We can’t ignore how slavery has shaped Britain | Letters

Readers respond to Olivette Otele’s article about how the culture war is impeding truthful reflection on the country’s difficult history

Re Olivette Otele’s article (Today we remember the tragedy of slavery, but the culture war that denies Britain’s past continues, 23 August), I am white British, but feel a sense of vicarious insult from “anti-woke” campaigns against the teaching or discussion of our unsavoury history – and the pretence that the British version of empire was somehow more benign than others.

Even the imperialist Winston Churchill in 1914 recognised our darker side when he said: “We have engrossed to ourselves an altogether disproportionate share of the wealth and traffic of the world … mainly acquired by violence, largely maintained by force ... ”

Nothing is gained by purging history, or by appealing to the flag to cover up past evils with false patriotism. When Liz Truss and others talk of British workers “lacking graft”, they are using the same language employed by the gentry at the time of the enclosures, who justified their theft of common land for the new capitalist economy by bemoaning the laziness of the peasants who survived on it.

The new British mercantilist and capitalist economy was driven by slave-trading merchants who amassed incredible wealth, and transformed England and the world through land theft, plantations and horrendous brutality. Black slave labour, white indentured labour, with accompanying vicious laws and punishments, and transportation, are all part of our collective CV, indeed our very landscape. The article is right. We shouldn’t forget.
William Candler
Ipswich, Suffolk

• Olivette Otele is right that the “culture war has become a mechanism of distraction”, but we should be clear what it is a distraction from. British governments have always sought to racialise class-based inequalities, and denied the entrenched nature of institutional racism. The denial of Britain’s involvement in profiteering through enslavement, though, isn’t just a denial of the historical roots of racism, it’s a denial of the extent to which the liberal state is based on violence. The same voices that would deny the history of slavery would also decry any “intelligent and compassionate conversation” about the British state’s violence in Ireland, or about the Peterloo massacre.

Precisely because the capitalist state is rooted in violence and dispossession, it cannot engage with “honest conversations about the past”. To do so would be to repudiate its instituting myths of peaceful democratic development. As the political activist Angela Davis puts it, capitalism can only survive as a society of imposed forgetfulness. There can never be a “collective memory” because we are not all on the same side.
Nick Moss

• As Olivette Otele says, considering the “unprecedented wealth” gained by the country through slavery, the least any decent government would do is “publicly commemorate slavery”, and support the teaching of its history through “curriculum change”. Yet the purpose of teaching history still seems in many cases to be ignoring the facts. Such colonial amnesia denies the existence not only of Britain’s reliance on the empire’s help in time of war, but also of British atrocities and barbarism.

Hopefully Labour will promise changes to the history curriculum and the release of 1.2m history files hidden away in Hanslope Park, Buckinghamshire. Only then can real understanding begin.
Bernie Evans

Have an opinion on anything you’ve read in the Guardian today? Please email us your letter and it will be considered for publication.


The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Britain’s despicable history of slavery needs teaching and commemorating | Letters
Letters: Guardian readers respond to Afua Hirsch’s call for a London memorial to the victims of slavery


24, Oct, 2019 @5:05 PM

Article image
Why Britain needs a slavery memorial | Letter
Letter: It would be a permanent sign of regret and a tangible tribute to those on whom much of our prosperity is based, writes Steve Barrass


06, Dec, 2021 @5:42 PM

Article image
Like it or not, we all bear some responsibility for slavery | Letters
Letters: When it comes to atoning for the slave trade, we need to acknowledge how much we have benefited, says Prof Sir Roderick Floud. Plus letters from Nic Madge, Morris Gyles, Rex Knight and Kit Jackson

20, Mar, 2023 @5:12 PM

Article image
The debt that Britain still owes for slavery | Letters
Letters: Mary Ruck on the forced labour endured by Kenyans during the 1950s state of emergency, Dr Charmian Goldwyn on today’s inequalities, Fawzi Ibrahim on the downside to reparations and James Heartfield on Lord Palmerston’s acknowledgment of Britain’s debt to Africa. Plus letters from Norman Miller and John Pelling


12, Jul, 2020 @4:21 PM

Article image
Crude, racist textbooks have no place in today’s education system | David Lammy
Don’t teach children that Caribbean fathers are ‘largely absent’, teach them about slavery and exploitation, says Labour MP David Lammy

David Lammy

10, Oct, 2018 @10:36 AM

Article image
Don’t knock Nelson for failing to fight slavery – he had a war to look after | Letters
Letters: The descendant of a 19th-century abolitionist points out that even Wilberforce had his flaws. Plus other reactions to Afua Hirsch’s piece on Britain’s view of its imperial history


04, Jun, 2018 @5:02 PM

Article image
Historians working towards a full imperial reckoning for Britain | Letters
Letters: Miles Larmer says that Britain’s universities and schools are at the forefront of uncovering the nation’s imperial past; Mike Pitts writes about Bristol’s positive contribution in documenting the empire; David Bradbury argues that, far from being airbrushed from history, resources for the study of British slavery are widespread; plus letters from Michael Peel and Jen Wilson


22, Nov, 2017 @6:44 PM

Article image
Time for Britain to face its imperial demons | Letters
Letters: John P Cooper on what the country must do to make peace with itself, John Rowe on why the focus on statues is frustrating, Shirley Osborn on one glorious moment that will stay with her and Graham Foster on changing the honours system


12, Jun, 2020 @3:42 PM

Article image
I agree that Britain is a work in progress. But let’s be wary of distorting the past | Letter
Letter: Shyamol Banerji responds to an article by Mihir Bose on the country coming to terms with its colonial past

05, May, 2024 @3:57 PM

Article image
Mayflower 400 is ignoring slavery | Letters
Letters: Mayflower 400 is commemorating the Mayflower voyage of 1620 without reference to the context and aftermath of that colonising venture, writes Angela Sherlock


08, Nov, 2019 @5:59 PM