Bring in measures soon or risk 7,000 daily Covid hospitalisations, Sage warns

Ministers told ‘basket of measures’ such as continued home working can keep cases under control

Between 2,000 and 7,000 people a day could be hospitalised with Covid in England next month unless the government urgently implements a “basket of measures”, government scientific advisers have warned as Boris Johnson made clear he hopes to avoid fresh restrictions.

The prime minister confirmed on Tuesday that Covid passports, the return of mandatory mask-wearing and advice to work from home would be kept in reserve as the government’s “plan B”, to be introduced if the NHS is at risk of being overwhelmed.

But newly published modelling from experts on the Sage advisory committee warn the government not to wait too long, with cases, hospitalisations and deaths all higher than a year ago despite the success of the vaccination programme.

Speaking alongside Johnson at a Downing Street press conference, the government’s chief scientific adviser, Sir Patrick Vallance, also said experience of battling the virus showed “you have to go earlier than you think you want to, you have to go harder than you think you want to”. He said the UK was now at a “pivot point” where, if the situation worsens, it could do so rapidly.

Modellers on the Sage committee expect cases to rise in the coming months after almost all restrictions were lifted this summer, documents show. Daily hospitalisations could plausibly peak at 7,000 in England next month, far surpassing the winter peak, which reached 4,500 UK-wide, according to the updated modelling. Currently about 1,000 people with Covid are being admitted to UK hospital wards each day.

Graph

But if enacted early enough, before a rise in cases becomes sustained, even light-touch measures could be sufficient to keep infections flat and prevent a damaging fresh wave of hospitalisations, the Sage documents say.

“With the current levels of high prevalence combined with unknown behaviours, the burden on health and care settings could rise very quickly,” the scientists warn. They say “it could be a very difficult winter ahead” if acute Covid combines with other pressures such as long Covid, other infections like flu, or co-infection causes more serious illness.

Even though 81% of UK adults are double-jabbed, nearly 6 million are unvaccinated and more likely to be vulnerable to the highly transmissible Delta variant now most Covid restrictions have been lifted.

Sage modellers expect R – the number of people an infected person typically infects – to rise from about 1 in England to between 1.1 and 1.5 with schools reopening and people returning to work. If so, daily hospitalisations could peak at between 2,000 and 7,000 in October they said. More extreme scenarios that project many more cases are highly unlikely, the modellers add, without substantial waning of immunity or a new coronavirus variant emerging.

The recommendations were published as the health secretary, Sajid Javid, set out the government’s autumn and winter plan for tackling the virus.

Graph

He said ministers’ “plan A” included pressing ahead with booster jabs for the over-50s and clinically vulnerable and expanding vaccination to 12- to 15-year-olds, and continuing to advise the public to meet outdoors where possible and wear masks in enclosed spaces.

Javid also announced contingency measures for the autumn and winter including mandatory masks, compulsory vaccine passports for large and crowded venues, and urging the public to work from home.

When Javid was appointed in June, he described the removal of Covid restrictions as “irreversible” but setting out the plans to the House of Commons on Tuesday he declined to rule out another lockdown and conceded: “Any responsible government must prepare for all eventualities.”

Asked at Tuesday’s press conference when tougher restrictions may need to be implemented, the prime minister said: “Just bear in mind what we’re trying to prevent, which is the overwhelming of the NHS, and that will remain our objective.”

The chief medical officer for England, Prof Chris Whitty, stressed the pressures the NHS was already under. “We are entering the winter with this reasonably high level; it wouldn’t take many doubling times to get into trouble; and therefore people still need to take this disease very seriously,” he said.

The government’s autumn and winter plan set out for the first time details of how it would implement vaccine passports – a proposal announced by Johnson in July but that provoked a furious backlash from Tory MPs.

Under the plan, the passports would be applied to all nightclubs; all indoor, crowded settings with 500 or more people such as music venues; all outdoor settings with 4,000 or more people such as festivals; and any venue with 10,000 or more people, such as big sports matches.

At the weekend Javid confirmed plans to introduce Covid passports from October had been ditched but on Tuesday the government acknowledged they might need to be implemented at short notice – and encourages businesses to introduce them voluntarily. The Sage group proposes “a basket of measures” they believe are light enough to keep the epidemic under control if brought in soon enough. They include more mask-wearing, encouraging continued home working, clear messaging about the remaining risk of catching Covid, more widespread testing and a return to requiring all contacts of positive cases to self-isolate.

The scientists are concerned that if ministers wait until cases take off, such light-touch measures will fail and more severe restrictions will be needed to bring the epidemic back under control.

A consensus document from the modellers, written on 8 September, says that rather than the sharp peak anticipated at the end of the summer, hospitalisations could peak next month and remain high into the winter.

The scientists warn that hospital occupancy in England only has to rise two and half times to reach last winter’s peak. In Scotland, it took two weeks for hospital occupancy to double after schools went back.

The scientists add there is a “clear consensus” that high levels of home working played a major role in keeping the epidemic under control in recent months, and warn: “It is highly likely that a significant decrease in home working in the next few months would result in a rapid increase in hospital admissions. If enacted early enough, a relatively light set of measures could be sufficient to curb sustained growth.”

Sage scientists have stressed through the pandemic that the scenarios they model are neither forecasts nor predictions and come with substantial uncertainties, largely because it is difficult to predict how people will behave.

Modelling in September last year was instrumental in Sage calling for an urgent “circuit breaker” to prevent cases from soaring, though other projections have under- or over-estimated how fast the epidemic was growing. In the summer, the experts expected cases to reach 100,000 a day but infections fell sharply in July before picking up again.

• This article was amended on 15 September 2021. A reference in an earlier version to unvaccinated people being “vulnerable … to the Delta variant” was changed to “more likely to be vulnerable … [than vaccinated people]”.

Contributors

Ian Sample and Heather Stewart

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Secrecy has harmed UK government's response to Covid-19 crisis, says top scientist
Exclusive: Sir Paul Nurse says lack of openness fuelled poor decisions and put public trust at risk

Ian Sample Science editor

02, Aug, 2020 @8:11 PM

Article image
UK at 'critical point' over Covid-19, top scientists to tell public
Patrick Vallance and Chris Whitty to make televised appeal ahead of ‘challenging winter’

Heather Stewart and Josh Halliday

20, Sep, 2020 @9:00 PM

Article image
Can the UK avoid 50,000 Covid-19 cases a day?
Continued doubling of infection rate feared by top advisers is unlikely to happen, say some experts

Caelainn Barr, Pamela Duncan and Niamh McIntyre

21, Sep, 2020 @5:18 PM

Article image
Boris Johnson admits regrets over handling of first Covid wave
PM says he wishes ‘many things’ were done differently as country marks one year since first lockdown

Jessica Elgot Deputy political editor

23, Mar, 2021 @7:16 PM

Article image
No 10 facing fresh calls for transparency over Sage pandemic advice
Government publishes names of 50 members of experts’ group but list is incomplete

Ian Sample and Rowena Mason

04, May, 2020 @5:56 PM

Article image
'The seasons are against us': what we learned from UK's top Covid scientists
Patrick Vallance and Chris Whitty’s briefing predicted an autumn of rising deaths and difficult lockdown choices

Peter Walker Political correspondent

21, Sep, 2020 @2:00 PM

Article image
MPs’ fury as 55m people in England face months in top tiers
Not the time ‘to take foot off the beast’ says PM as scientists emphasise enduring risk of Covid

Heather Stewart Political editor

27, Nov, 2020 @12:07 AM

Article image
UK coronavirus peak at least two weeks away, chief scientist says
Patrick Vallance says deaths likely to keep rising for fortnight after ICU situation improves

Matthew Weaver

09, Apr, 2020 @6:17 PM

Article image
Government must be transparent about science advice it receives
Analysis: inquiry into UK’s response to Covid crisis shows Sage guidance should be put in public domain as soon as possible

Nicola Davis Science correspondent

12, Oct, 2021 @6:14 PM

Article image
From super-spreader Boris to Classic Dom's eyesight: daily press conference hits | John Crace
As No 10 announces Covid-19 press conferences are to end, here are some world-beating moments

John Crace

23, Jun, 2020 @5:03 PM