Boris Johnson admits regrets over handling of first Covid wave

PM says he wishes ‘many things’ were done differently as country marks one year since first lockdown

Boris Johnson has admitted there are many things he wishes he had done differently to tackle the Covid-19 pandemic as the UK marks a year since the first lockdown and remembers the 126,000 people who have died so far.

At a Downing Street press conference, England’s chief medical officer, Prof Chris Whitty, also conceded the country had endured “a bad outcome”, but the prime minister once again refused to commit to a public inquiry to look at the decisions taken by the government over the last year.

Rebuffing calls for an inquiry, he said lessons would be learned at the right time. He did announce there would be “a fitting and a permanent memorial to the loved ones we have lost and to commemorate this whole period”.

The prime minister later prompted an outcry from opposition MPs after telling a meeting of his own backbenchers, in remarks he quickly retracted, that the UK’s “vaccine success” was “because of greed my friends”.

During the No 10 briefing both Johnson and Whitty repeated stark warnings about the risk of a third wave of infections in the UK after steep rises in European countries.

Whitty said there would “definitely be another surge” of Covid cases despite the vaccine programme, saying there would be “bumps and twists on the road” ahead, a hint at the struggles the UK has faced over new variants and the looming threat of export bans on vaccine supplies.

Johnson said he believed one key error was a failure to appreciate how the disease could spread asymptomatically, while his chief scientific adviser, Sir Patrick Vallance, said lack of testing capacity and data meant the government lost control of tracking the virus’s spread.

“I think in retrospect, there are probably many things that we wish that we’d known and many things that we wish we’d done differently at the time, because we were fighting a novel disease under very different circumstances than any previous government had ever imagined,” Johnson said.

“Perhaps the single biggest false assumption that we made was about the potential for asymptomatic transmission, and that did govern a lot of policy in the early days. All that misunderstanding about the reality of asymptomatic transmission certainly led to real problems that [meant] we then really had to work very hard to make up ground.”

Though evidence of asymptomatic transmission only became widespread public knowledge in March 2020, preliminary evidence was already being presented to the government from late January.

In the minutes of the government’s Scientific advisory group for Emergencies (Sage) from 28 January, it says: “There is limited evidence of asymptomatic transmission, but early indications imply some is occurring.” It says Public Health England was investigating the prevalence of such transmission. A fortnight later, it says better testing of travellers would be needed to understand asymptomatic cases.

Johnson refused to say he regretted the decision not to lock down the country earlier, both at the start of the first wave and the second, the latter of which he is said to have personally strongly opposed.

“All I can say is we took all the decisions with the interests of the British people foremost in our hearts and in an effort to protect the public and to prevent death and suffering,” he said. “That was what we were trying to do at all stages.”

But he again refused to put a date on a time for an inquiry, saying only that “doubtless there will be a moment to properly review, to learn lessons and make sure we learn them for future pandemics”.

Labour said many of the errors had been made by Johnson and urged him again to order an inquiry. “The tragic reality is we’ve seen a litany of errors from Boris Johnson,” said the shadow health secretary, Jon Ashworth.

“Public health should have been central to our response from the start, the failure to sufficiently financially support people to isolate has been a monstrous failure, the lack of protection for care homes was negligent, contact tracing should have been community led. And years of underfunding and cutbacks left our NHS vulnerable and exposed when the virus hit. Given future pandemic risk lessons must be learned – meaning a public inquiry is vital.”

Vallance said having adequate testing in place at the beginning of the pandemic would have made a significant difference.

“The one thing that I think would have been really important earlier on is to have much better data on what was happening. And that would have required testing to be up and ready immediately and it would have required the ability to get that information into a source and to be able to see it,” he said.

“We simply didn’t have that at the beginning and it was very difficult to know the speed at which things were moving and therefore make decisions based on the real-time data, which we can do now, and that would’ve made a big difference.”

Whitty said the UK had had “a bad outcome” but said similar results had been seen across many other countries. “What we want to try and do is to minimise mortality and learn lessons from the past,” he said.

He said there had been “much less of an understanding about how widespread the virus was in Europe for exactly the same reason … because of the lack of testing in Europe as well as in the UK”.

Whitty said the UK now knew that the virus had been imported from Spain, France and parts of Italy that were not seen as being particularly high risk. “At the time we didn’t have that information and that would have almost certainly have led to slightly different approaches to how we did things,” he said.

He also repeated his warnings that the world was unlikely to eradicate Covid-19 even with mass vaccination. “We’ve only achieved eradication of one disease, which is smallpox, with a phenomenally effective vaccine over a very long period of time, literally hundreds of years,” he said.

Prof Neil Ferguson, the Imperial College London epidemiologist who gave crucial advice to the government ahead of the first lockdown, said on Tuesday that an inquiry should start in the next few months.

“Frankly we need an inquiry to properly go through both the advice at the time but also what was going on with the government at the time to address the issue of why didn’t we lock down a week earlier or two weeks earlier,” he said. “With an inquiry that lasts three years, the risk is that in three years time people’s concerns will have moved on and it’s less likely to affect real change.”

Contributor

Jessica Elgot Deputy political editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Boris Johnson says government did everything it could to limit Covid deaths
PM says it is ‘hard to compute the sorrow’ after number of deaths passes 100,000

Niamh McIntyre, Peter Walker, Pamela Duncan and Robert Booth

26, Jan, 2021 @6:09 PM

Article image
Top experts not asked to approve 'stay alert' coronavirus message
Chris Whitty and Patrick Vallance had no role in signing off advice, Guardian has learned

Denis Campbell Matthew Weaver and Ian Sample

11, May, 2020 @2:06 PM

Article image
Strict Covid restrictions could last months, Boris Johnson signals
PM says lifting lockdown is subject to ‘lots of caveats’ as figures show 1m people in England have Covid

Jessica Elgot and Peter Walker

05, Jan, 2021 @8:16 PM

Article image
Be prepared for winter Covid wave, Boris Johnson to warn
Jabs for teenagers, booster scheme, flu shots and vaccine passports expected to be part of PM’s winter plan for England

Heather Stewart, Rowena Mason, Peter Walker and Aubrey Allegretti

10, Sep, 2021 @2:12 PM

Article image
Boris Johnson to hold daily coronavirus press briefings
Decision follows criticism of government’s muddled strategy towards Covid-19

Andrew Sparrow Political correspondent

15, Mar, 2020 @10:30 PM

Article image
Failure to protect: who is to blame for Britain's coronavirus crisis?
A number of prominent people are being criticised for their shortcomings over Covid-19

Kate Proctor and Rajeev Syal

21, Apr, 2020 @7:30 PM

Article image
Covid: Boris Johnson unveils lockdown exit plan: schools and social contact first
PM to unveil proposals for England on Monday, with shops and restaurants facing longer wait

Jessica Elgot and Archie Bland

22, Feb, 2021 @3:03 PM

Article image
From super-spreader Boris to Classic Dom's eyesight: daily press conference hits | John Crace
As No 10 announces Covid-19 press conferences are to end, here are some world-beating moments

John Crace

23, Jun, 2020 @5:03 PM

Article image
Boris Johnson says more deaths inevitable whenever lockdown lifts as he sets out roadmap for England – as it happened
PM says ‘realistic’ to accept lifting restrictions will lead to more infections and more deaths as he outlines four-step plan

Andrew Sparrow

22, Feb, 2021 @8:44 PM

Article image
Boris Johnson brushes off Tory revolt over Dominic Cummings
PM also refuses to allow top scientific advisers to talk about chief aide at daily No 10 briefing

Rowena Mason and Vikram Dodd

28, May, 2020 @8:19 PM