgot Deputy political editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Did Boris Johnson break ministerial code over James Dyson tax texts?
PM says he alerted officials after sending texts, but entrepreneur’s name was never officially released

Peter Walker Political correspondent

21, Apr, 2021 @5:03 PM

Article image
Tory chair of health committee investigated over NHS lobbying claims
MP Steve Brine accused of lobbying NHS and ministers on behalf of recruitment firm that employed him

Rowena Mason Whitehall editor

17, Mar, 2023 @2:41 PM

Article image
‘Absolute madness’: circus around an MP that riled the Commons
Backbenchers infuriated as reality dawned and Owen Paterson’s path swerved from invincibility to hasty departure

Aubrey Allegretti

04, Nov, 2021 @9:47 PM

Article image
Ex-Tory chairman alleges Braverman responsible for ‘multiple breaches of ministerial code’
Opposition call for inquiry as Braverman is reappointed home secretary six days after resigning over security breach

Rajeev Syal , Jessica Elgot and Kevin Rawlinson

26, Oct, 2022 @9:57 PM

Article image
Sir Laurie Magnus named Rishi Sunak’s new ethics adviser
Prime minister appoints Historic England chair to role that had been vacant for six months

Peter Walker Political correspondent and Henry Dyer

22, Dec, 2022 @5:49 PM

Article image
Labour asks for lobbying by four Tory MPs to be investigated
Work of Iain Duncan Smith and three more MPs should be examined for possible rule breaches, Fleur Anderson tells cabinet secretary

Jessica Elgot Chief political correspondent

15, Nov, 2021 @12:51 PM

Article image
Key target in scrutiny row? Westminster’s standards watchdog
Efforts to undermine parliament’s independent regulator, Kathryn Stone, follow her repeated enquiries over Johnson finances

Robert Booth Social affairs correspondent

04, Nov, 2021 @6:54 PM

Article image
Tory U-turn complete as MPs approve Owen Paterson report
Rees-Mogg says trying to spare fellow MP from suspension was a ‘serious mistake’

Aubrey Allegretti Political correspondent

16, Nov, 2021 @3:52 PM

Article image
Ministers hold out against proposal on reporting hospitality in new MPs’ code
Government likely to accept 18 out of 20 recommendations but risks triggering another standards row

Rowena Mason Whitehall editor

10, Dec, 2022 @8:00 AM

Article image
Phoenix Community Capital case shines light on UK’s lobbying problem
Interest groups have poured about £250,000 into all-party parliamentary groups in past five years

Rowena Mason Whitehall editor

23, Feb, 2023 @4:49 PM