MEPs back action against European Commission over Poland and Hungary

European parliament now expected to prepare case over failure to trigger sanctions against Poland and Hungary

MEPs have backed legal proceedings by the European parliament against the European Commission over a failure to trigger financial sanctions against Poland and Hungary for undermining the rule of law.

The parliament’s legal service is now expected to prepare a case to be lodged at the European court of justice later this year, pitting two EU institutions against each other in the EU’s highest court, with only the formality of approval by key committees of the chamber now required.

The resolution proposed by the Greens group passed with 506 MEPs voting in favour, 150 against and 28 abstentions on Thursday.

MEPs agreed in their resolution that the EU’s new rule of law mechanism, which links funding from the bloc’s budget to the protection of fundamental democratic norms, should already have been triggered against Poland and Hungary.

In February the commission launched legal action over Hungary’s failure to implement a judgment from the ECJ that legislation on restricting foreign-funding of NGOs was against EU rules.

Last month an ECJ advocate general advised judges that a reform to Poland’s legal system had dispensed with “the minimum guarantees necessary to ensure the indispensable separation of powers between the executive and the judiciary”.

MEPs have said the mechanism under which budget payments can be deducted, which came into force on 1 January after a tortuous internal negotiation, had to be seen to be effective.

The commission has said that it cannot be triggered, however, until detailed guidelines are published. Leaders of the main political groups in the parliament have claimed this is merely an excuse for inaction.

Last year the governments in Budapest and Warsaw threatened to veto the bloc’s €1.8tn (£1.6tn) budget and coronavirus recovery plan over attempts to link funding to respect for democratic norms.

Without agreement among the 27 member states, projects financed by the bloc’s seven-year budget would have gone without funds and the €750bn plan to rebuild Europe’s shattered economy would not have been activated.

MEPs fear that the two countries were only won round to backing the budget by behind-the-scenes promises that there would not be an early issuing of financial sanctions.

As a result of the inaction by the commission, MEPs voted in March to give the commission a deadline of 1 June to adopt the guidelines they claimed were necessary. But the EU’s executive branch is yet to do so. The resolution passed on Thursday highlights a “failure to act” by the commission under article 265 of EU’s treaties.

Terry Reintke, a Green MEP, said: “The EU needs a strong basis we can all stand on, which is spelled out in the treaties: democracy, rule of law and fundamental rights. But this is under attack and being dismantled as we speak.

“Instead of defending European values, the commission is watching, writing reports and sitting on its hands. The rule of law needs action now. Unfortunately, it’s clear from yesterday’s debate in parliament that the commission doesn’t seem to feel the same sense of urgency to act.”


Daniel Boffey in Brussels

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
ECJ adviser backs rule-of-law measure in blow to Poland and Hungary
Court advised to dismiss challenge against law that lets EU block funds to states that curb judicial independence

Jennifer Rankin in Brussels

02, Dec, 2021 @12:30 PM

Article image
EU launches legal action over LGBTQ+ rights in Hungary and Poland
Move is part of ongoing fight for rule of law and freedom from discrimination in heart of Europe

Jennifer Rankin in Brussels and Shaun Walker in Budapest

15, Jul, 2021 @12:52 PM

Article image
ECJ dismisses Hungary and Poland’s complaints over rule-of-law measure
Bloc’s highest court rejects countries’ cases objecting to law tying EU funds to democratic standards

Jennifer Rankin in Brussels

16, Feb, 2022 @2:55 PM

Article image
Eastern European leaders defy EU effort to set refugee quotas
Czech Republic, Poland, Slovakia, Hungary and Latvia reject efforts by Brussels to form common policy on just 66,000 migrants, calling it illegal

Ian Traynor in Brussels

21, Sep, 2015 @5:50 PM

Article image
Slovakia joins Poland and Hungary in halting Ukraine grain imports
EU and Kyiv condemn unilateral bans that aim to protect local farmers amid glut and price crash

Jon Henley, Europe correspondent

17, Apr, 2023 @11:22 AM

Article image
Hungary PM Viktor Orban faces EU backlash over new policies
Rightwing leader's proposals for central bank, judiciary and data protection are undemocratic, say critics

Ian Traynor, Europe editor

18, Jan, 2012 @6:03 PM

Article image
Brussels vows swift response to Poland’s ruling against EU law
Ursula von der Leyen says European Commission will decide on next steps to take

Jennifer Rankin in Brussels

08, Oct, 2021 @2:52 PM

Article image
EU leaders clash with Hungary over proposed laws on migration
Viktor Orbán used provocative language at summit, saying EU had gone ahead without his or Poland’s support

Lisa O'Carroll in Granada

06, Oct, 2023 @5:16 PM

Article image
Orbán allies could use EU as cash register, MEPs say
Hungarian PM’s supporters are winning EU-funded contracts while facing little competition

Jennifer Rankin in Brussels

12, Feb, 2018 @5:00 AM

Article image
Poland fined €1m a day over controversial judicial system changes
Warsaw calls European court of justice move blackmail and says penalties ‘not the right road’

Daniel Boffey in Brussels

27, Oct, 2021 @3:38 PM