Covid report reveals failure after failure by Tories | Letters

Tony Kemp, David Head, David Plumpton, Robert Walker and Gillian Dalley respond to the Commons report into the government’s handling of the pandemic

In recent months, ministers – when challenged over their handling of the Covid pandemic – have switched the conversation to their success in the vaccination programme and the number of deaths and serious illnesses this has prevented. Now we have a report that sheds light on just how catastrophic the Tory leadership has been during one of the most disastrous episodes in the history of this country (Covid response ‘one of UK’s worst ever public health failures’, 12 October).

The report, led by two former Conservative ministers, one of whom, Jeremy Hunt, was health secretary from 2012 to 2018, was damning of this government in so many respects, but stopped short of pointing the finger of blame at any individuals. Why? Could it be to do with the fact that, after years of NHS cuts under his tenure, Hunt is not prepared to share the blame for the NHS being overwhelmed?

It is often said that the pandemic was an unprecedented situation and nobody could have planned for it. But in 2016, again under Hunt’s watch, the report on Exercise Alice identified specific actions to be taken in preparation, including quarantining/isolating, the need for increased PPE and consistent public messaging (Report, 7 October). Clearly, these were not addressed in the years leading up to the Covid outbreak.

Lessons learned to date? None. The report is nothing more than a typical Tory whitewash aimed at protecting those who are culpable – in particular, Boris Johnson, Matt Hancock and Hunt – and we should not forget what has happened as a result of this government’s sheer incompetence and lack of planning:
• 137,763 deaths due to Covid – a 58% increase since January despite the vaccination rollout.
• The highest number of Covid-related deaths in Europe.
• The eighth highest death rate in the world.
Tony Kemp
Spennymoor, County Durham

• Christina Pagel and Martin McKee remind us that in England there are still more than 500 Covid deaths each week (Why is England doing worse against Covid than its European neighbours?, 7 October). This is a startling figure, as comparison with recent British military involvement in Afghanistan shows. Over the past 20 years, there were 457 deaths of UK armed forces personnel, according to figures available from the House of Commons library, and 405 of these deaths were the result of hostile action.

If more than 500 British military personnel were being killed each week, there would quite rightly be a public outcry. Yet more than 500 Covid-19 deaths per week in England alone pass with minimal media comment and public protest, and they make no perceptible impact on the Conservative MPs who sit without face coverings in the crowded House of Commons, oppose vaccine passports and back a policy of “vaccine just” for England.

England is in a bad place for a number of reasons: food and fuel shortages, rising gas prices, the cut to universal credit and growing inequality. But one of the salient symptoms of a nation that has lost its way is surely the apparent indifference to the weekly death toll from Covid-19.
David Head

• One would think such a damning report might bring a government down, and in more honourable times this would have been the case. Profumo resigned not because he had an affair with Christine Keeler, but because he lied about it in parliament and had therefore misled the Commons, where convention insisted that he fall on his sword.

In this government, there have been many instances of worse behaviour. Indeed, the prime minister himself has stood at the dispatch box and habitually misled the Commons and the British people. He is a real and present threat to our fragile democracy. More surprising than the report, however, is his continued popularity. He and his cabinet need to go.
David Plumpton
Warrington, Cheshire

• Dame Sally Davies says that British exceptionalism contributed to the deaths of thousands. Is “exceptionalism” code for systemic racism, attachment to cultural purity, ideological prejudice, or some combination of the three? The success of countries in east Asia in controlling Covid through masks, social distancing and lockdowns was evident weeks before Britain followed suit.
Robert Walker
Beijing Normal University

It seems that the explanation of “it was the wrong sort of pandemic” is going to be used as the excuse for the poor performance of this country’s response at the start of the Covid pandemic (‘Extraordinary omission’: key findings in scathing UK Covid report, 12 October). However, much of the preparation required – personal protective equipment, emergency Nightingale hospital and overflow care home beds and testing capability – was not specific to the particular type of infection that faced us (be it flu or the unknown coronavirus). It would have been essential in any type of pandemic. Instead, it was found that stores of PPE had been left unmonitored and were unusable at the point of need. Care homes were brought into the collective response without the appropriate infection control capacity or PPE, completely cut off from the main NHS supply chains, and not part of any integrated testing regime. They were simply not part of any national planning infrastructure. This was well known.

The Cygnus report, relating to a trial pandemic exercise in 2016 (when Jeremy Hunt was secretary of state for health) notes that “it was not possible to collate an accurate picture of social care capacity because much of that capacity lies with private providers”. Politicians had simply ignored social care’s relevance. This is not a mere observation – it underlines the immediate need for a truly national social care service to be established in the public sector that which is fully integrated, as part of national resilience capacity, in the planning, provision and delivery of emergency care.
Gillian Dalley


The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Care home crisis is the result of years of neglect | Letters
Letters: Bill Shaw says the Thatcher government systematically dismantled social care provision, while Les Bright highlights what went wrong with private services. Plus letters from Tom Wilson and Janet Broadmore


03, Jun, 2020 @5:38 PM

Article image
Why Britain needs a national care service | Letters
Letters: Alan Walker on the history of care home ownership, Gillian Dalley on the prospect of a cross-party agreement, Jennifer Knowles on discrimination against those with dementia, and Dr Simon Gibbs and Ann Jolly on Boris Johnson’s claim that ‘too many care homes didn’t really follow the procedures’


07, Jul, 2020 @4:22 PM

Article image
There is no magic fix for our social care crisis | Letters
Letters: Readers react to government proposals for the NHS to take over the management of social care


30, Jul, 2020 @4:49 PM

Article image
Boris Johnson is trying to mug us off | Letters
Letters: Readers are unimpressed by the prime minister’s comeback speech in which he likened Covid-19 to a mugger


28, Apr, 2020 @5:34 PM

Article image
The haves and have-nots in vaccination rollout | Letters
Letters: Karen McCarthy on the different vaccination priorities in largely white, affluent suburban areas and more diverse inner-city ones, and Jane Coward on jumping the queue. Plus letters from Charles Barker and Dr Ray Jones


08, Feb, 2021 @5:12 PM

Article image
Counting the cost of the UK’s Covid failures | Letters
Letters: Jeremy Cushing on the tragic consequences of the pandemic response, Prof W Richard Bowen on the need for more scientifically educated politicians, Joseph Palley on England’s excess deaths, and Betty Cairns on how the dead are being remembered in Italy


04, Aug, 2020 @4:45 PM

Article image
The UK's catastrophic failure to heed the coronavirus warnings | Letters
Letters: Readers respond to an article by Nesrine Malik that said many coronavirus deaths could have been prevented had the government acted faster


14, Apr, 2020 @5:16 PM

Article image
The shameful failures that threw care home residents to Covid | Letters
Letters: Readers on the government’s mistakes and neglect that meant elderly patients were discharged to care homes, without a Covid test, at the height of the pandemic


30, May, 2021 @3:51 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on the Covid report: a reckoning begins | Editorial
Editorial: Multiple failings are revealed in a critique of pandemic policy by MPs. It marks the start of a long, hard process


12, Oct, 2021 @5:58 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on lionising Covid-19 workers: Johnson’s donkeys still fail them | Editorial
Editorial: Frontline staff deserve more than praise from the government. They need it to do its job


27, Aug, 2020 @6:11 PM