Covid: UK spent £569m on 20,900 ventilators but most remain unused

Government was right to prioritise speed over cost, says National Audit Office

The government spent £569m buying 20,900 ventilators to keep people alive during the Covid-19 pandemic but lack of demand means NHS hospitals have used just a few of them.

All but 2,150 of the machines it bought are still being held in a Ministry of Defence warehouse in case they are needed in the coming second wave of the disease.

That is the conclusion of a National Audit Office (NAO) investigation into the costs of ministers’ scramble to buy tens of thousands of mechanical ventilators in March and what it achieved.

Whitehall’s spending watchdog found that the Department of Health and Social Care (DHSC) and Cabinet Office paid a lot more than usual for the devices but were right to do so given the threat to life.

“The government acted with urgency to increase the number of ventilators available to the NHS. It prioritised speed over cost and spent a total of £569m. So far, most of these ventilators have not been needed,” says its report, which is published on Wednesday.

The DHSC tried to source most of the extra devices it was seeking from China. However, intense global demand meant it had to pay suppliers upfront, but without any assurance the ventilators would be high quality. In one case it spent £2.2m on 750 transport ventilators, which ended up not being used when doctors said they were unsuitable for patients in intensive care.

Despite both departments vigorously pursuing more of the machines from mid-March, they had only acquired 1,800 extra by the time the peak of the pandemic struck in mid-April.

And they missed the government target to increase the NHS’s stock of ventilators from only 7,400 at the start of the crisis to 18,000 by the end of April and 30,000 by the end of August.

However, no patient with Covid who needed to undergo mechanical ventilation had been left without one.

“In the event the new ventilators were not needed at the April peak because demand was considerably lower than the reasonable worst-case scenario,” the NAO said.

On 14 April, the day Covid admissions peaked in English hospitals, the NHS in England had 6,818 beds available with ventilators. However, just 2,849 were occupied by Covid patients, another 1,031 were taken by those with other ailments and the other 2,938 were empty.

“DHSC and NHS England and NHS Improvement are not aware of any point when a patient who needed a ventilator was unable to get one,” the NAO said.

The DHSC spent £292m in total, including £244m (excluding VAT) buying 11,100 ventilators and £45m on other oxygen therapy devices. As global competition for intensive care ventilators intensified it had to pay £30,100 for each one it acquired compared with the usual £20,000 cost.

The Cabinet Office spent £277m. However, £113m of that went on “design costs, components and factory capacity for ventilators it did not buy, including £11m for an order of 15,000 additional Penlon devices that was later cancelled”. It paid an average of £18,300 for each device it obtained through its “ventilator challenge” to British industry to design and build machines.

Meg Hillier, the MP who chairs the Commons public accounts committee, said: “The government was quick off the blocks when it seemed like there was a pressing need to increase the number of ventilators in the NHS.

“We were lucky the worst-case scenario didn’t come to pass before the extra ventilators had arrived. However, the NHS is now much better prepared for whatever happens next.

“DHSC and the Cabinet Office have shown it’s possible to work at pace and get results without writing a blank cheque. In this case they kept the chancers at arm’s-length and have set a benchmark for procurement during the pandemic.”

The DHSC was contacted for comment.

Contributor

Denis Campbell Health policy editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
UK manufacturers to export surplus medical ventilators
UK government initially called for 30,000 machines but NHS capacity was never stretched

Rob Davies

03, Jul, 2020 @11:01 PM

Article image
Private health firms in England to receive up to £525m to fight Omicron surge
Hospital operators agree deal to maintain services and ensure NHS does not become overwhelmed

Julia Kollewe

13, Jan, 2022 @2:50 PM

Article image
First batch of new NHS ventilators to be built this weekend
Regulatory approval expected for machine being adapted by Oxfordshire-based Penlon

Rob Davies

31, Mar, 2020 @4:56 PM

Article image
Treasury blocks plan for private hospitals to tackle NHS backlog
NHS bosses seek to finalise £5bn contract covering treatment including cancer surgery

Denis Campbell Health policy editor

18, Jun, 2020 @6:00 AM

Article image
Body parts scandal: serious questions remain, says Labour
Shadow health secretary says public should have been told earlier that NHS waste firm was amassing human remains

Heather Stewart Political editor

09, Oct, 2018 @6:37 PM

Article image
Liverpool Covid admissions will 'devastate' other hospital care
Non-urgent operations at risk unless infection and admission rates fall, top doctor says

Denis Campbell Health policy editor

15, Oct, 2020 @11:25 AM

Article image
UK doctors and health experts back Covid-19 'circuit breaker'
Medics favour series of short lockdowns ‘to buy time’ as chancellor Rishi Sunak says regional tiered action is best

Denis Campbell, Jessica Elgot and Heather Stewart

15, Oct, 2020 @7:13 AM

Article image
BAME Britons still lack protection from Covid, says doctors' chief
More than a third of coronavirus intensive care patients are from ethnic minorities

Haroon Siddique

20, Sep, 2020 @2:00 PM

Article image
Birmingham NHS trust halts planned surgery as Covid cases rise
Move could affect thousands of patients at Queen Elizabeth and Good Hope hospitals

Denis Campbell Health policy editor

06, Nov, 2020 @2:06 PM

Article image
Quarter of Covid hospital admissions in England aged under 55
NHS boss Sir Simon Stevens reveals figure as he tells MPs the virus is spreading out of control

Rajeev Syal

11, Jan, 2021 @7:27 PM