Reasons to be fearful of China’s data-gathering | Letters

We should be suspicious of the role of the Chinese Communist party in the harvesting of genetic data from unborn babies, argues William Matthews

In her column (What does the Chinese military want with your unborn baby’s genetic data?, 10 July), Arwa Mahdawi suggested that the alleged involvement of the People’s Liberation Army (which is directly answerable to the Chinese Communist party) with BGI’s data-gathering (likewise answerable as a China-based company) is essentially equivalent to data-gathering by western companies. To suggest that the former case is worse, she argued, “smacks of Sinophobia”.

As a scholar of China, I cannot agree. While the harvesting of genetic data by any company is frightening and fraught with ethical issues, it should be obvious that this is a false equivalence. It is undoubtedly worse if genetic data is gathered by a company which must also comply with the rule of the Chinese Communist party (CCP) and its military-industrial complex, a regime which harvests and aggregates data on its citizens on a massive scale and uses it directly to implement the most repressive system of social control on earth in Xinjiang.

It is much worse if genetic data is harvested by a party-state which presides over the racist AI-driven surveillance of Uyghurs, even as it incarcerates them and appears to be forcibly sterilising Uyghur women. This alongside the existing policies of promoting “population quality” which, among other things, have forcibly and often brutally repressed women’s reproductive freedom for decades and feed directly into the marginalisation of disadvantaged social groups. Unfortunately, the false equivalence drawn with the actions of an increasingly totalitarian, ethno-nationalist and patriarchal party-state under Xi Jinping are symptomatic of a broader lack of attention paid by left-of-centre media to CCP human rights abuses.

It is not Sinophobic to call out Xi Jinping’s regime as especially odious – rather, to do so is to show solidarity with its victims among China’s citizens (including those incarcerated in re-education camps), the people of Hong Kong, and the people of Taiwan. A progressive media concerned with combatting racism, colonialism and the institutionalised repression of women ought to reserve particular criticism for the party-state responsible for some of their most egregious current manifestations.
William Matthews

Have an opinion on anything you’ve read in the Guardian today? Please email us your letter and it will be considered for publication.


The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
China’s authoritarian streak | Letters
Letters: Xi Jinping’s ending of two-term limits and Beijing’s intimidating tactics should make the world wary, says David YL Lin


09, Mar, 2018 @5:02 PM

Article image
Hong Kong crackdown reveals China’s fear of contagious rebellion
Xi Jinping’s hardline stance sends fear across Taiwan, Tibet and Xinjiang, where there are other challenges to monolithic rule

Simon Tisdall

01, Dec, 2014 @1:52 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on Taiwan’s election: an extraordinary comeback – then what? | Editorial
Editorial: Polls suggest President Tsai Ing-wen is heading for a second term. Beijing will not welcome the news


09, Jan, 2020 @6:58 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on Britain and China: fasten your seatbelts | Editorial
Editorial: The UK and other countries are reshaping their approach to Beijing. It’s going to be bumpy


09, Jul, 2020 @5:57 PM

Article image
Liu Xiaoming to quit his role of Chinese ambassador to Britain
Critic of UK decision to ban Huawei from 5G networks to be replaced by China’s vice-foreign minister

Patrick Wintour Diplomatic editor

27, Dec, 2020 @2:37 PM

Article image
China's leaders seeking to 'draw strength from weakness' in 2020
Faced with problems at home and abroad, Beijing will seek to boost nationalist sentiment by blaming foreign influences

Lily Kuo in Beijing

28, Dec, 2019 @5:00 AM

Article image
'Of course it's not ethical': shock at gene-edited baby claims
Chinese geneticist He Jiankui’s claim to have altered embryos prompts outcry from scientists

Suzanne Sataline in Hong Kong

27, Nov, 2018 @1:04 PM

Article image
A child screams in Myanmar … and China pretends not to hear
The country’s global standing is plunging as Xi Jinping attempts to whitewash atrocities in the name of empire-building

Simon Tisdall

14, Mar, 2021 @7:30 AM

Article image
‘Chairman Xi’ seeks only to purge and subjugate. That is his weakness | Simon Tisdall
From Tibet to Taiwan, China’s leader is intent on wielding absolute power. Instead he is fanning the flames of dissent

Simon Tisdall

06, Sep, 2020 @6:56 AM

Article image
Panda accused of faking pregnancy for more buns and bamboo was maligned
Claims that Ai Hin was faking pregnancy to get better treatment have been debunked by leading panda expert

Jonathan Kaiman in Beijing

28, Aug, 2014 @1:38 PM