Hong Kong finds new ways to remember Tiananmen Square amid vigil ban

Residents light candles, lay flowers and paint messages as police enforce ban on annual vigil for massacre

A man walked down a Hong Kong street on Friday wearing a shirt hand-painted with “There is nothing to say”. The previous night an artist held a placard aloft reading: “Don’t go to Victoria Park and light candles”.

On any other day these sights would have been confusing, but on Friday they were a small symbol of resistance to authorities’ efforts to stop anyone from commemorating the 4 June 1989 massacre of student protesters in Beijing.

streets of HK rn: “there is nothing 2 say” pic.twitter.com/dbxjQSWwIG

— csz (@cszabla) June 4, 2021

Hong Kong has long been the traditional home of public remembrance of the Tiananmen Square massacre, with an annual vigil in Victoria Park, attended by tens, sometimes hundreds of thousands of people.

But amid a deepening crackdown on resistance, opposition and freedom of assembly, the city’s police banned the 2021 event. After initially citing pandemic-related restrictions, they soon made it clear they were also treating the vigil as an unauthorised political act, invoking the national security law in warning people to stay away.

Determined to mark the event regardless, Hongkongers have had to become creative. One campaign has called for people to write the numbers 4 and 6 (representing the day and month of the massacre) on their light switches at home. On Wednesday evening, artists laid flowers on the street, or painted banners, while young people sat in Victoria Park and studied.

Artists gathered in Hong Kong the night before the 32nd anniversary of the Tiananmen Massacre and commemorated the victims with different street performances. Photos: @StandNewsHK pic.twitter.com/CeTAJTyKyn

— Hong Kong Free Press HKFP (@hkfp) June 4, 2021

Others laid flowers and candles at the Goddess of Democracy statue in the Chinese University of Hong Kong campus. In 2010 the statue was at the centre of controversy after the university refused an application to have it permanently stationed on site, sparking protests.

The night the goddess was taken onto campus and the controversy that ensued seems like it happened in a different world.
CUHK today, June 4th. pic.twitter.com/v2hhKbSw8v

— Yuen Chan (@xinwenxiaojie) June 4, 2021

In a Facebook message posted from prison, the activist and longtime vigil organiser Lee Cheuk-yan said that at 8pm he would be using cigarettes to replace candles to mourn for the soul of the 4 June movement.

The UK consulate in Hong Kong tweeted a captionless photo of a burning candle.

A police senior superintendent, Liauw Ka-kei, was asked by media if wearing black clothes or lighting candles near the park was illegal. He said it wasn’t easy to answer, but that people knew “full well” if they were joining an unauthorised assembly.

Thousands of officers patrolled the city, shutting down Victoria Park and local sporting fields, and arrested a vigil organiser in the early hours. Apple Daily reported armoured cars and a water cannon heading towards the area. Near Victoria Park a local reporter filmed police delivering a caution to a man who held a sign reading “conscience”.

Police surround an old man with a placard reading "conscience" outside Victoria Park, which was the venue of Hong Kong's June 4 vigil in previous years. The man was given a verbal warning, and officers followed him as he left. #Tiananmen32 pic.twitter.com/gltvkRZDjf

— Holmes Chan (@holmeschan_) June 4, 2021

In the afternoon police set up roadblocks at multiple cross-harbour tunnels, banking up traffic, as they stopped and searched vehicles heading to the main island. At least one woman was stopped and searched because police reportedly found her flowers suspicious. Some people walked through shopping districts carrying candles or leaving tea lights on posts and fences.

Light a candle outside the gate pic.twitter.com/fVchP8Ip1d

— Galileo Cheng (@galileocheng) June 4, 2021

As night fell crowds of people gathered at the edge of the closed park, lighting the torches on their phones.

Hong Kong time 20:00, traditionally the time when the #June4 candlelight vigil started at Victoria Park: At least dozens switching on the light of their mobile phones at the gate of the now-sealed off venue. The light hasn't been extinguished.#HongKong #TiananmenVigil pic.twitter.com/a5yovkl0lN

— Phoebe Kong (@phoebe_kongwy) June 4, 2021

Some activities appeared to go ahead without interference, including the laying of flowers and ceremonial washing of the Pillar of Shame monument inside Hong Kong university.

In Causeway Bay activists set up street booths, protesting against the detention of “political prisoners” and asking: “Is speaking our mind a crime?”


Helen Davidson

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Hong Kong police investigate organisers of Tiananmen Square vigil
Longstanding group accused of being ‘agent of foreign forces’ and is asked for information about its membership

Helen Davidson in Taipei

26, Aug, 2021 @7:48 AM

Article image
Hong Kong police ban Tiananmen memorial vigil, citing Covid-19
Announcement means event will not be held for first time since massacre in 1989

Helen Davidson

01, Jun, 2020 @1:27 PM

Article image
Tiananmen Square massacre marked with Hong Kong vigil
More than 100,000 gather for anniversary but many fear for future of commemoration

Helen Davidson in Hong Kong

04, Jun, 2019 @2:56 PM

Article image
Hong Kong blocks Tiananmen Square vigil with gathering ban
Restrictions were due to end but Hong Kong extends social distancing measures for 14 days

Helen Davidson

19, May, 2020 @8:53 AM

Article image
Hong Kong protesters hold banned Tiananmen vigil as anthem law is passed
Protesters defy police ban as legislation prohibits mockery of Chinese anthem

Verna Yu in Hong Kong

04, Jun, 2020 @5:31 PM

Article image
Hong Kong police raid Tiananmen massacre museum
Crackdown follows arrest of four members of civil society group that ran June 4th Museum

Helen Davidson in Taipei

09, Sep, 2021 @7:29 AM

Article image
Tiananmen anniversary: the marked contrast of Hong Kong and Beijing
Tens of thousands unhindered at candlelit vigil as security, house arrests and censorship stepped up in crackdown on mainland

Tania Branigan in Beijing

04, Jun, 2014 @6:27 PM

Tiananmen Square memorial museum to open in Hong Kong – video

The first permanent museum dedicated to the 1989 Tiananmen Square massacre is planned to open on 4 June

18, Apr, 2014 @8:58 AM

Article image
Hong Kong vigil leader arrested as 7,000 police enforce ban on Tiananmen anniversary protests
Officers have been mobilised to break up the once-traditional events to mark the brutal crackdown against dissent in China 32 years ago

Helen Davidson in Taipei and Vincent Ni

04, Jun, 2021 @10:45 AM

Article image
Hong Kong protesters march over abducted booksellers
Thousands demand resignation of CY Leung who critics accuse of failing to confront China over bookseller scandal

Tom Phillips in Beijing

01, Jul, 2016 @7:50 AM