Data on Delta variant splits scientists on lifting final Covid restrictions

Sage group advises against easing social distancing on 21 June, but others say it is too early to assess risks

Health experts remain divided over the dangers posed by the new Delta variant of Covid-19 and the risks it poses to the nation as ministers consider whether or not to lift lockdown later this month.

Some argue that the new variant, first identified in India, is a significantly increased threat to the UK and have urged that delays be imposed on the total removal of social restrictions, due on 21 June.

“By the government’s own criteria, it would be foolish now to proceed on the data that we’ve got. The risk would be very great indeed,’ said Professor Stephen Reicher, a member of the Scientific Pandemic Insights Group on Behaviours (SPI-B) which advises the government. Reicher said the current assessment of the risks not being fundamentally changed by the appearance of the Delta variant was “not upheld”.

This view was backed by scientists of the Independent Sage group, who argued that data indicated the Delta variant had higher infectivity and was more likely to cause disease and hospitalisations. “That makes it very difficult to justify progressing with the last stage of lockdown,” the group said last week.

Other scientists believe such calls are premature. While urging caution, they say fears that the Delta variant poses a significant new threat – both in terms of infectivity and as a cause of serious illness – are premature. “The suggestion that the India variant is more pathogenic needs to be taken with a big dose of salt,” said Ian Jones, professor of virology, Reading University.

This view was supported by Paul Hunter, professor in medicine at the University of East Anglia. “We need to be a little cautious in assuming that the Delta variant is intrinsically more virulent than the Alpha variant [first identified in Kent],” he said.

Virologist Julian Tang, of Leicester University, added: “There was an initial belief that the Alpha was more transmissible, which turned out to be true, and more clinically severe, which turned out to be false.”

The head of NHS Providers, Chris Hopson, said last week the number in hospital with the Delta variant was rising but not “very significantly”. Many of those in hospital in Bolton - the area worst hit by the variant - were younger, with “very few” fully vaccinated patients. This appeared to show vaccines had “broken the chain” between infection and serious illness, he added.

A key issue is whether the new variant is more infectious and more likely to trigger serious illness. Tang said that from an evolutionary viewpoint, if a virus is more transmissible, it tends to be less severe. “Those infected still have to be well and mobile enough to spread the infection to others,” he added.

SARS-CoV-2, which causes COVID-19
Scientists believe if a virus is more transmissible, it tends to be less severe. Photograph: National Institutes of Health/AFP via Getty Images

Researchers argue that over time, viruses tend to trigger less severe symptoms in those they infect. “From a virus’s point of view, there is an advantage in being more transmissible, you reach more people, but there is no advantage in making people sicker.”

But Professor Rowland Kao of Edinburgh University, sounded a note of caution. “Yes, the long-term trajectory of a virus is that it tends to become less pathogenic over time but we are only in the early stages of Covid-19,” he told the Observer . “This virus spread virtually instantaneously round the world in early 2020. Then lockdowns were imposed. So we have essentially set up hundreds of individual laboratory experiments all around the world, a mix that is conducive to producing variants – and some could be more pathogenic than others. However, in the longer term, in a couple of years I expect the virus to become less dangerous.”

Scientists say it should become apparent very soon if the Delta variant is more pathogenic than its predecessors. Hospitalisations are likely to increase although that might just reflect rising case numbers.

“However, if increased numbers of people have to go to hospital because of the seriousness of their condition, and we discover it is not just because there are more infected people but because it is being caused by the Delta variant triggering more hospitalisations per infection, then it would be a very bold move to release all restrictions at that point,” added Kao.

Last week, a government spokesperson said “no decision” had been made on whether to ease all coronavirus restrictions on 21 June, amid reports Boris Johnson could delay the move by at least a fortnight.

Contributor

Robin McKie

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Pfizer and AstraZeneca ‘highly effective’ against India Covid variant
A Public Health England study has revealed the vaccines can be up to 88% effective after a second dose

Robin McKie

22, May, 2021 @6:28 PM

Article image
Scientists say clinical trials for ‘variant-proof’ vaccines could start very soon
From immunity to blocking transmission of the virus, labs across the UK are hunting for second-generation jabs

Robin McKie

21, Feb, 2021 @10:45 AM

Article image
Will Omicron kill Christmas? How science stacks up in boosters v Covid variant battle
Analysis: UK faces grim winter if vaccines offer poor overall protection, but if the virus has weak powers to evade immunity, hospital cases can be contained

Robin McKie Science editor

12, Dec, 2021 @7:15 AM

Article image
Will vaccines protect us against the Delta variant?
The virus’s behaviour will be a key factor in how it affects the UK and the wider world, with further mutations almost certain

27, Jun, 2021 @7:45 AM

Article image
UK can expect thousands of Covid deaths every year, warn scientists
Disease will circulate alongside flu and other seasonal viruses and become part of accepted winter illness

Robin McKie Observer science editor

31, Jul, 2021 @5:31 PM

Article image
UK scientists want to infect volunteers with Covid-19 in race to find vaccine
Trials could be speeded up by using risky strategy of deliberately introducing the virus

Robin McKie

24, May, 2020 @7:27 AM

Article image
Covid vaccine does not affect fertility but misinformation persists
Scientists emphasise safety but younger women still hesitant

Harriet Sherwood

28, Feb, 2021 @7:15 AM

Article image
UK might not be over the worst, scientists warn, as Covid case numbers stay high
Inoculation programme must be stepped up before the onset of winter

Robin McKie

03, Oct, 2021 @6:45 AM

Article image
Scientists urge caution over proposals to impose vaccine passports in UK
Experts’ warning as Covid crackdowns across Europe result in widespread protests

Robin McKie

21, Nov, 2021 @8:30 AM

Article image
How worried should we be about the Indian variant of Covid-19?
With the end of lockdown in sight, cases are on the rise again. What are the likely consequences in the coming weeks?

Robin McKie

16, May, 2021 @8:30 AM