Big tech firms may be handing Hong Kong user data to China

Allegation follows new law that lets Hong Kong ask for sensitive data if deemed to threaten national security

Big technology companies may already be complying with secret Chinese requests for user information held in Hong Kong and ought to “come clean” about the vulnerability of the data they hold there, a senior US state department official has said.

The allegation of possible secret cooperation between major companies and Hong Kong authorities follows the implementation of a sweeping and controversial new national security law that allows Hong Kong authorities to demand sensitive user data from companies if it is deemed to threaten national security.

While some tech and social media companies, like Facebook, Google, and Microsoft, said in the immediate aftermath of the law being implemented in June that they would put a “pause” on complying with any Hong Kong data requests, interviews with activists, legal experts, and a current and former US government official have raised doubts about their ability to fend off such legal demands and their right to disclose if they have received them.

The state department official said: “There is a possibility that things are happening but because of the restrictions put on by the Hong Kong authorities, they [companies] would not be able to divulge this.”

The official added that if the request was “detoured” into the mainland legal system it would fall into a “black hole”.

“The company would be told by mainland authorities ‘you will be breaking the [law] if you reveal the fact that I’m asking for this information,’” the official said.

Facebook and Google did not respond to requests for comment.

Microsoft said: “As we would with any new legislation, we are reviewing the new law to understand its implications. In the past, we’ve typically received only a relatively small number of requests from Hong Kong authorities, but we are pausing our responses to these requests as we conduct our review.”

Microsoft declined to comment on the remarks by the state department official.

For Hong Kong activists like Glacier Kwong, who is living outside Hong Kong at the moment but is a vocal pro-democracy advocate, the threat of having her information turned over to Beijing is reminiscent of the 2004 incident in which Yahoo complied with a Chinese request for identifying information about the journalist Shi Tao after he used a Yahoo account to send information about how China was restricting coverage of the anniversary of the Tiananmen Square massacre to a human rights forum in the US.

Shi was arrested and spent nearly 10 years in prison as a result of Yahoo’s disclosure, an act that was later described by a US congressman as akin to corporate collaboration with Nazi Germany. Yahoo had also shared information about the dissident Wang Xiaoning, who had been posting his writings on Yahoo forums anonymously. The activist was sentenced to a decade in prison after he was identified. He was released in 2012 and Yahoo publicly apologised for the disclosures.

Kwong says it would create “huge problems” for her and fellow activists if their most “highly sensitive and intimate” data – collected over many years of using Facebook and Google – was handed to Beijing.

She said: “I don’t want to put it that way but I will. If Google or other technology companies comply with this national security law, it is actually helping indirectly the Hong Kong government, the Chinese government, to oppress or crack down on the civil society.”

Activists like Kwong are not calling for the companies to abandon Hong Kong, but said all companies ought to minimise the data they collect or store, and end to end encrypt the data that gives even the companies limited access to the information.

Another dissident, Yaxue Cao, who is based in Washington, said companies ought to remember the 2004 Yahoo case, and the reputational damage and lawsuit that Yahoo eventually had to settle with Chinese dissidents, as they navigate the new Hong Kong security law. But there was one major difference between then and now: neither Hong Kong nor China would likely now acknowledge in court, as China did in the Yahoo case, that it had obtained sensitive data from a major technology company.

“It will therefore be that much more important for the tech companies to be honest and to have integrity,” she said.

But one former US government official, who has discussed the issue with affected groups, said it would be problematic to rely on companies with a vested interest in expanding their business in China to essentially act as whistleblowers and reveal if they have been asked to turn over information.

“Within companies [the issue] is pretty well understood but companies want to keep it quiet, they want to keep it hush-hush, they want to make their own decisions about what is best for their business,” the person, who asked not to be identified because of possible repercussions, said. “To have data that is from south-east Asia, regional data, or data from Europe or the US, in Hong Kong, at this point , is just nuts. Or, at least, if you have it and don’t have a plan in the next year to get it out … then you’re either naive or you just don’t care.”

Contributor

Stephanie Kirchgaessner in Washington

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Hong Kong protesters go on trial as fight for democracy continues
Case highlights failure to honour promise of free elections, say campaigners

Suzanne Sataline in Hong Kong and agencies

18, Nov, 2018 @6:01 PM

Article image
Oxford moves to protect students from China's Hong Kong security law
Students will submit work related to China anonymously and told not to record classes

Patrick Wintour Diplomatic editor

28, Sep, 2020 @4:00 AM

Article image
Hong Kong bookseller Gui Minhai jailed for 10 years in China
Swedish citizen who went missing in 2015 sentenced for ‘providing intelligence’ abroad

Lily Kuo in Hong Kong

25, Feb, 2020 @10:45 AM

Article image
Beijing calls Hong Kong bar association chief an ‘anti-China politician’
Authorities lambast British-born Paul Harris for criticising treatment of pro-democracy campaigners

Helen Davidson in Taipei

27, Apr, 2021 @11:10 AM

Article image
After Hong Kong: China sets sights on solving 'the Taiwan problem'
An invasion may not be imminent but experts say armed forces could have capacity to mount one by 2028

Emma Graham-Harrison and Helen Davidson

02, Oct, 2020 @4:00 AM

Article image
Google shift to Hong Kong played down by US

Obama administration offers muted response to search giant's move in attempt to maintain China relations

Ewen MacAskill in Washington

23, Mar, 2010 @6:52 PM

Article image
Hong Kong democracy campaigners jailed over anti-China protests
Alex Chow, Nathan Law, and Joshua Wong given six to eight month sentences for roles in anti-government occupation known as the umbrella movement

Tom Phillips in Beijing

17, Aug, 2017 @8:27 AM

Article image
Hong Kong court bans pro-independence politicians from office
Yau Wai-ching and Baggio ‘Sixtus’ Leung banned from parliament after criticising China during swearing-in ceremony

Benjamin Haas in Hong Kong

15, Nov, 2016 @1:28 PM

Article image
'In my dreams I'm there': the exodus from Hong Kong
Beijing’s national security law has prompted the exit of people from all walks of life in fear they or their children are at risk

Guardian reporter in Hong Kong

01, Oct, 2020 @1:00 AM

Google angers China by shifting service to Hong Kong
Internet giant makes bold move after two-month standoff over web censorship with Beijing

Tania Branigan in Beijing

23, Mar, 2010 @7:58 AM