End United Nations veto in mass atrocity cases, urges David Miliband

Former foreign secretary calls on Britain to back French proposal over UN Security Council powers

Britain must back calls for countries in the United Nations security council to give up their veto on cases of alleged mass atrocities, genocide and war crimes, the former foreign secretary David Miliband has said.

Miliband, now the president of the New York-based NGO, International Rescue Committee, said he supported a proposal from France that would suspend the power of the US, China, the UK, France and Russia to block action in these cases. He called on the foreign secretary, Liz Truss, to back the measure.

He said there was now a “system failure” in the international humanitarian system that had combined with the Covid pandemic and climate change to fuel unprecedented rises in global hunger, poverty and refugee numbers.

“I support the French proposal,” Miliband told the Observer. “The UK veto in the security council is a very powerful tool for the UK and the other permanent members of the security council. But in debates involving mass atrocity, the veto and threat of veto prevents diplomacy and fuels dangerous conflicts.

“I think the UK should support the French proposal, now supported by 100 other countries, to abandon the veto in the security council in cases of mass atrocity. In these cases, the veto and threat of veto does much more harm than good.”

The measure would avoid a repeat of situations in the past when Russia attempted to block UN investigations into chemical weapons attacks in Syria, and China prevented effective UN action against the Rohingya genocide in Myanmar. The French proposal has been co-signed by Mexico.

Russia has also used its veto in other areas. Last week, it used its veto against a UN security council resolution casting the climate crisis as a threat to international peace and security.

Russian ambassador Vassily Nebenzia raises his hand to veto a resolution casting climate change as a threat to international security
Russian ambassador Vassily Nebenzia raises his hand to veto a resolution casting climate change as a threat to international security. Photograph: Loey Felipe/AP

The vote sank a lengthy effort to make global heating more central to decision-making in the UN’s most powerful body, which had been championed by Ireland and Niger.

Miliband said use of the veto must be limited in the most serious cases.

“The veto is unjustifiable in cases of mass atrocity, and the threat of the veto strangles effective diplomacy in these cases,” said Miliband.

“The sidelining of the UN is a threat to global peace and security, and encourages the rise of impunity. If the UN security council was being created today, then the veto would not be granted to the five permanent members.

“But we cannot rewrite the past. We need a more effective security council today, not a thought experiment about yesterday.”


Michael Savage and Simon Tisdall

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Fresh fears for newborn babies as Rohingyas’ plight worsens
Aid agencies in camps are overwhelmed as family tragedies unfold on Myanmar’s border

Thaslima Begum, Ben Quinn and Millie Shields

16, Sep, 2017 @11:44 PM

Article image
United Nations withdraws Matt Hancock job offer
Former health secretary will no longer become special envoy for UN’s economic commission for Africa

James Tapper

16, Oct, 2021 @4:47 PM

Article image
David Miliband: we need a second vote on Brexit deal
Former Labour minister enters fray over Europe to urge fightback on ‘act of economic self-harm’

Jamie Doward

12, Aug, 2017 @8:30 PM

Article image
The Observer view on the world needing the United Nations more than ever
Seventy-five years after VE Day, the pandemic is a sharp reminder of the continuing need for tolerance and co-operation

Observer editorial

10, May, 2020 @5:00 AM

Article image
Migrant death toll expected to exceed 10,000 in 2016
Projected figures on migrant fatalities released as US prepares to host two major summits on refugee crisis

Mark Townsend and Tracy McVeigh

17, Sep, 2016 @8:07 PM

Article image
Russian ambassador pours scorn on Boris Johnson’s protest call
Diplomat says foreign secretary’s proposal shows weakness of Britain’s Syria policy

Daniel Boffey

15, Oct, 2016 @7:42 PM

Article image
Starving families in Aleppo fear ‘safe passage’ may be a trap
‘How can you trust a government that says you can come out safely but is bombing children and hospitals every day?’

Emma Graham-Harrison

30, Jul, 2016 @7:05 PM

Article image
Ukraine: what will China do? There are signs it is uneasy about Putin’s methods
Beijing has held off from backing Russia, raising questions about the extent of any partnership

Patrick Wintour

27, Feb, 2022 @7:15 AM

Article image
Russia's veto on Syria sidelines UN as diplomatic options run out

Ian Black: Moscow and Beijing's refusal leaves international community all but helpless in face of escalating violence

Ian Black, Middle East editor

04, Feb, 2012 @11:52 PM

Article image
UN sends warning to Assad as monitors prepare to leave for Syria
Unarmed observers ready to fly to Damascus within hours after security council authorises deployment

Peter Beaumont, foreign affairs editor

14, Apr, 2012 @8:00 PM