Rotting Red Sea oil tanker could leave 8m people without water

FSO Safer has been abandoned since 2017 and loss of its 1.1m barrels would destroy Yemen’s fishing stocks

The impact of an oil spill in the Red Sea from a tanker that is rotting in the water could be far wider than anticipated, with 8 million people losing access to running water and Yemen’s Red Sea fishing stock destroyed within three weeks.

Negotiations are under way to offload the estimated 1.1m barrels of crude oil that remains onboard the FSO Safer, which has been deteriorating by the month since it was abandoned in 2017. The vessel contains four times the amount of oil released by the Exxon Valdez in the Gulf of Alaska in 1989, and a spill is considered increasingly probable.

The oil will spread well beyond Yemen and cause environmental havoc affecting Saudi Arabia, Eritrea and Djibouti, according to the latest modelling, which is unlike previous studies because it examines the impact more than a week after the spill.

Three-way talks between the Houthi rebels, the UN-recognised government of Yemen and the UN have foundered, despite repeated warnings, including at the UN security council, of the impact if the tanker explodes, breaks up or starts leaking. UN officials have been unable to secure guarantees to maintain the vessel, including its rotting hull, which is now overseen by a crew of just seven.

The modelling is published in the journal Nature Sustainability on Monday and showed the spill was likely to lead to the closure of the Red Sea ports of Hodeidah and Salif within two weeks, threatening delivery of 200,000 tonnes of fuel for Yemen, the equivalent to 38% of the national fuel requirement. Fuel prices are likely to rise by as much as 80%, and the absence of fuel for water pumps will result in 8 million Yemenis being deprived of running water. As many as 2 million will lose access to water if desalination plants in the region become polluted.


Although half of the oil is anticipated to evaporate on the sea within 24 hours, the rest will within six to 10 days reach Yemen’s western coastline, and ports further south in three weeks.

The numbers in need of food assistance vary from 5.7 million to 8.4 million people, depending on whether the spill reaches ports in the south, such as Aden. The estimates depend on the season when the the spill occurs and the extent of the oil loss.

The spill will threaten 66.5%-85.2% of Yemen’s Red Sea fisheries within one week, and 93.5%-100% of those fisheries within three weeks, depending on the season.

The effects of air pollution from a spill, including increased risk of cardiovascular and respiratory hospitalisations, range across 11.3m person-days for a slow-release winter spill to 19.5m person-days for a fast-release summer spill.

Red Sea coral reefs, which have been studied for their unique resilience to seawater warming, would also be threatened.

The report in Nature Sustainability warns: “The spill could hinder global trade through the vital Bab el-Mandeb strait, 29 km wide at its narrowest point, through which 10% of the global shipping trade passes. Exclusion zones created for clean-up could reroute traffic, and shipments will be delayed as ships potentially exposed to oil will require cleaning”

It adds: “The possibility of a spill is increasingly likely. The visibly dilapidated Safer is single-hulled, meaning a breach will cause the onboard oil to spill directly into the sea. Water entered the engine room in May 2020 through a seawater-pipe leak, and the vessel’s fire extinguishing system is non-operational. A spill could occur due to a leak or combustion.

“A leak could arise through continued deterioration of the vessel’s hull or by breach of the hull due to inclement weather; combustion could occur through build-up of volatile gases aboard the vessel or direct attack on the vessel.”

The UN has been seeking Houthi permission to inspect the ship, but the Houthis want undertakings that the vessl will also be repaired, an exercise that requires money the UN does not have available.


Patrick Wintour Diplomatic editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The town that reveals how Russia spills two Deepwater Horizons of oil each year
Oil spills in the Komi Republic caused by old pipelines are relatively small and rarely garner widespread attention - but added up they threaten fish stocks and pasture for cattle

Alec Luhn in Usinsk

05, Aug, 2016 @5:00 AM

Article image
BP oil spill in Great Australian Bight would be catastrophic, modelling shows
Wilderness Society report shows spill would likely affect fishing and tourism, and threaten whales, seabirds, sea lions and sea turtles, along the southern coast

Oliver Milman

08, Oct, 2015 @8:02 PM

Article image
Leaked BP report reveals serious near-miss accidents
Costly failures show ‘urgent attention’ needed to improve how oil giant manages crucial engineering data at plants

Damian Carrington

13, Dec, 2016 @12:48 PM

Article image
BP spill: White House says oil has gone, but Gulf's fishermen are not so sure

Counsellors and lawyers are busier than seafarers in Louisiana, as some experts warn that fishing industry will never recover

Suzanne Goldenberg

06, Sep, 2010 @6:33 PM

Article image
Deepwater Horizon oil spill: turtle deaths soar amid fight to save wildlife

Tests take place to determine cause of deaths, as locals hope booms along coastline will protect commercial fisheries

Ed Pilkington in Pass Christian

03, May, 2010 @7:23 PM

Article image
Offshore oil industry needs sweeping overhaul – White House commission

Oil spill commission to criticise Obama administration for failing to go far enough to reform industry after BP disaster

Suzanne Goldenberg, US environment correspondent

11, Jan, 2011 @1:55 AM

Article image
Lord Browne, the Sun King of oil, returns to Gulf of Mexico

Lord Browne's Riverstone buys 2m acres of oil and gas fields worth $3.75bn from Apache Corporation in Houston, Texas

Terry Macalister

19, Jul, 2013 @6:37 PM

Article image
Arctic oil rush will ruin ecosystem, warns Lloyd's of London

Insurance market joins environmentalists in highlighting risks of drilling in fragile region as $100bn investment is predicted

Julia Kollewe and Terry Macalister

11, Apr, 2012 @11:03 PM

Article image
BP gets go-ahead to expand North Sea drilling
Cameron backs £4bn plan for 'new Atlantic frontier' but Greenpeace warns of oil spills and rising emissions

Richard Wachman

13, Oct, 2011 @6:41 PM

Article image
Niger delta oil spills clean-up will take 30 years, says UN

A succession of oil spills by Shell and other companies over half a century will cost $1bn to clean up, according to a major report

John Vidal, environment editor

04, Aug, 2011 @6:54 PM